Which poster do the CA rank and file regulars find the most troubling: Poche, Jayne, or Greg? I have entertained myself over the years watching some here go apoplectic over the aforementioned posters. Are Jayne and Greg banned as well?
poche, is that you?

No, the decision wasn't based on the fact that people went "apoplectic" over something. Apoplexy, as you put it, often simply has to do with the issue at hand. So, for instance, JayneK mixed it up with flat earthers and also took a position regarding the discipline of wives that some strongly disagreed with, and these can be hot-button issues.
I know of two posters here who irritate me much more than poche ever did, but I've never called for them to be banned since they have done nothing that was objectively ban-worthy. Getting under my skin because of how they think or post, etc., is not worthy of a ban. Out of charity, I won't name them here, but they probably know who they are. Neither of them have lied and distorted and also promoted error/heresy condemned by the Church. Nor have Jayne or Greg.