Author Topic: Quis Threatens to Shut Down FE Subforum & Ban Theological Topics (Read 3899 times)

CM · « **Reply #15 on:** October 14, 2009, 12:12:16 AM »

:devil2:Fisheaters :devil2: sounds like the place to go for a stroll down the broad path.

At least here there is open discussion between Catholics and non-Catholics in the hopes of converting souls to God.

Chant, good example in Antipope Augustine. I have always seen him as a very intelligent person, but his positions change like a reed in the wind, yet he's always ready with an anathema for you if you disagree with him -- even though he's most likely going to disagree with himself in a matter of weeks.

stevusmagnus · « **Reply #16 on:** October 14, 2009, 12:34:44 AM »

Quote from: ChantCd

Just read the missives of "Pope Augustine" -- the layman who still has a day job but considers himself pope (he said he's found the Great Monarch, and yesterday he said he's going to canonize Christopher Columbus.) The man clearly has some natural intelligence -- but he's gone off into his own world -- he's completely mad.

Matthew

Indeed. Quis reminds me of Herod in the Passion movie. The FE posters are those all around him mired in sin, but completely loyal to Herod because he has the power. They are all drunk off the wine, laughing, committing immorality.

Christ is brought in. He just looks at him with pity. Herod knows he is a sinner. Christ's stare convicts him, but he denies the chance to redeem himself. Herod interrogates Christ but He is silent. Herod uses it as a pretext to mock him and send him on his way. He "bans" Christ from his presence and the party continues.

Also, fittingly, Herod was the same guy who beheaded John the Baptist for publicly protesting the scandal of his divorce and remarriage.

Raoul76 · « **Reply #17 on:** October 14, 2009, 12:51:41 AM »

ChantCD said:

Quote

It's part of the Hegelian dialectic:

Catholicism (thesis)
Modern world (antithesis)
Vatican II (synthesis)

then, we have
Catholicism, traditional (thesis)
Vatican II Catholicism (antithesis)
Neo-traditionalism (synthesis)

It's just another step.

I wrote a post about this, didn't put it up yet.

You understand the system very well, Matthew. Puzzling to me that you are in SSPX. The point of my post was that the synthesis is always a false conservatism allowed by the Modernists to make people think they are really conservative.

The Synthesis SEEMS Catholic but is usually relative morality. It is moral relative to the perverted modern world, but it still not Catholic.

I had this one about NFP:

Thesis: Catholic marriage is primarily for procreation, secondarily to pay the debt

Antithesis: Abortion and birth control are great goods for an overpopulated world

SYNTHESIS: The rhythm method is non-procreative but not anti-procreative

The Hegelian dialectic is fun!

stevusmagnus · « **Reply #18 on:** October 14, 2009, 01:05:19 AM »

Hey Raoul,

Here is one for you. Quis has said it is not heretical to believe, as a Catholic, that God plucks souls out of Hell.

Thoughts?

stevusmagnus · « **Reply #19 on:** October 14, 2009, 01:25:32 AM »

Apparently the Pope doesn't agree...

http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/news/story.html?id=626f4f93-9e33-4339-b61c-b94535beab36

Author Topic: Quis Threatens to Shut Down FE Subforum &amp; Ban Theological Topics (Read 3899 times)

Author Topic: Quis Threatens to Shut Down FE Subforum & Ban Theological Topics (Read 3899 times)