Catholic Info

Traditional Catholic Faith => Catholic Living in the Modern World => Topic started by: Vintagewife3 on January 02, 2019, 12:25:42 PM

Title: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 02, 2019, 12:25:42 PM
Dear ladies, and gents,

I’m curious as to what advice you’d offer young couples seeking Holy Matrimony.

Men, what would you tell young husbands?
And what advice would you give young wives? 

Ladies, same goes for you. What would you tell a young wife, and husband?

I’m curious about advice on everything, and  not just the proper roles each spouse should play. We are going from the basis that the young couple knows the husband is the Christ figure head of the house, and the woman the church. 

I’m looking for Catholic perspectives so as to continue to weed out any modernization in my personal marriage, and myself.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: songbird on January 02, 2019, 08:09:03 PM
Be sure to say the rosary together daily, if possible. Together is important.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: forlorn on January 03, 2019, 10:07:09 AM
Be sure to say the rosary together daily, if possible. Together is important.
Families that pray together stay together as the saying goes. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: 1st Mansion Tenant on January 03, 2019, 11:30:55 AM
Carefully examine whether one of you may have a vocation to the Church before getting too serious.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: forlorn on January 03, 2019, 12:10:04 PM
I'd suggest having a chat about where you'd like to live and in general where you yourself in the future before tying the knot. You don't have to agree on absolutely everything, but if the lifestyle, location, etc. one of you would like would be torture for the other it's better to discuss that and see if you can compromise before it's too late. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Matthew on January 03, 2019, 12:16:27 PM
Don't bear the yoke with unbelievers. But beyond that, make sure your spouse is a solid, serious Catholic. That shared faith will give you the means to solve any problems and challenges that will appear later in your married life.

Ladies: make sure your prospective spouse can work. Make sure he can do things he "doesn't want to do" -- in other words, make sure he has a certain minimum level of mortification or self-discipline. Without that, he will be nothing but trouble. In fact, without self-discipline he's likely to be wallowing in sin (rather than fighting sin at all times) as well.

Men: The above advice applies to ladies as well -- they need to be able to work, albeit different kinds of work (housework, being pregnant, raising children, homeschooling, "frugality" tasks to help save the household money, etc.) Make sure your wife has a low degree of feminism. 0% is too much to hope for, but make sure she's content being a stay-at-home wife and mother rather than the co-equal head of the household. Make sure she's willing to believe that motherhood is a lofty role and not some kind of degrading role, beneath her dignity, invented by "the Patriarchy". Make sure she hasn't bought into the bill of goods that a career (working for The Man in a cubicle 40 hours a week) is the only way to live a fulfilling life.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: SusanneT on January 03, 2019, 12:54:16 PM
I'd suggest having a chat about where you'd like to live and in general where you yourself in the future before tying the knot. You don't have to agree on absolutely everything, but if the lifestyle, location, etc. one of you would like would be torture for the other it's better to discuss that and see if you can compromise before it's too late.
You don’t have to agree on everything but as a future wife you do have to be happy that you respect your husband sufficiently and that he is completely committed to Church teaching such that you can submit to him as your ‘head’ willingly and in the knowledge that in doing so you will honour God. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Nadir on January 03, 2019, 02:42:29 PM
Make sure that he/she agrees to or is at least open to the idea  of homeschooling your prospective children, as it could be that no other option will be available to Catholics. 
.
And while you are at it, consider the other's attitude to health issues such as whether or not to vaccinate.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: 2Vermont on January 03, 2019, 03:46:39 PM
Consider the possibility that you can not have children since it is not a guarantee.  Discuss this possibility with your potential spouse.  Given our older age when we met, we were already on board with "if it's God's Will", so this wasn't an issue for us, but I imagine that younger Catholic couples don't even consider the possibility of infertility.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: SusanneT on January 03, 2019, 05:33:25 PM
Consider the possibility that you can not have children since it is not a guarantee.  Discuss this possibility with your potential spouse.  Given our older age when we met, we were already on board with "if it's God's Will", so this wasn't an issue for us, but I imagine that younger Catholic couples don't even consider the possibility of infertility.
And equally if you marry young that you may be blessed with a very large family.  
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 03, 2019, 09:30:55 PM
Carefully examine whether one of you may have a vocation to the Church before getting too serious.
I’ve always wondered what happens if a husband or wife realizes to Late they were called to priesthood/nun life? That couldn’t be a very good feeling.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: JezusDeKoning on January 03, 2019, 09:47:06 PM
I’ve always wondered what happens if a husband or wife realizes to Late they were called to priesthood/nun life? That couldn’t be a very good feeling.
The Byzantine/(also the Orthodox Church) has married subdeacons/deacons, but that system hasn't been in place in the Western Church for thousands of years.

