Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Women going to college?  (Read 44514 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Women going to college?
« Reply #190 on: August 20, 2012, 12:22:13 AM »
Quote from: SpiritusSanctus
Catherine, I believe those Catholic colleges were meant more for women who intended to stay single. I was actually talking about women who are married or who intended to marry.

But really, considering that most "Catholic" universities are no longer Catholic, and considering a degree is over-rated by the modern world anyway, I wouldn't even advise a woman who did not intend to marry to go to one. If they truly desired a degree, taking online college coruses would be better. And come to think of it, the same could be said for men who wish to obtain degrees.


Hijack  ;)
Is intending to stay single outside of religious life an option for a Catholic woman?

I've seen this "intend to marry" over and over again on this board and I thought that automatically should be the case unless she is joining a religious community.

Women going to college?
« Reply #191 on: August 20, 2012, 12:28:44 AM »
Quote from: Tiffany
I've seen this "intend to marry" over and over again on this board and I thought that automatically should be the case unless she is joining a religious community.


What does St. Paul say?  


Women going to college?
« Reply #192 on: August 20, 2012, 12:41:24 AM »
Quote from: Traditional Guy 20
Quote from: PenitentWoman
Thank you.  I just  have  moments of exhaustion when  I curse my financial status. Not because I desire material things, but just so I know I can pay my rent. Then the Lord finds a good way to remind me that my cross serves a purpose, and we are all blessed in different ways. Lack of money is not the reason I struggle.

Be proud of your occupation.


Poverty is a state of mind, not material. One can be poor as dirt but happy about their vocation in life. Think about this: while those who go to college usually lose their faith, those who work hard usually don't (with some exceptions, I work around plenty of white trash who love talking about sex and porn). Being "white trash" has to do with one's moral character, not one's paycheck.

Quote
BTW, have you ever thought about putting this on T-shirt?


Ha I don't wear T-shirts unless I'm working or in the house and I don't have anything on them. :P



I agree that people can happy at all economic levels including poverty. I disagree that poverty is state of mind. Hunger, cold, oppression, being unable to afford medical care and suffering with treatable illness, clothing that doesn't fit or falls apart, wages that don't pay enough for basics, being destitute with little realistic opportunity for a better life, the hardships from being on the margin of society,  are not states of mind.

I don't know about those who work do not lose their faith. I was exposed to a great deal of immorality and opportunity to sin at work.

Women going to college?
« Reply #193 on: August 20, 2012, 02:38:51 AM »
Quote from: Tiffany

I've seen this "intend to marry" over and over again on this board and I thought that automatically should be the case unless she is joining a religious community.




I am one who has made this designation in my replies. I guess I do it because not all women are called to marriage, and for these women there might be exceptions regarding her education. I would still say campus life and many course offerings are unsuitable for any woman, but one not planning marriage might be more justified in exploring the pursuit of higher education (like maybe, nursing?) because time at a university isn't such a time waster for her.  

I guess I don't know for certain if it is okay for a woman to pursue single life and not become a nun.  I will have to read what Paul says on this subject, because I've never noticed before. Perhaps my idea of granting exceptions has feminist undertones.  Sometimes I unintentionally find myself being politically correct not to hurt the feelings of others.

I do know that God has always designed women in a way where her fertility begins at a young age. It seems very counter to his perfect design of women that when fertility is fast approaching its peak, society (and even traditional Catholics, apparently) believe a woman should be ignoring her nature and instead immersed only in academic and social pursuits. Even as a young child I always knew I wanted to be a wife and Mom. Maybe I was not the norm, but by the time I could actually physically have a baby, I was already strongly desiring just that.  Being able to identify at 13-14 that I wanted to get married and be a mother someday, it would have been best for my soul (and isn't that the ultimate goal?) to begin being focused on learning and living to be a keeper of the home.

I am certainly not saying that girls should be betrothed at menarche, but if the instinctive desire is there, a young girl's education and training should begin to be geared towards becoming a keeper of the home. Young teenage girls are so vulnerable, this is the time their attitudes can still be molded. Parents should be encouraging the correct values and lifestyle, not throwing her into battle (modern high school environments and college) and hoping she has enough spiritual armor to withstand immoral environments.  The period of "adolescence" now extends way too far beyond physical puberty, and constantly telling girls they need a period of being "independent" before marriage is just not founded in scripture and teaching.  At least not that I can find.

 It is a really taboo subject, even though we are really just talking nature.  I still remember what my mother said to me when I was little and I told her I was getting married at 16 because that is when Ariel from The Little Mermaid got married.  :wink: I guess I've just always wondered why we are called to be fruitful, but then designed to be most fruitful when it is totally unacceptable (to the world) to do so.  It seems to me that when women are having to resort to evil science to extend their fertility, it should be a sign that we are pushing too much against our nature.  What is the logic in the world saying a young lady is grown up enough at 18 to be sent to live with strangers in a corrupt environment where she must constantly fight for herself,  but somehow at this same she is not grown up to have a family? When she would have a husband to protect and guide her against evil, which she does not have at a University? Yes, not everyone can get married right as they become an adult, but a major reason for that is because they don't think it is a possibility and aren't prepared for it. Isn't that an easily fixed problem?

 I worry about questioning God's design of women.  It hasn't worked out very well so far. Maybe as a convert to tradition I romanticize too much. I've also been told that knowing I wanted a family at a young age was just me making up for having parents that fought all the time and having no siblings.  I'd be really surprised though if other young girls didn't think about marriage and babies. I just think it is just how we teach them to alter and suppress such instincts.  It was okay to promote lusting after male celebrities at this age, but don't dare associate certain feelings with innate desire for marriage and understanding of personal fertility! Isn't that how the world stopped courting and started "dating" in the modern sense? Separating natural feelings from their true purpose?  

As far as college for social enrichment?  The point was, that even if different classes have different roles in society, morals do not change.  I don't recall reading anything about the purpose and role of women where there is a footnote made that said that wealthy young ladies who want to be wives and mothers should have different moral values than poor women who desire the same thing.  That is what this entire discussion was about. Is going to college a good moral choice for young women?

Sorry for long this is.  Middle of the night nursing sessions are when I think way too much. =)

Women going to college?
« Reply #194 on: August 20, 2012, 06:47:49 AM »
Quote from: SouthernBelle


I'm currently in the process of renovating a home, and have been away from the computer ... just got back online.

I'll try to reply more to comments about my last post in the coming days, but wanted specifically to reply to what I bolded.

Comments like those are not only sniffy, snarky responses, but are also examples of reverse elitism, as if manual labor and a poor or modest income are in and of themselves more worthy than an educated man who also works hard, though his labor may not be manual. This does not reflect Catholic teaching. A truly Catholic society is hierarchical, and there is as much room for the educated elite as there is for the uneducated manual laborer.



Haven't you heard? I am an anti-intellectual. :smile:

I do agree in a hierarchal society, but it is when the higher half of society looks down on the lower half is when I get frustrated. We all need eachother. If there were no manual laborers a store would not be stocked, there would be no construction, etc. And who said I was uneducated? :wink: