Do you realize that there are some Sedevacantists who consider all other Traditional Catholics to be non-Catholic? They really consider themselves to be in a different religion. Not compared to the Conciliar Church, mind you (for which an argument could certainly be made!) but compared with SSPX, Resistance, and any other non-Sedevacantist group.
I just got an "unsubscribe" request today for my Gregorian chant CD business. His reason for unsubscribing?
Here is my response:
Can I ask how a piece of traditional, pre-Vatican II Gregorian chant can have an opinion or position on the Pope question?
Chant is chant. Do statuary, rosaries, altar linens, and other Catholic merchandise have to be sedevacantist/non-sedevacantist as well?
I bet you $50 you couldn't tell a sedevacantist recording of "Jesu dulcis memoria" from a non-sedevacantist one.
It seems to me that certain things, like pre-Vatican II Catholic books (i.e., the old TAN Books) and Gregorian Chant qualify as "neutral" in all the controversies in the Traditional movement...