So, I don't know. That's actually a very good question.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 03, 2019, 10:00:56 PM
How about for handling arguments? It doesn’t Matter really how much you agree on. Things happen in marriages such as hurt feelings, and misunderstandings. 


I would say that women need to ask for time to process things the husband is saying if they feel like may have a negative reaction. Or I’ll repeat back what he says so he knows I’ve heard him if we are having a fight about something I may have done to hurt his feelings. We also have a rule that no matter what if the person calls truce we stop the argument completely. We don’t even try to approach sensitive subjects until a few days later when all feelings are calm.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 03, 2019, 10:06:50 PM
Don't bear the yoke with unbelievers. But beyond that, make sure your spouse is a solid, serious Catholic. That shared faith will give you the means to solve any problems and challenges that will appear later in your married life.

Ladies: make sure your prospective spouse can work. Make sure he can do things he "doesn't want to do" -- in other words, make sure he has a certain minimum level of mortification or self-discipline. Without that, he will be nothing but trouble. In fact, without self-discipline he's likely to be wallowing in sin (rather than fighting sin at all times) as well.

Men: The above advice applies to ladies as well -- they need to be able to work, albeit different kinds of work (housework, being pregnant, raising children, homeschooling, "frugality" tasks to help save the household money, etc.) Make sure your wife has a low degree of feminism. 0% is too much to hope for, but make sure she's content being a stay-at-home wife and mother rather than the co-equal head of the household. Make sure she's willing to believe that motherhood is a lofty role and not some kind of degrading role, beneath her dignity, invented by "the Patriarchy". Make sure she hasn't bought into the bill of goods that a career (working for The Man in a cubicle 40 hours a week) is the only way to live a fulfilling life.
Matthew, I think this is great. What feminist don’t understand is that while motherhood is rewarding. It takes time to see that reward. Every milestone of religious growth, mental, and physical is a compliment to the mother’s perseverance. It took me a while to understand that the best reward takes time. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Simple as Doves on January 06, 2019, 11:00:58 AM
“The Wife Desired” and “The Man For Her” by Fr Leo J. Kinsella are must Reads. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Matthew on January 06, 2019, 11:14:26 AM
The Byzantine/(also the Orthodox Church) has married subdeacons/deacons, but that system hasn't been in place in the Western Church for thousands of years.

So, I don't know. That's actually a very good question.

That's why young men and women need to try out a vocation while they're single, unfettered, and have nothing but time.

And young men need to investigate a vocation even if they feel attracted to women, and confuse that with a calling to the married state. What, do you think priests are a bunch of fαɢɢօts? I know that sounds harsh, but such is the LOGICAL CONCLUSION of the fallacious arguments of some young men!

If every man who was attracted to women had a "vocation" to the married life, then only asɛҳuąƖs (defective) and fαɢɢօts (perverts) would be left to become priests. Ridiculous!

What's really tragic is when young men stubbornly assert they are called to the married state even though they are in their late 30s or 40s and God hasn't sent them a suitable marriage partner yet! Again, they are just experiencing the attraction to women that every normal, non-damaged, intact, post-puberty male experiences.

Priests (bishops, etc.) are normal, red-blooded men. But unlike laymen, they make a sacrifice of their lives for God.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: forlorn on January 06, 2019, 04:05:57 PM
That's why young men and women need to try out a vocation while they're single, unfettered, and have nothing but time.

And young men need to investigate a vocation even if they feel attracted to women, and confuse that with a calling to the married state. What, do you think priests are a bunch of fαɢɢօts? I know that sounds harsh, but such is the LOGICAL CONCLUSION of the fallacious arguments of some young men!

If every man who was attracted to women had a "vocation" to the married life, then only asɛҳuąƖs (defective) and fαɢɢօts (perverts) would be left to become priests. Ridiculous!

What's really tragic is when young men stubbornly assert they are called to the married state even though they are in their late 30s or 40s and God hasn't sent them a suitable marriage partner yet! Again, they are just experiencing the attraction to women that every normal, non-damaged, intact, post-puberty male experiences.

Priests (bishops, etc.) are normal, red-blooded men. But unlike laymen, they make a sacrifice of their lives for God.
Agreed. And it's the ridiculous attitude that "oh I'm not asɛҳuąƖ, therefore I'm not fit to be a priest" which caused the priesthood to be filled with these lavendar mafia pedos in the first place. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: magdalena59 on January 06, 2019, 04:58:15 PM
Remember that communication is very important. 
Sometimes one spouse will want or be in need of assistance and expect the other to know what they want without being asked.  
If upset about something or feelings are hurt, take some time to pray before speaking. 

Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on January 06, 2019, 07:22:08 PM
Women need to know that men were created by God to be different. He is not meant to be like a best girlfriend. I don't know of any Catholic books that address this, but a couple of secular books are Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus and You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men.

Many divorces and marriage difficulties arise because our disgusting culture, among other problems, has de-gendered our culture. Deluded women expect their husbands to have feminine characteristics, be all touchy- feely, talk about their feelings, cry, etc. God made men to lead, to protect, to provide, to problem-solve -- not to be a girlfriend.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: 2Vermont on January 06, 2019, 07:34:25 PM
How about for handling arguments? It doesn’t Matter really how much you agree on. Things happen in marriages such as hurt feelings, and misunderstandings.


I would say that women need to ask for time to process things the husband is saying if they feel like may have a negative reaction. Or I’ll repeat back what he says so he knows I’ve heard him if we are having a fight about something I may have done to hurt his feelings. We also have a rule that no matter what if the person calls truce we stop the argument completely. We don’t even try to approach sensitive subjects until a few days later when all feelings are calm.
I tend to think of it as learning how to respond rather than react. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 06, 2019, 07:50:28 PM
Women need to know that men were created by God to be different. He is not meant to be like a best girlfriend. I don't know of any Catholic books that address this, but a couple of secular books are Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus and You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men.

Many divorces and marriage difficulties arise because our disgusting culture, among other problems, has de-gendered our culture. Deluded women expect their husbands to have feminine characteristics, be all touchy- feely, talk about their feelings, cry, etc. God made men to lead, to protect, to provide, to problem-solve -- not to be a girlfriend.
That’s probably true. Men are fixers, and when you give them a problem that’s what they will want to do. Then we get upset because we just wanted someone to commiserate with us. Every Man should be good at romance though lol I think that’s different than being touchy feely 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on January 15, 2019, 03:44:59 PM
That’s probably true. Men are fixers, and when you give them a problem that’s what they will want to do. Then we get upset because we just wanted someone to commiserate with us. Every Man should be good at romance though lol I think that’s different than being touchy feely
Exactly. In one of the books I used when I taught Marriage class, the example was used of a woman who had breast cancer was facing possible loss of one or both breasts, and needed moral support. Had she turned to one of her female friends, they would have recognized her emotional overload and held her and let her cry.
However, when she told her husband about her pain at the loss of her breast/s, he wanted to fix things, since God wired men to fix things. Her DH said "Well, you could always have breast reconstruction surgery."
As a woman, you can imagine how that went over.
Many men, hearing this, don't see what the problem was. He was just trying to help her.
And he was.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vintagewife3 on January 15, 2019, 05:51:08 PM
Exactly, now I do have female friends, but I love talking to my husband about everything. There is nothing i don’t tell him really. If it’s mindless chatter I keep it to myself, or girlfriends. But when I need to vent I’ll tell him I just need to get this off my chest, and I’m not looking for an answer/fix. He does a good job acting upset with me, even if he thinks it’s ridiculous lol I love him for it. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on January 16, 2019, 03:40:49 PM
Exactly, now I do have female friends, but I love talking to my husband about everything. There is nothing i don’t tell him really. If it’s mindless chatter I keep it to myself, or girlfriends. But when I need to vent I’ll tell him I just need to get this off my chest, and I’m not looking for an answer/fix. He does a good job acting upset with me, even if he thinks it’s ridiculous lol I love him for it.
You are a wise woman.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: cassini on January 17, 2019, 06:03:34 AM
What would you tell young young husbands, young wives, young men about to get married or young women about to get married?

Having read replies, I wonder how many live in the real world, the world of today, or only in a close-knit group of traditiional Catholics?

Oh if life were as simple as the latter group. Now while we can all aspire to how we would like things to be, the reality is what each of us experience. By that I mean how we were reared, how those of us in marriage experienced it, and most of all those of us who have/had children living in the real world.
To be honest, the traditional Catholic family of parents and children is as rare as miracles today, and hoping your son or daughter will meet, fall in love and marry a traditional Catholic is very rare indeed.

But let us start with ourselves. When I met my wife I was AWOL. I had not lost the faith, just drifted away from churchgoing in my late teens into my 20s. My wife was still going to Mass. Given what I have read so far on this thread, the advice to my wife would have been, get rid of that guy. She didn't, and soon we will celebrate our 40th wedding aniversary. My wife has a Mass planned for that day and all 15 in the family will attend before we all go off for a meal. We are more in love today than ever before and know we are the lucky ones. Indeed it was that marriage that brought me back into active service where I returned to the faith the Holy Ghost Fathers had taught me. We both wanted to rear our five children in the faith.Once you share the faith, that helps a lot, especially knowing you promised God on that wedding day to love each other until death. That is as much a promise to God as to each other. As for the other secrets of a loving marriage, well respect is number one and helping each other in any way possible number two.

