Yes, I know. I was agreeing with you and providing evidence. Here is the only official docuмent signed by John XXIII regarding the 1962 update of the Missal:
https://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/es/motu_proprio/docuмents/hf_j-xxiii_motu-proprio_19600725_rubricarum-instructum.html
It was referred to as an update to the "rubrics" only. Definitely not mentioning any change to "the Roman Canon."
Dear Angelus and Pax Vobis,
"It pertains exclusively to the Holy See to control sacred liturgy and to approve liturgical books (c.1257)" L. Bouscaren S.J, A.C Ellis S.J "Canon Law, A Text and Commentary", 1958.
"58. It follows from this that the Sovereign Pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish any practice touching the worship of God, to introduce and approve new rites, as also to modify these he judges to require modification." Pope Pius XII "Mediator Dei".
Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli, born 25 Nov 1881, died 3 June 1963.
The date of the Decretum authorizing insertion of the name of St. Joseph into the Canon is 13 Nov 1962.
There is no way the Pope was not aware of it. He did not reverse it, he therefore authorized it. If you can prove that he was nonresponsive from 13 Nov 1962, until 3 June 1963, the guilt will be transferred onto his Successor.
For now, objectively, Pope John XXIII is under anathema of Trent. Let him be anathema. "Anathema sit" is iussive subjunctive, and it is directed to any soul alive, not only to clergy or popes. The curse is the source of our confusion. Until its source is removed, we will just keep arguing with each other. The good part is that we learn our religion, which will help us learn our Faith.
If the 1962 liturgy was never promulgated by the Pope, it is certainly illicit and should not be used. Either way, why is SSPX and the Resistance (in agreement with Fr. Ratzinger) adamant about using the affected book? Is the law of self defense a good reason? Why did Abp. Lefebvre make such a terrible concession?
Topic: Red Alert! Are the Sedevacantists the Only True Followers of Abp. Lefebvre? (Read 23708 times)