A person responds from his knowledge base. Study the difference in your response and PereJoseph's. A good dog is never too old to learn new tricks.
I am treating you with the same courtesy or lack of that you give me and others. If you want a real discussion, stop acting like a fool.
I said nothing about you being discourteous. You respond from your knowledge base, with what you know, you are frustrated because you don't know the subject so you resort to name calling. If you had something to contribute you would have said it, as PereJoseph did.
There is no name calling, I do not know you, maybe you do not act this way elsewhere, but on here, you are all over the map.
Since you hold Nishant and PereJoseph in so high of a regard, why do you fail to learn anything from them? Why do you look to the boys in upstate New York as teachers? What credentials do they have to teach on a matters of Faith?
I am not a theologian, I am a layman just like you, Bowler. The difference between us is that I learn my Faith from those authorized to teach me. Myrna, SJB and others keep giving you sources approved by the Church, and you keep ignoring them. I could do the same, but why waste my time?
If you want to learn about this subject in depth, you should be reading Msgr. Fenton. His writings can be found all over the web, but most are on the Bellarmine Forum library. He was a real theologian, who had the training, expertise, and approval from the Church to explain matters of theology.