The first lessons we teach our kids goes on for years. Now that is easy until they reach about 18. I recall my father telling me when I was 18 that I was now a man who must decide for myself what is the right thing to do. By that he meant that there is no point in telling someone what to do at that age, it must come from within. When my kids reached 18 I had to hope they would continue with the faith they were reared in. Going to Mass because their parents would give them hell if they didn't doesn't work. As soon as you are gone they will stop. Again, thank God, they all still go and will after we are gone, I hope and pray. It will be harder for them than it was for us, given the rot in the world today.

But, but, where do they meet husbands or wives? Yes, a few are lucky to meert traditional Catholics like themselves and live happy ever after. But the rest have to look elsewhere. On two occassions I have been asked for my daughters' hands in marriage. They were not traditional Catholics but lapsed Catholics like I was when I got married. So what did I say to them? I said I ask only one thing they must promise me, support my daughter in her Catholic faith. It worked and while the husbands only go to Latin Mass occassionally, the girls and the kids are there every sunday. They do defend pro-life etc among friends and acquaintances and on media of the young but they are up against it today, 99 to 1. That is the world our kids live in today and God help them.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: ggreg on January 22, 2019, 05:11:12 PM
I’ve always wondered what happens if a husband or wife realizes to Late they were called to priesthood/nun life? That couldn’t be a very good feeling.
I bet Bishop Williamson would like the movie though.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Geremia on January 22, 2019, 05:49:20 PM
Carefully examine whether one of you may have a vocation to the Church before getting too serious.
Yes, it seems lurking in the back of the minds of some entering marriage is lack of appreciation of the religious life, that there is something wrong/unhealthy with those called to celibacy/virginity. From Sacra Virginitas (http://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/docuмents/hf_p-xii_enc_25031954_sacra-virginitas.html) §37:
Quote from: Pope Pius XII
37. We have recently with sorrow censured the opinion of those who contend that marriage is the only means of assuring the natural development and perfection of the human personality. For there are those who maintain that the grace of the sacrament, conferred ex opere operato, renders the use of marriage so holy as to be a fitter instrument than virginity for uniting souls with God; for marriage is a sacrament, but not virginity. We denounce this doctrine as a dangerous error. Certainly, the sacrament grants the married couple the grace to accomplish holily the duties of their married state, and it strengthens the bonds of mutual affection that unite them; but the purpose of its institution was not to make the employment of marriage the means, most suitable in itself, for uniting the souls of the husband and wife with God by the bonds of charity.

Also, interestingly, before the 1917 Code, couples were given the so-called "bimestral privilege," during which one spouse could not demand the marriage debt of the other so the latter could consider whether to enter religious life instead. I think such a privilege was removed in the 1917 Code because it caused legal headaches, but it does illustrate the Church's desire to promote and encourage religious life.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Geremia on January 22, 2019, 06:01:17 PM
What's really tragic is when young men stubbornly assert they are called to the married state even though they are in their late 30s or 40s and God hasn't sent them a suitable marriage partner yet!
Reminds me of those who objected to St. Ambroses's promotion of the religious life, in which he defends himself by saying it is not difficult to find a wife:
Quote
One favorite topic of his was the excellence of virginity, and so successful was he in persuading maidens to adopt the religious profession that many a mother refused to permit her daughters to listen to his words. The saint was forced to refute the charge that he was depopulating the empire, by quaintly appealing to the young men as to whether any of them experienced any difficulty in finding wives. He contends, and the experience of ages sustains his contention (De Virg. (https://archive.org/details/onholyvirginity00ambr), vii) that the population increases in direct proportion to the esteem in which virginity is held.
—Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). St. Ambrose (https://archive.org/stream/V01CatholicEncyclopediaKOfC#page/n427/mode/2up). Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Miseremini on January 24, 2019, 08:10:58 PM
Whether you're looking for Mr Right or Miss Right, make sure their first name isn't Always.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: clarkaim on January 30, 2019, 06:28:41 PM
After 20+ years, a few for the guys.

Better to ask forgiveness than permission.
Honey, no it's not new, I've had this gun for years.
Make me a sandwich   Please I guess.

to my sons.  Remember its a man's world.  We get to Pee standing up.

To the women, try to be patient with your man, we are only men after all. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Ladislaus on January 30, 2019, 06:37:29 PM
If every man who was attracted to women had a "vocation" to the married life, then only asɛҳuąƖs (defective) and fαɢɢօts (perverts) would be left to become priests. Ridiculous!

