Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.  (Read 51377 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Meg

Re: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.
« Reply #25 on: November 13, 2024, 03:37:03 PM »
Pretty sure that's a Banable offence as per the sign up page.

It is a banable offense. For some reason, Matthew is allowing Nishant Xavier to keep posting, but he hasn't said why. Though maybe he has said why, and I missed it. Perhaps Matthew has grown weary of continually banning this guy, and is maybe hoping that we will talk some sense into him.  Though Nishant Xavier never, ever admits that he is wrong, or that he could be wrong, about anything. Perhaps he believes that he is a prophet of God, and therefore above reproach? There's no humility there at all. Does he realize this? Maybe not. If he has mental problems, then that would explain a lot. 

Re: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.
« Reply #26 on: November 13, 2024, 04:02:48 PM »
It is a banable offense. For some reason, Matthew is allowing Nishant Xavier to keep posting, but he hasn't said why. Though maybe he has said why, and I missed it. Perhaps Matthew has grown weary of continually banning this guy, and is maybe hoping that we will talk some sense into him.  Though Nishant Xavier never, ever admits that he is wrong, or that he could be wrong, about anything. Perhaps he believes that he is a prophet of God, and therefore above reproach? There's no humility there at all. Does he realize this? Maybe not. If he has mental problems, then that would explain a lot.
MarkM's name was changed, but I'm not sure what that means.


Offline Meg

Re: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.
« Reply #27 on: November 13, 2024, 04:08:08 PM »
MarkM's name was changed, but I'm not sure what that means.

I'm not sure either, but maybe Matthew just wants MarkM to admit that he is a retread - and that he is actually Nishant Xavier. Admitting that one has done something wrong is part of the battle for truth. 

Re: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.
« Reply #28 on: November 13, 2024, 04:25:17 PM »
Do you have a point?  You think you're doxing me or something, you malicious heretic?  While I have referred to this letter myself before, your obvious intention to dox out of malice should result in your immediate banning.  You will be reported for this.  You feign sanctimonious piety all the time, but it's a lie just like everything else you post.  I'm also going to go on X and call you out for malicious doxing on another forum to show your "followers" who you really are.

Not sure how many times I've had to explain to your low-IQ and/or dishonest brain that I'm a sedeprivationist and not a sedevancantist.  I've referred to this letter before and explained its history.  I wrote this as a letter to a friend who had asked me why I had backed away from straight sedevacantism.  This was never intended for publication but somehow got over to The Angelus and they published it without my permission or knowledge ... and even made some edits, including some faulty translations.  It didn't even have my name on it, which they added ... but spelled wrong.  They knew where I was and could have easily reached out to me.

In any case, this started me on my journey away from SVism toward sedeprivationism.  Interestingly, then-Father Sanborn, whom I had left just before this I wrote this, ended up in the same place by a different route.  You'll notice that this is not an endorsement of R&R, which The Angelus took it to be, engaging in false dichotomy, something you do all the time, just an expression of my difficulties with straight SVism, which was in fact my original title, or, rather, subject line,  ... which I still hold to and continue to argue when I debate straight SVs on CI here.
Yeahhh, I've seen you refer to this before. And this letter plus your other writing on this topic has been almost instrumental to helping me understand the crisis AND putting the matter to rest for me personally, thereby easing my conscience.
Lots of others take issue with what you say on this topic but I have learned a ton from you and I'm grateful. I am one of the few Sedeprivationist/SV I know and your explanations made it so much easier for me to talk(and get along) with other Traditional Catholics that do not see things the same way. 

You are appreciated here on the forum. Just want to tell you that, man. 👍

God bless you.

Re: Pope Sifting - Difficulties with Sedevacantism from Angelus 1995.
« Reply #29 on: November 13, 2024, 04:56:28 PM »
I'm not sure either, but maybe Matthew just wants MarkM to admit that he is a retread - and that he is actually Nishant Xavier. Admitting that one has done something wrong is part of the battle for truth.
Looks like he's gone (banned) as there's no NishantXavier either.