Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?  (Read 10711 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?
« Reply #20 on: November 08, 2017, 06:41:10 PM »
It seems that a fair number of Trads including priests find nothing wrong in going out to purchase a meal in a restaurant on a Sunday when they can just as easily stay home and prepare and eat their meal at home.  Isn't there something wrong with this picture in terms of avoiding unnecessary purchases on Sunday?
I have actually never heard of the commandment to avoid unnecessary purchases on Sunday, only unnecessary servile work.  As for meals, whether they are procured at a restaurant or procured at home, the servile work to prepare the meals is necessary work.  

Re: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?
« Reply #21 on: November 08, 2017, 09:28:49 PM »
In these day, without the easy availability of the teaching Church, fplk tend to be unsure,  so they tend to make up their own rules, which are stricter than the Church - in other words - scrupulous.


Offline Ladislaus

  • Supporter
Re: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?
« Reply #22 on: November 09, 2017, 07:58:12 AM »
It seems that a fair number of Trads including priests find nothing wrong in going out to purchase a meal in a restaurant on a Sunday when they can just as easily stay home and prepare and eat their meal at home.  Isn't there something wrong with this picture in terms of avoiding unnecessary purchases on Sunday?

I have not heard an opinion from any Catholic theologian who says this is wrong.  It's not about the money changing hands.  It's about the labor to be performed.  Whether I do the work of cooking or someone else does, there's labor involved.  And if someone else does that necessary labor for you, there's nothing wrong with paying them for it.  That's the theological reasoning.  Money is not part of the equation.  There's no prohibition about spending money on a Sunday.

Re: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?
« Reply #23 on: November 09, 2017, 10:03:36 AM »
  There's no prohibition about spending money on a Sunday.
Some theologians such as Fr. Heribert Jone (Moral Theology, TAN,) would seem to very likely place a prohibition on unnecessarily going to a restaurant on Sunday.  On p.122 of said book he states: "Forbidden in themselves are such activities as marketing, fairs, buying and selling, public auctions, shopping in stores." 

The 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia under the entry for Sunday reads as follows: " From the eight century the law began to be formulated as it exists at the present day, and the local councils forbade servile work, public buying and selling,....."

To go out and buy a meal on Sunday when it is not necessary may well be in keeping with the letter of the law, but it would seem to be of some real doubt as to whether it was in keeping with the spirit of the law, i.e. the Third Commandment.

I am of the impression that although most Trads would agree that we should try to refrain from unnecessary buying at department stores on Sunday many of them find nothing wrong in buying tickets to entertainment events or to buying a meal on Sunday when it is not necessary.  It seems to me that by doing the latter we feed into the secular culture (which profanes Sundays in every way imaginable) by treating Sundays like any other day of the week.

It may be of some of some interest that Sr. Maie of St. Peter, O.C.D., the nun and visionary mystic who is best known for starting the devotion to the Holy Face of Jesus and for the Golden Arrow Prayer, asserted that in one of her private revelations concerning reparation to Christ's Holy Face, Jesus told her: "The executioners crucified me on Friday, Christians crucify me on Sunday." Interestingly enough this revelation was given the following year (1847) after Our Lady of LaSallete wept over man's neglect of Sunday


Re: What is Sinful to do on Sundays?
« Reply #24 on: November 09, 2017, 10:36:30 AM »
In these day, without the easy availability of the teaching Church, fplk tend to be unsure,  so they tend to make up their own rules, which are stricter than the Church - in other words - scrupulous.

Of course, it goes both ways!  They can also tend to be more lax than the spirit of the law would allow -- in other words -- complacent.