Interestingly, I had a Traditional priest once probe me about a potential vocation to the priesthood (when I was making a Confession).  One of the things he asked me was, "Are you attracted to women?"  I was a bit confused by that question.  Am I not supposed to be?
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Ladislaus on January 30, 2019, 06:42:01 PM
Exactly. In one of the books I used when I taught Marriage class, the example was used of a woman who had breast cancer was facing possible loss of one or both breasts, and needed moral support. Had she turned to one of her female friends, they would have recognized her emotional overload and held her and let her cry.
However, when she told her husband about her pain at the loss of her breast/s, he wanted to fix things, since God wired men to fix things. Her DH said "Well, you could always have breast reconstruction surgery."
As a woman, you can imagine how that went over.
Many men, hearing this, don't see what the problem was. He was just trying to help her.
And he was.

This is the typical "Men are from Mars" scenario.  Indeed, it took me many, many years to figure this out myself.  Even now I find myself slipping.  Something's wrong, and I see a solution, so I propose the solution.  Sometimes it even turns out that a solution was not even wanted, just sympathy.  In fact, I almost suspect that sometimes women don't want a solution because that would remove a reason to receive sympathy.   :)
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Marie Teresa on January 30, 2019, 08:31:08 PM
Exactly. In one of the books I used when I taught Marriage class, the example was used of a woman who had breast cancer was facing possible loss of one or both breasts, and needed moral support. Had she turned to one of her female friends, they would have recognized her emotional overload and held her and let her cry.
However, when she told her husband about her pain at the loss of her breast/s, he wanted to fix things, since God wired men to fix things. Her DH said "Well, you could always have breast reconstruction surgery."
As a woman, you can imagine how that went over.
Many men, hearing this, don't see what the problem was. He was just trying to help her.
And he was.
This is the typical "Men are from Mars" scenario.  Indeed, it took me many, many years to figure this out myself.  Even now I find myself slipping.  Something's wrong, and I see a solution, so I propose the solution.  Sometimes it even turns out that a solution was not even wanted, just sympathy.  In fact, I almost suspect that sometimes women don't want a solution because that would remove a reason to receive sympathy.   :)
.
Good points above.  Here's a video that relates to that....  ;)

It's Not About The Nail (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4EDhdAHrOg)


Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Geremia on January 30, 2019, 09:24:31 PM
Interestingly, I had a Traditional priest once probe me about a potential vocation to the priesthood (when I was making a Confession).  One of the things he asked me was, "Are you attracted to women?"  I was a bit confused by that question.  Am I not supposed to be?
Perhaps he meant: "Are you attracted to women [more than to prayer, etc.]?"
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Croixalist on January 31, 2019, 09:09:34 AM
.
Good points above.  Here's a video that relates to that....  ;)

It's Not About The Nail (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4EDhdAHrOg)
Haha that's great! 
I think it would be fair to say that women have a bigger emphasis on longsuffering which makes sense considering that they often are made to conform or adapt to the pace of others, so when things get bad they get stuck in ways most men don't, though they have more channels for relieving the stress then men do. Most of the time I think it's beneficial.The worst case might look something like that skit, where the woman really hasn't thought her situation over much at all, but doesn't have the maturity to take a little bit of good-natured advise because it makes her feel foolish. They treat their symptomatic feelings ahead of the root cause.
Even when there are things men can't change in the near future, we usually break it down into scenarios, where it could be overcome and hope it happens. Or, we try to divert the helplessness by focusing on identifying the problem in a systematic way. That's if we don't take the stoic approach and just not talk about it with anyone. More than sympathy, most guys are looking to provide space for action with whoever we agree or disagree with. The immature male equivalent of the lady with the nail in her forehead might be a man who acts out emotionally on everything but the problem with a sledgehammer. 
So sympathy sessions typically strengthen social ties between females, just as men strengthen friendships by throwing out solutions even if it means locking horns. And then there's marriage where all of this gets thrown into a blender anyway, lol.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Ladislaus on January 31, 2019, 09:25:21 AM
Perhaps he meant: "Are you attracted to women [more than to prayer, etc.]?"

Perhaps.  That was 31 years ago now, and I'm married, so it's no longer relevant.   :)  I just recalled that incident after Matthew brought up that of course men considering a vocation are (should be) attracted to women.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: AnthonyPadua on February 19, 2025, 11:01:35 PM
This is the typical "Men are from Mars" scenario.  Indeed, it took me many, many years to figure this out myself.  Even now I find myself slipping.  Something's wrong, and I see a solution, so I propose the solution.  Sometimes it even turns out that a solution was not even wanted, just sympathy.  In fact, I almost suspect that sometimes women don't want a solution because that would remove a reason to receive sympathy.  :)
I saw that book recommended several times on cathinfo so I recently bought it. Currently reading through chapter 4 and while I think it has very useful advice I have noticed the secular and even feminist tendencies in it.

Take this image, in the top bullet point. The context on this was setting and respecting limits/boundaries. I was quite shocked to see this example, a wife should never suggest going on a vacation alone, it was basically a threat. No if the wife really needs a vacation a good discussion with the husband should take place and never a threat of going alone, the implications of which are terrible. Personally I found this point to be very disrespectful to the husband I am not sure why the author included it.

And some pages earlier it states, to quote;

"Similarly, many women today are also tired of giving. They want time off. Time to explore being themselves. Time to care about themselves first."

While this book was written many decades ago, as soon I see the expression or similar expressions to "explore being themselves" I get big alarms bells.

Still so far I think the book has been worth it, I just need to be careful due to the secular nature of the work.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on February 20, 2025, 10:54:41 AM
That's why young men and women need to try out a vocation while they're single, unfettered, and have nothing but time.

And young men need to investigate a vocation even if they feel attracted to women, and confuse that with a calling to the married state. What, do you think priests are a bunch of fαɢɢօts? I know that sounds harsh, but such is the LOGICAL CONCLUSION of the fallacious arguments of some young men!

If every man who was attracted to women had a "vocation" to the married life, then only asɛҳuąƖs (defective) and fαɢɢօts (perverts) would be left to become priests. Ridiculous!

What's really tragic is when young men stubbornly assert they are called to the married state even though they are in their late 30s or 40s and God hasn't sent them a suitable marriage partner yet! Again, they are just experiencing the attraction to women that every normal, non-damaged, intact, post-puberty male experiences.

Priests (bishops, etc.) are normal, red-blooded men. But unlike laymen, they make a sacrifice of their lives for God.
One of my favorite priests was not ordained until his wife had passed and his children grown.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on February 20, 2025, 11:00:33 AM
Remember that communication is very important.
Sometimes one spouse will want or be in need of assistance and expect the other to know what they want without being asked. 
If upset about something or feelings are hurt, take some time to pray before speaking.
Yes! I remember a friend saying that when the family was driving home from the beach, sandy, tired and hungry, she kept hinting to him "Oh look there's that pizza chain we like. Look, that little burger place looks good. When they got home she was faced with fixing dinner and getting the little ones washed of the sand. She started banding pots and pans in the kitchen and her husband asked "what's wrong?" She said "you wouldn't stop for something to eat." He said "why didn't you ask me?" etc.

Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on February 20, 2025, 11:11:20 AM
Helpful book

You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation Paperback

by Deborah Tannen (https://www.amazon.com/Deborah-Tannen/e/B000AQ3YWU/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_1) (Author)

Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Vanguard on February 20, 2025, 11:48:25 AM
Be prepared to sacrifice. Stick with your principles no matter what. Do unto others….. Try to set a good example even if you’re not. Beg the BVM, Jesus and all the saints to help you in distress. Pray daily. Know that God will give you the best possible circuмstances to save your soul if you ask. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Geremia on February 20, 2025, 03:55:54 PM
I’ve always wondered what happens if a husband or wife realizes to Late they were called to priesthood/nun life?
That happened to St. Rita of Cascia (https://isidore.co/calibre/#panel=book_details&book_id=6225) and many others.
Priestly or religious life is a higher calling, and marriage (either one's parents' or one's own) can be a good preparation for it.
Religious life is a big family, continuation of "nuclear" family life.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Geremia on February 20, 2025, 03:58:27 PM
“The Wife Desired (https://isidore.co/calibre/#panel=book_details&book_id=9447)” and “The Man For Her (https://isidore.co/calibre/#panel=book_details&book_id=9532)” by Fr Leo J. Kinsella are must Reads.
These are the best marriage books I've read. Fr. Kinsella delves into the nitty-gritty, practical aspects, based upon his counseling hundreds of couples.
He's a realist; he doesn't over-glorify marriage, nor does he undervalue it, but presents it as it is. He seemed to be an experienced priest.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Giovanni Berto on February 20, 2025, 05:22:42 PM
Interestingly, I had a Traditional priest once probe me about a potential vocation to the priesthood (when I was making a Confession).  One of the things he asked me was, "Are you attracted to women?"  I was a bit confused by that question.  Am I not supposed to be?

You sure are. Maybe he was just trying to unmask a potential "gαy priest".
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Matthew on February 20, 2025, 06:45:58 PM
One thing that surprised me that I never would have guessed when I was 23:

You could have no mortgage, no car payment(s), no debt of any kind, no monthly "subscriptions", no rental fees or services, food completely covered by Food Stamps, and STILL spend $2500/month on BASIC SUPPORT of your family. That's $30K a year!
Go ahead and re-read the major items that are ZERO in the budget.

