Having read this purported "refutation" it's clear that it is merely more of the same obfuscation typical of TFP/TIA.
Nowhere is the key point addressed: that Atila laid on the floor in front of Plinio, who put his foot on Atila's neck, and Atila (in a mockery of Louis de Montfort's consecration to the Blessed Virgin Mary) swore his allegiance to Plinio, making himself a slave to Plinio and taking a slave name.
Disgusting and more importantly NOT Catholic, once again affirming what Bishop Mayer said of TFP, calling them an anti-Catholic, anti-clerical, heretic sect.

Official refutation: https://traditioninaction.org/Library/texts/A_001_ServCar.pdf?fbclid=IwAR1rRuucbL9eSBU5Sb2qBD8g_aAUI6xUNyaCCahfs7k_G4FCxta3sRrLeT4

...
From all this it was concluded that it could not be truthfully said that slavery to Dr. Plinio Corrêa de Oliveira exists de facto in the TFP.

This is for various reasons:

1. Because any temporal slavery is absolutely unthinkable;

2. Because the disciples who made the vow of obedience viewed their vow as laymen in the Church generally consider it - without special reference to religious "slavery;

3. Because the only ones who made a consecration as "slaves" to the Blessed Virgin with him as intermediary did not confer to him de facto any greater power than that which a director has over those he directs. In addition to this, such a consecration lost its effectiveness in the family of souls of the TFP.

Having said this, it would be a show of bad faith and a flagrant injustice to manipulate the words "slavery" and "slave" to give the understanding that the family of souls of the TFP would have returned to those dark pagan times when it was not considered that every man is made in the image and likeness of God and that all that one does for the most humble who occupies the lowest places on the social scale is the same as if one does it for Christ Our Lord Himself (Mt. 25:45).

Having closed this work with the idea that helping the lesser is the glory of the greater and the outstanding characteristic of the harmony of Christian Civilization, it is impossible for the one who writes this work not to relate this idea to all the assistance that the great founder of the family of souls of the TFP, Dr. Plinio Corrêa de Oliveira, gives to each one of those whom the grace has called to participate in his most high and most ardent vocation, even though they be weak and small. How many weaknesses sustained by his firm hand, how many defects cured by his efficacious remedies, how many shortcomings transcended by his continuous support, how many thirsts for good and justice satiated by limpid waters of confidence, how much hunger for truth filled at the banquet table of orthodoxy!

How can one consider so many favors without returning thanks? And how to return thanks without asking pardon for that which was not done?

But, over and above the expressions of gratitude and the pardons, a joy fills the spirit of the members of the family of souls of the TFP: It is the joy that, at least in one, Our Lady was duly served and glorified. It was in that one who, meriting to be the master of all, served all (1 Cor. 9:19) in order to be the true "slave" of She who was the "Slave of the Lord" (Luke 1:38). And serving all, he conquers all, because the epic grandeur of his vocation, humiliating himself even to the level of the smallness of each one, reveals in his souls such a dedication and meekness that it moves the good in those who still have even a Catholic fiber in their hearts.42 (42).

To the founder of the family of souls of the TFP, to the director of the Counter-Revolution, to my father,43 to my master, to my lord, rendered here is the samll homage of one who should have served much more.

Atila Sinke Guimarães São Paulo, September 1, 1984

I'm new here

Thank you for the friendly welcome - uh, was that what it was?

I post frequently an another forum, but it doesn't use the same BBcodes/quoting mechanism. That's no reason to poke fun at my post.

Thank you for the friendly welcome - uh, was that what it was?

I post frequently an another forum, but it doesn't use the same BBcodes/quoting mechanism. That's no reason to poke fun at my post.

I find it suspicious your very first post was a polemic against Dr. Plinio and Atila... That is why I made my comment.

 I have also met Marian Horvat when she gave a talk here and found her very intelligent.