I think one of the keys to understanding this dilemma is the idea that the carnal, unbelieving Jєωs that had broken themselves off from the Covenant have been transformed down through history into the Gentile, thus presenting the inverse of ancient Israel. Thus, if these Jєωs "falsely so-called" have become the Nations and all error and corruption in the world can be traced back to Jєωιѕн perfidity, it would explain why they form the ѕуηαgσgυє of Satan. And simply because they make the claim to be Jєωs is apparently enough to refer to them as such, even though no substantial identity exists. With regard to the continued punishment of Deicide, it would be found in their naturalism, those claiming the Jєωιѕн name, would receive the particular manifestation of Divine Justice, whereas the rest of the world, the Nations, have become blind and thus share in the work of the Jєωs. Furthermore, since the term 'Jєω' is practically impossible to define, it thus remains indestructible down through the centuries precisely because it has come to mean everything and nothing at all. In the end, it will not be those who are known as Jєωs that convert, but the Nations, that is, many people of different Nations will convert to the Catholic faith near the end of time. I think this is the significance of Russia in the revelations of Fatima. Meanwhile, those who claim to form "Israel" who claim to be "Jєωs" will be misled by the Anti-Christ as foretold by the Fathers and Scripture. Thus, there is no retrograde reference to carnal Israel since it was dead and buried 2,000 years ago. I am currently reviewing this theory in light of St. Paul's statements in Romans. Any thoughts?