What does that leave? What costs $2500 a month? Well, $500 of that is "cost sharing" Christian co-op health insurance for the 2 parents. Another $500 is property taxes. The rest is electricity, water, internet, gasoline, car insurance, house/property/car maintenance, household goods/supplies/equipment, and HOMESCHOOLING.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Matthew on February 20, 2025, 06:53:34 PM
Yes! I remember a friend saying that when the family was driving home from the beach, sandy, tired and hungry, she kept hinting to him "Oh look there's that pizza chain we like. Look, that little burger place looks good. When they got home she was faced with fixing dinner and getting the little ones washed of the sand. She started banding pots and pans in the kitchen and her husband asked "what's wrong?" She said "you wouldn't stop for something to eat." He said "why didn't you ask me?" etc.


I'm going to side with the wife in this case.
If a man can afford a family vacation, day trip, field trip, outing to the beach, or whatever, you can PLAN and afford to eat out afterward. And even if you are too poor to eat out, either you PLAN bringing something in a picnic basket from the grocery store, or you do the mainstream "stop for fast food". Those are your two choices.
The husband in this case was a real doofus.
You don't just make your wife fix dinner while she and everyone else is tired, hungry, and dirty after a long day of exhausting fun. That's ridiculous.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Seraphina on February 20, 2025, 07:58:50 PM
I'm going to side with the wife in this case.
If a man can afford a family vacation, day trip, field trip, outing to the beach, or whatever, you can PLAN and afford to eat out afterward. And even if you are too poor to eat out, either you PLAN bringing something in a picnic basket from the grocery store, or you do the mainstream "stop for fast food". Those are your two choices.
The husband in this case was a real doofus.
You don't just make your wife fix dinner while she and everyone else is tired, hungry, and dirty. That's ridiculous.
Some men are slow to take social cues!  He can still redeem himself. Give his wife the choice of cleaning up the kids while he gets take-out, he cleans the kids while she gets take out, or depending upon where they live, they both clean up the kids and call DoorDash or GrubHub!
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: FarmerWife on February 20, 2025, 08:21:43 PM
I saw that book recommended several times on cathinfo so I recently bought it. Currently reading through chapter 4 and while I think it has very useful advice I have noticed the secular and even feminist tendencies in it.

Take this image, in the top bullet point. The context on this was setting and respecting limits/boundaries. I was quite shocked to see this example, a wife should never suggest going on a vacation alone, it was basically a threat. No if the wife really needs a vacation a good discussion with the husband should take place and never a threat of going alone, the implications of which are terrible. Personally I found this point to be very disrespectful to the husband I am not sure why the author included it.

And some pages earlier it states, to quote;

"Similarly, many women today are also tired of giving. They want time off. Time to explore being themselves. Time to care about themselves first."

While this book was written many decades ago, as soon I see the expression or similar expressions to "explore being themselves" I get big alarms bells.

Still so far I think the book has been worth it, I just need to be careful due to the secular nature of the work.
It does seem manipulative. And besides, not every husband is going to fall for that. She could express her desire to go on vacation and leave it at that and maybe the husband might surprise her with one. 
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: FarmerWife on February 20, 2025, 08:27:13 PM
Yes! I remember a friend saying that when the family was driving home from the beach, sandy, tired and hungry, she kept hinting to him "Oh look there's that pizza chain we like. Look, that little burger place looks good. When they got home she was faced with fixing dinner and getting the little ones washed of the sand. She started banding pots and pans in the kitchen and her husband asked "what's wrong?" She said "you wouldn't stop for something to eat." He said "why didn't you ask me?" etc.
I see this as potentially being one-sided and somewhat husband-bashing. 

He did say, "why didn't you ask me?" because he can't read her mind?

She was banging pots and pans instead of communicating her needs. 

I don't think she was forced to fix dinner. She could have order food for the family herself, left the kids with the husband and got some convenient food and came home, husband could fix the food while she relaxed, etc. I'm sure the husband would have done something if his wife communicated to him that she just couldn't make dinner because she was too exhausted.


Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Mark 79 on February 21, 2025, 10:41:58 AM
…The husband in this case was a real doofus.
You don't just make your wife fix dinner while she and everyone else is tired, hungry, and dirty after a long day of exhausting fun. That's ridiculous.

If accurately reported, the husband was utterly lacking in empathy.… or… the wife nagged him all day on a "vacation day" about all manner of matters and he was simply being passive aggressive as "pay back" (as her pot banging was also passive aggressive).


I see this as potentially being one-sided and somewhat husband-bashing.

He did say, "why didn't you ask me?" because he can't read her mind?

She was banging pots and pans instead of communicating her needs.

I don't think she was forced to fix dinner. She could have order food for the family herself, left the kids with the husband and got some convenient food and came home, husband could fix the food while she relaxed, etc. I'm sure the husband would have done something if his wife communicated to him that she just couldn't make dinner because she was too exhausted.



