Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV  (Read 9774 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV
« on: August 22, 2013, 07:25:46 AM »
Apart from them being sedevacante believers.

is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV
« Reply #1 on: August 22, 2013, 08:11:30 AM »
Not to detract from SSPV..  But , you asked.

On the back of their bulletins , they have the requirements for reception of Holy Communion.  

One Cannot hold to not believing in Baptism of Desire (No acceptance)

One must not come to the altar rail if you are going to "Schismatic Priests"
I think that is another  way of saying , "Thuc" line Priests.  

And of course , you have to be practicing exclusively the Traditional Faith,
No Novus Ordo , back and forth.

Seems its ok to be coming from SSPX Mass s , as they don t mention that in their bulletin.  

Best to give the Chapel s a call and talk to one of the Priests, these requirements may have changed.

Dedicated Group, Great bunch of Sisters. Good Schools for the younger families.


is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV
« Reply #2 on: August 22, 2013, 08:55:31 AM »
The only thing I specifically know about the SSPV is that they do refuse communion to anyone who accepts the Thuc line priests and bishops.  I do not understand their objections as their objections are weak and have been very adequately refuted many times.

The CMRI does not refuse communion to any Catholic in the state of grace.

is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV
« Reply #3 on: August 22, 2013, 09:30:56 AM »
I attended Catholic schools my entire life and I can honestly say CMRI has never taught or said anything different than the Roman Catholic Church I was brought up in.  I was born in 1940 so I had a taste of the True Church before being led into the novus ordo, and through the grace of God brought right back where I started from through CMRI, remnant of Roman Catholic church.  

CMRI does not believe in refusing the sacraments, unless the priest knows without a doubt the person is not Catholic and never has been one.  This is what I was taught prior to Vatican II as well.  

The sermons from CMRI are exactly the same as what I was taught, including belief in BOD and BOB, just different persons (priests) giving them. As a child growing up in the Roman Catholic church, it was stressed we can not judge the soul of another person at death, as CMRI teaches.  Which is why they do not judge at the Communion rail, just because a stranger comes to Mass.  

Even prior to Vatican II, persons received Communion unworthy, this has always been an abuse, which is why in the Bible we are warned when we receive Our Lord, we will be judged according to the disposition of our soul.
 
All the other groups, traditional, have little defects within them that are foreign to the way I was taught in the Church.  A good example from SSPX; it was unheard of to speak from the pulpit about bad deeds from the Holy Father, as SSPX believes he is, and yet they speak about him in such a way; and from the pulpit no less, they have no respect for the office he holds (according to their belief about him).  

SSPV, refusing sacraments just because they do not know the person, or do not approve what Mass he has been attending, as if they are God themselves, judging souls of good willed people, and by whose authority, I would like to know.

CMRI is willing to face the facts about what is going on, and face the truth that Masons, Commies, and Protestants should not only be refused Communion but they also can not be popes.  Therefore CMRI is not lukewarm which is the opposite of having a holy zeal for saving souls, the first mission of the Church of Christ.  They are not afraid to tell it as it is. Tcat, if you want the Truth and think you can live with the Truth, talk to a CMRI priest.  

is there anything I should know about the CMRI and SSPV
« Reply #4 on: August 22, 2013, 11:55:26 AM »
I was watching a conference on the youtube channel "sedevideos"
It was a conference of sedevacante clergy back in 1991.
The CMRI bishop present said that you can go to SSPX if there is nothing else available, but that they don't recommend it.
I never heard of the SSPV before, but one priest from the SSPV was there (but in the video you cant see him) and he said that their position is that someone cannot go to CMRI because of some situation where some bishop who was schismatic back in 1910 started a line of bishops and that there are priests in CMRI who were ordained by a bishop who was ordained by a bishop in schkism.

The CMRI priest says that cannon law says that the excommunication does not pass "from father to son" and that just because the original skismztic was something called "Old Catholic" that he could still consecrate others.

Very interesting but I fear these groups are only in the US and not near me.
The only trad group is the SSPX, and if I would get trad Catholicism from joining them I would join one of their monasteries if I could.