Author Topic: Krah chose Williamsons lawyer (Read 36743 times)

ServusSpiritusSancti · « **Reply #50 on:** December 02, 2010, 04:38:40 PM »

Quote from: Emerentiana

LABELS! LABELS! What, pray tell us Spiritus is EXTREME Sedevacantism?

I hardly classify myself as an extremist. The CMRI, whos congregation Ive been associated with for over 40 years, state that
Valid Priests say valid masses
We can go to any valid mass
We simply believe that the Chair is Vacant in Rome, but that there are valid priests and bishops throughout the world.

Some sede groups have become "cultish". They think they are the only SEDE group out there! They are STILL simply SEDES....... with a warped prospective! No papal authority is there to tell them differently.
The Vatican imposter says Bishop williamson is not a "Catholic in the true sense", and the SSPX are schizmatic. Those are his pronouncements.
Then you have the SSPX calling the Sedes schizmatic!!!!!!! Everyone crowing and fingerpointing! If it wasnt so serious, it would be hilarious.
SSPX is SO afraid to loose its members......less money to give Bishop Fellay for his "investments"
:pop:

Did I say you were an extremist? No. Extreme sedevacanism is sedevacanism taken to a much higher level. Extreme sedes believe that numerous Popes were anti-popes and also go nuts over the anti-pope debate. An extremist is someone like CM or AntiClimax.

Matthew · « **Reply #51 on:** December 02, 2010, 04:47:34 PM »

Then there are the dogmatic Sedevacantists --

Those who believe that if you set foot in a non-sedevacantist chapel, you might as well be attending a protestant service. You are a sellout and possibly a heretic.

They think that attending a Mass where the 1962 Missal is used --or Benedict XVI's name is uttered -- makes you odious to God.

They believe that "the See is vacant" is another dogma of the Catholic Faith -- just like the Incarnation, perpetual virginity of Mary, or the Particular Judgment.

Such people are NOT sanguine about people making other choices in this Crisis -- in fact, they often condemn fellow Sedevacantists who are not "dogmatic" about it as they are.

Needless to say, such people are not welcome on CathInfo.

Caminus · « **Reply #52 on:** December 02, 2010, 06:57:28 PM »

http://truerestoration.blogspot.com/2010/02/das-ist-geschehen-responding-to-herr.html

It seems this has already been covered back in February.

Emerentiana · « **Reply #53 on:** December 02, 2010, 07:32:32 PM »

Quote from: SpiritusSanctus

Quote from: Emerentiana
LABELS! LABELS! What, pray tell us Spiritus is EXTREME Sedevacantism?

I hardly classify myself as an extremist. The CMRI, whos congregation Ive been associated with for over 40 years, state that
Valid Priests say valid masses
We can go to any valid mass
We simply believe that the Chair is Vacant in Rome, but that there are valid priests and bishops throughout the world.

Some sede groups have become "cultish". They think they are the only SEDE group out there! They are STILL simply SEDES....... with a warped prospective! No papal authority is there to tell them differently.
The Vatican imposter says Bishop williamson is not a "Catholic in the true sense", and the SSPX are schizmatic. Those are his pronouncements.
Then you have the SSPX calling the Sedes schizmatic!!!!!!! Everyone crowing and fingerpointing! If it wasnt so serious, it would be hilarious.
SSPX is SO afraid to loose its members......less money to give Bishop Fellay for his "investments"
:pop:

Did I say you were an extremist? No. Extreme sedevacanism is sedevacanism taken to a much higher level. Extreme sedes believe that numerous Popes were anti-popes and also go nuts over the anti-pope debate. An extremist is someone like CM or AntiClimax.

I gottcha!............however.....they are still sedes. That group are extreme independent thinkers who have gone into the abyss because they wont listen to priests, but will listen to "lay popes" interpretations.
Sedes are not confused for the most part. They KNOW whats going on in the Church, and that we are in the great apostacy predicted by St Paul!

Good post!

ServusSpiritusSancti · « **Reply #54 on:** December 05, 2010, 08:20:31 PM »

Quote from: Matthew

Then there are the dogmatic Sedevacantists --

Those who believe that if you set foot in a non-sedevacantist chapel, you might as well be attending a protestant service. You are a sellout and possibly a heretic.

They think that attending a Mass where the 1962 Missal is used --or Benedict XVI's name is uttered -- makes you odious to God.

They believe that "the See is vacant" is another dogma of the Catholic Faith -- just like the Incarnation, perpetual virginity of Mary, or the Particular Judgment.

Such people are NOT sanguine about people making other choices in this Crisis -- in fact, they often condemn fellow Sedevacantists who are not "dogmatic" about it as they are.

Needless to say, such people are not welcome on CathInfo.

Basically dogmatic and extreme sedevacanism is the same thing, I just choose to call it extreme. I agree with you, though.