CathInfo.com

The Church has rules and practice around all this.
Honest people can look them up and use their common sense.
Stop trying to gaslight people just because you have been exposed.

So how did you determine that +Lefebvre act of disobedience and causing a break from the Novus Ordo church a valid thing to do?  It is not correct to consecrate bishops for the Catholic church without a Papal mandate.  If we are really going to be honest with ourselves then doesn't that make his line doubtful, too?  

Maybe I am over simplifying it?

God knows exactly what is going on, we really shouldn't let our emotions get the best of us.  (Telling that to myself, but maybe others needs to hear it.)

There are degrees of insanity.
And the judgment as to his is a cuмulative one.

Thuc cultists try to hair split, but normal people see right through it.

You're all angry because you have had it good here on cathinfo for far too long.And no one has been calling out your nonsense.


All the mental gymnastics you make to yourselves about his intention, does not change the facts of what he did. And his fruits. You can never escape that, not matter how much gaslighting,bullying and posturing you all do.

Your logical fallacies are so stupid that they don’t even make sense.  Because +Thuc made a few mistakes (novus ordo and Palmar) you ASSUME he made these same mistakes every.single.time.  Thats the most retarded logic I’ve ever heard.  

Not only is there NO EVIDENCE for it, but that’s not how humans act.  NO ONE IS THAT CONSISTENT IN ACTIONS OVER 30 YEARS, unless one is very evil or a very holy.  

The only way for your fairytale to be true (that every +Thuc consecration is gravely doubtful) would be if +Thuc was a mastermind who infiltrated Tradition with the express purpose of providing doubtful sacraments.  The problem with this is, if he’s a mastermind, then he certainly can’t be insane, so your #1 charge is proven wrong.  

Your fantasy, than +Thuc was insane for MANY DECADES and HUNDREDS of clerics don’t know (or did know, and cooperated with him), is so outlandish and inconceivable, that I wonder if YOU ARENT INSANE.  It would mean that every +Thuc cleric is part of the infiltration and conspiring together.  

Of course, none of that is true.  There were many letters posted (including by Fr Cekada) where +Thuc was interviewed and nobody came away saying he was mentally insane.  

You’ve not thought this through because you’re only reacting emotionally.  You need to stop GRAVELY SLANDERING HUNDREDS OF CLERICS.  Or you’ll be guilty before God for your hatred.  

Don't you know that our Tom has a special grace whereby he alone can determine what is valid and what is doubtful?
Alas, not to worry, he will continue to spam his weighty opinion on the matter ad nauseam

I really think it would be nice to have that grace.  It would surely make this whole crisis easier to endure.