Effective communication depends on both the speaking and listening parties having communications skills.

While not true in the majority of "trads," I do see a significant percent of "trads" as socially inept. In many cases it crosses the line into the Autism Spectrum.  A couple of 'spergs on CathInfo, one male, one female, come to mind.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on February 21, 2025, 03:07:26 PM
Yes! I remember a friend saying that when the family was driving home from the beach, sandy, tired and hungry, she kept hinting to him "Oh look there's that pizza chain we like. Look, that little burger place looks good. When they got home she was faced with fixing dinner and getting the little ones washed of the sand. She started banding pots and pans in the kitchen and her husband asked "what's wrong?" She said "you wouldn't stop for something to eat." He said "why didn't you ask me?" etc.
Sorry I didn't clarify (back pain made me stop and just say etc). My takeaway from this was that we women need to be explicit when we talk to our husbands. A woman listener would have understood that what the woman wanted by the first hint, but in communicating with our husbands we need to clearly say exactly what we need, as in "I'm not up for cooking tonight" or"I just need a hug right now."

 In regard to the husband-bashing I didn't see that at all, but I think this may be generational. One example amomg many --my husband never changed a diaper, but all of our sons are expert diaper changers. Most husbands back then, like mine, never bathed the children, never cooked dinner, etc. My husband, until my health recently declined, never washed a dish in his life. I think it's wonderful that husbands and fathers in thy younger generations take part in more than before.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Ladislaus on February 21, 2025, 03:10:25 PM
In many cases it crosses the line into the Autism Spectrum.  A couple of 'spergs on CathInfo, one male, one female, come to mind.

Now, now, that's not nice.  I do not have Asperger's or Autism.  :laugh1: ... Well, actually, I may just be at the very beginning of the spectrum, now that I think about it.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Matthew on February 21, 2025, 04:04:17 PM
Here is my point:
A nice day trip for the (large) family is a bit of extra work. You all come home tired and hungry, etc. Now "needing to eat" doesn't come as a surprise. A normal person would see that coming, right? Maybe I'm just Germanic but planning is second nature around here.
It's not fair, on a "family fun day", to put all the expense/extra burden on ONE person. As in, "the whole family is going to have fun, but not you, wife! You have a lot of hard work ahead of you! hahaha" Normally you just eat out -- it's part of the expense, like gas or price of admission. Either you can AFFORD the field trip or you CANNOT.

The husband in question was either autistic/oblivious, super COLD, super CHEAP, or crap as a planner. Either way, a doofus describes it best. And by "super" I mean "too much". I'm all about being frugal, but that doesn't mean it's impossible to be STINGY or CHEAP.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Gray2023 on February 21, 2025, 04:44:47 PM
Now, now, that's not nice.  I do not have Asperger's or Autism.  :laugh1: ... Well, actually, I may just be at the very beginning of the spectrum, now that I think about it.
Hey I was going to ask who the man was, I figured I was the woman. :laugh1:
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Mark 79 on February 21, 2025, 06:08:59 PM
Now, now, that's not nice.  I do not have Asperger's or Autism.  :laugh1: ... Well, actually, I may just be at the very beginning of the spectrum, now that I think about it.
No, it's not you. The "man" already knows because I told xim so. Xe eased up and stopped inflicting ximself upon us for a time, but xe has been back at it.

You'll recognize xim by xis Poche-like style of pious one-liners.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Gray2023 on February 21, 2025, 07:30:12 PM
I see this as potentially being one-sided and somewhat husband-bashing.

He did say, "why didn't you ask me?" because he can't read her mind?

She was banging pots and pans instead of communicating her needs.

I don't think she was forced to fix dinner. She could have order food for the family herself, left the kids with the husband and got some convenient food and came home, husband could fix the food while she relaxed, etc. I'm sure the husband would have done something if his wife communicated to him that she just couldn't make dinner because she was too exhausted.


Yes men don't get hints.  It is much better to be direct.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: Cera on March 03, 2025, 03:19:54 PM
Yes men don't get hints.  It is much better to be direct.
Yes Gray, thank you for getting what I was trying to say. That little story has helped me tremendously.
Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: andy on March 03, 2025, 03:26:39 PM
Well, $500 of that is "cost sharing" Christian co-op health insurance for the 2 parents.
Some Christian co-op healthcare cost sharing require you to sign off a protestant faith precepts though ...

Title: Re: What I wish I knew before marriage....
Post by: andy on March 03, 2025, 03:28:05 PM
My advise (married for 30 year). Never give up.

While it is good to find a suitable spouse in the first place, the actual life verifies ALL assumptions. So, NEVER GIVE UP. :laugh1:;)