I was banned from FE maybe 9-10 months after I started CathInfo -- so it was sometime in 2007.
It's been a LONG time, so weeks go by without even thinking about Fisheaters now. I'll admit that wasn't always so. It used to be the largest Traditional Catholic forum, and even the banned members kept half an eye on it from time to time. But who can say that with a "straight" face now? (pardon the pun)
It's gone so far downhill, at some point
A) all real Trads absolutely have to leave
B) you have to stop even considering it a Trad forum
All joking aside, and in all honesty, I've stopped considering Fisheaters to be my competition a long time ago. I don't consider Catholic Answers to be competition either. In both cases, anyone who belongs on those forums certainly wouldn't belong on or enjoy CathInfo. Just like a fancy restaurant ($50 or more for a meal, serving wine, everyone dressed up) doesn't consider McDonald's to be its competition, even though they both technically serve food.
First of all, if the most conservative members there are "Indult" Catholics, then it's not a Trad forum. I barely consider Indult Trads to be Traditional Catholics, since they don't believe the number one basic principle of a Traditional Catholic: "Catholics have a right by virtue of their baptism to doubt-free Sacraments and doubt-free priests. The Novus Ordo is dangerous to the Faith. Therefore it is licit and even required to disobey any authority, including the Pope, which suggests we place our faith in danger by making use of doubtful priests/sacraments and dangerous liturgy".
So although I disagree with both Indult Catholics as well as Sedevacantists, at least Sedes qualify as Traditional Catholic. Indult Catholics, if they believe they have to have permission to attend the Latin Mass (they only attend Masses "in union with Rome"), are to be called Conservative Catholics.
If Catholic forums were liturgy, Fisheaters would have people dancing in the aisles, clown Masses, and rock music playing during Mass by now.
Any frogs still in that pot are fully dead and boiled, ready for the table.
Fisheaters is now Catholic Answers with a thin veneer of "supporting the Latin Mass". But get dogmatic and objective about any Catholic dogmas or morality, and you're likely to get in trouble! Perhaps Catholic Answers is more conservative than Fisheaters in some ways now.