The spirit on this forum these days is vicious and unloving. It didn't used to be like that, but some people seem to think they have a mission from God to correct everyone around them by any means at their disposal. That alone screams hubris, but the continual breakdown of peace and charity is what alarms me the most. Will you be satisfied when Cathinfo is destroyed?
Far as I'm concerned, this board, or any other, would be a peacefull and loving space if it was concerned with; providing help to those in need, hope for those who have none, chronicle ones effort in fighting isolation, poverty, fear and hopelessness.
Rather, it's largely a space to whip oneself into a frenzy, with all the horror stories that can be garnished, either factual or speculative. Now, you and others would like to be able to escalate this fear in a spirit of camaraderie... I respect that, but it's not likely to fly with everyone equally.
Of course, thats my angle, others may have other reasons to be antagonistic.
Another point is, that this board was created by and large has a reaction to another board that we all know. By this quality, people will spill over from that board, but not all for the same reasons. If Chant wants this board to be really open, he will need to contend with all those various overspills... If he wants a specific direction to it, he will likely moderate harder and possible ban some subjects or users.
I am not very charitable, quite intransigeant and often times arrogant, I am sorry for that, and do try to minimize it... But like I said, the subjects leveled here are very serious, and the rethoric quite strong and destructive. My tone is equally strong in denouncing what I view to be wrong. I would not be like this if the subjects would be lighter.
Edit: On that note Trinity, I applaud your thread... and agree with you on it. I applaud it also of course, because it is exactly a counter-weight to my argument above, and shine the kind of light that I would expect to see more out of on a religious board.
I also agree with you that one can be agnostic, and still have relevant and usefull nuggets of truth to tell.