Get rid of this guy, Matthew.
He's serving no good purpose here. He's just a Motarian preaching religious indifferentism and constantly attacking Traditional Catholics. And he's totally self-serving. He distorts and cherry-picks information out of context in order to work R&R members of the forum up against sedevacantists, but then condemns the principles of R&R. He does the latter more quietly because he knows he'll get kicked off the forum for it. But he actually agrees with the SVs (and against R&R) regarding whether it's possible for the New Mass to be offensive to God, etc. So this guy disagrees with both SVs and R&R. He just has more of an emotional thing against SVism (and the Dimonds on particular). I've pointed out to him that his allegations of heresy regarding Universal Acceptance apply to both both Bishop Williamson and Archbishop Lefebvre and, actually, most Traditional Catholics. He's derided the Resistance as schismatics for opposing the efforts of +Fellay to reunify with Rome, but then he praises Bishop Williamson to no end when he happens to agree with one of his other opinions and he can use that as a weapon against the sedevacantist.
After being about 5,000 - 6,000 ahead in upvotes over down, he's now very quickly drawn even. He starts one thread after another where it's him against pretty much everybody else on CI.
He's trying to divide and causes dissension among true Traditional Catholics while promoting his Indultarianism, his pan-Christian religious indifferentism (despite falsely claiming to be strong on EENS), and defending the New Mass as a good thing. He doesn't belong here.
Plus, if he's actually Nishant, then he's done the very unusual thing of going from someone with the maturity of a middle-aged man to behaving like a petulant teenager.
Topic: XavierSem Can't Be Same Person as Nishant of 7 years Ago (Read 6370 times)