CathInfo.com

Quo vadis, Taylor Marshall? Quo vadis, John-Henry Westen? Quo vadis, Michael Matt? Quo vadis, Robert Moynihan? Are you going to put your money where your mouth is and follow Vigano into schism? Or are you going to apologize for supporting him and leading your followers into the sin which got him excommunicated?

But did these people actually support him? If they did, I thought they only did so until it was clear Vigano didn't believe Bergoglio was the pope.

God is revealing the people you should avoid.  Why waste time with Michael Jones?  What we should be doing is talking to others about the true faith. 

  
Maybe you should explain why efforts to convert E. Michael Jones is a "waste (of) time"? Has God revealed this to you? Instructing the ignorant is a spiritual work of mercy that all Catholics are obligated when possible. What is evident is that you have not read the OPEN LETTER and I think it is inadvisable to enter a discussion that you have not made a preliminary examination.
 
The OPEN LETTER has been sent Dr. Jones and to the those that Dr. Jones identifies as the "Guild Prophets", that is, to Dr. Robert Moynihan, editor of Inside the Vatican, Dr. Taylor Marshall, a professional apologist, John-Henry Westen, editor of Life Site News, and lastly, Michael Matt, editor of the Remnant Newspaper. The four are conservative Catholics with traditional sentiments. They were accused by Dr. Jones of shamelessly defending Archbishop Viganò and leading their followers into schism. He has challenged them to publicly repudiate Archbishop Viganò and call upon their followers to do the same. Jones asks them if they are with Pope Francis in the Church or with Archbishop Viganò outside the Church. He reminds them that there is no salvation outside the Church.
 
Dr. Jones and the Guild Prophets share a common error: they hold the pope as their proximate rule of faith. They believe that the pope is the primary and essential cause and sign of unity in the Church. This is a grave error. My hope is that Dr. Jones will enter this exchange with the Guild Prophets for the purpose of bringing those in error back to truth.
 
In an ongoing and open defense of the Catholic faith in the Diocese of hαɾɾιsburg, I and members of Ss. Peter & Paul Roman Catholic Mission have been accused by the last five bishops of being schismatic. We have repeatedly asked the bishops to make formal canonical charges that permit an open and public defense. Lacking that, that they at least engaged themselves or their appointed representatives to enter a public written debate on the question. This has been going on for nearly 25 years and we have heard nothing in reply other than the repeated calumny of schism. I am happy to say that the majority of our members have been converted from the Novus Ordo by our public letters to hαɾɾιsburg and to Rome.
 
Dr. Jones professes to be an expert on the question of schism. I know that he is ignorant on the matter and his ignorance is long standing. The Guild Prophets are challenged by Dr. Jones to remain in the conservative Catholic fold or become sedecavantists. It is an utterly false option.
 
Lastly, Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò deserves to be defended against his detractors. The Guild Prophets are at the crossroads and they need encouragement to defend the Catholic faith.
 
Drew

11. Dogma is the proximate rule of faith for all the faithful.

Dogma is the matter of the proximate rule of faith; the form is the infallible teacher (Pope, council, etc) who proposes it for belief.  Without the infallible teacher (form) there is no matter (dogma) for belief.  I requires both.  The Pope/council is the form of the proximate rule of faith; the docrine infallibly proposed is the matter.