I believe that if the Resistance could assure Father Carley that his faithful would be cared for ... Father Carley is very much of the Resistance mindset, has absolutely no use whatsoever for any relations or dialog with the Conciliar Church, etc.  One thing the Resistance might do in attempting to persuade Father Carley would be to tell him that the SSPX could easily send a priest there who was ordained Novus Ordo and not conditionally ordained ... since I know that Father Carley holds NO Orders to be outright invalid.  I think that the subtle theological arguments about R&R vs. SV, etc., would go over his head and not register, but the point about doubtful NO Holy Orders making into his chapel would be very persuasive.  This was actually not an issue at the time that I resigned from the Board of Trustees, since that was, heck, back when Bishop Williamson was still with the SSPX ... and I haven't spoken to Father about the SSPX in a very long time.  Also, the Resistance could point out things like the SSPX holding confirmations in NO churches, having the Sacrament of Matrimony being approved/witnessed by Novus Ordo prelates ... those things would make a solid impression on him.