I remember when JayneK was Judaizing on various forums and trying to get the non-Judaized banned (she doesn't seem to do it anymore, at least overtly). Hardly anyone on these forums had a problem with her for that. They usually disliked her for her anti-feminism or her mini-modding. 

THE CATHOLIC CHURCH AND Jєωιѕн CONVERTS

It was not many months ago that the public press carried a news release from Tel Aviv which stated that a certain Portuguese Jєω, by the name of Jacob Amalak, was currently visiting the state of Israel in order to hire rabbis whom he would bring back to the Jєωιѕн communities in Portugal. The article explained that in the last few years several thousands of Portuguese Marranos (Jєωs who have become Catholics) have reverted to Judaism. What is more, at least three thousand of these Marranos are from families which have been formally Catholic for the past four centuries, but have perpetuated, in secret, their Jєωιѕн doctrine and rituals.

For nineteen hundred years, now, the Jєω has been to the Church a conscious and sustained cause of anxiety. And, ultimately considered, the worry has been less for the obstinate, тαℓмυdic, controllable-in-a-ghetto Jєω, than for the baptized one, the Jєω whom the Church has established as a Christian, and set free in the Christians’ world.

Only by realizing that the Church has had, equivalently, to adopt a “fingers-crossed” attitude toward most Jєωιѕн converts, is it possible to understand her historic inertia in the matter of apostolate to the Jєωs. Indeed, our traditions have, in the past, led not merely to hesitancy in evangelizing the Jєωs, they have discouraged all but the most guarded contact with them. His Holiness, Pope Innocent III, was thus echoing the common sentiment of Christendom when, in speaking about the Jєωs, he warned, “They repay their hosts, as the proverb says, after the fashion of the rat hidden in the sack, or the snake in the bosom, or the burning brand in one’s lap.”

If the Portuguese Jєωs we mentioned at the outset are rather a remote illustration of what Pope Innocent meant, we propose to our readers the recent and devastatingly apropos case of the American Jєωιѕн convert, Leon Paul. Writing last month in Columbia, the official publication of the Knights of Columbus, Mr. Paul seems almost to have anticipated us and to have reasoned that the surest way to escape being called “a snake in the bosom” is to establish, ahead of time, that the bosom is a snake, too. To accomplish this, he proceeds to explain that the Blessed Virgin, the Mother of God, is a Jєωιѕн convert, just like Leon Paul!

Mr. Paul leaves it to his readers to resolve the serpentine innuendoes in his statement. He fails to tell us, for example, at just which point in her life the Virginal Mother of God, chosen from all eternity as the bride of the Holy Ghost, immaculately conceived in the womb of Saint Ann, could be said to be without the Faith, and at just which point she received it.

Ultimately, in any discussion of the Church’s astringent outlook on the Jєωs and their conversion, there are these two questions: Isn’t it possible for a Jєω to be sincerely converted and save his soul? Isn’t the Jєωιѕн nation going to be converted toward the end of the world?

To neither question does the Church answer with a rousingly affirmative, “Of course!” To both questions, her answer is a deliberate, thoughtful, “Yes.”

We have seen what gives the Church pause with regard to the individual Jєωιѕн convert, as she has known him down the centuries. Here, briefly, is why the Church has never been over-enthusiastic about the pending conversion of the Jєωιѕн nation. She has traditionally taught that (1) the conversion of the Jєωs will take place at the very end of the world; that (2) its primary purpose will be for a triumph over the Jєωs, the triumph of Christ, their rightful and long-rejected king; and that (3) to bring about this conversion, God will have to send Saint Elias, who will find it necessary to preach, die, and resurrect (to the accompaniment of some very persuasive earthquakes) before the Jєωs finally accept the Catholic Faith.


--https://fatherfeeney.wordpress.com/2009/08/22/the-point-september-1954/