Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: The Montessori Method  (Read 3167 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: The Montessori Method
« Reply #5 on: December 20, 2022, 05:08:25 PM »
What I know, from people I know who took their children to a Montessori center. It's that they did not learn anything in the time they were there and then they went with a great delay in their studies compared to those who went to the public. So choosing a Montessori center seems like a very bad option.

Re: The Montessori Method
« Reply #6 on: December 20, 2022, 07:19:07 PM »
Fortunately, Theosophy declines in membership every year. I have a family member who is a Theosophist.
Hadn’t thought that, but theosphists are aware of it.

Folk are less likely to join and contribute nowadays, but certainly do follow, and the insidious creed grows as we see they are active in the Catholic world.

Here is an excerpt from theosophy.org

By Robert Ellwood, emeritus professor of religion at the University of Southern California and a former vice-president of the Theosophical Society in America. He currently resides at the Krotona School of Theosophy.

The day may come when Theosophy is no longer a shrinking membership organization but more like an educational foundation, supported by all who feel called to do so, and involved in promoting teaching in the Theosophical tradition through all possible media: books, pamphlets, lectures, films, Internet sites, classes, camps, and personal contact. (Even video games, which are just beginning to be taken seriously as a new art form—a fresh embodiment of the timeless hero myth?) The new Theosophy will maintain all facets of the Ancient Wisdom but will assure the old is made new by always being presented in a way that facilitates individual spiritual life and growth.

For all that, Theosophy will probably continue also to manifest itself in groups getting together in person as well as virtually, under whatever name and in whatever form they take. Clearly a reaction has set in against traditional kinds of organization, but that does not mean humans will forever be content to live, learn, and die alone. Numerous studies have shown that people who are not just in families, but also active in religious or other larger meaning-giving organizations, are happier and healthier than solitaries or those who know only casual and informal relationships. One can e-mail, tweet, text, game, and surf the Web all one wants, even stream Theosophical lectures or participate in virtual sacred rituals at a keyboard together with fellow worshipers across the continent; this has been done. But the screen still does not take the place of face-to-face meetings. Words alone will never be quite the same as hugs and eye contact.
The jury is still out on how this will be achieved. Many voices will need to be heard as Theosophy adapts itself, as it always has over the ages, to new occasions which teach new duties and new words. It is exciting to have the privilege of living in such times of change and challenge.



Offline Meg

Re: The Montessori Method
« Reply #7 on: December 20, 2022, 10:37:38 PM »
Hadn’t thought that, but theosphists are aware of it.

Folk are less likely to join and contribute nowadays, but certainly do follow, and the insidious creed grows as we see they are active in the Catholic world.

Here is an excerpt from theosophy.org

By Robert Ellwood, emeritus professor of religion at the University of Southern California and a former vice-president of the Theosophical Society in America. He currently resides at the Krotona School of Theosophy.

The day may come when Theosophy is no longer a shrinking membership organization but more like an educational foundation, supported by all who feel called to do so, and involved in promoting teaching in the Theosophical tradition through all possible media: books, pamphlets, lectures, films, Internet sites, classes, camps, and personal contact. (Even video games, which are just beginning to be taken seriously as a new art form—a fresh embodiment of the timeless hero myth?) The new Theosophy will maintain all facets of the Ancient Wisdom but will assure the old is made new by always being presented in a way that facilitates individual spiritual life and growth.

For all that, Theosophy will probably continue also to manifest itself in groups getting together in person as well as virtually, under whatever name and in whatever form they take. Clearly a reaction has set in against traditional kinds of organization, but that does not mean humans will forever be content to live, learn, and die alone. Numerous studies have shown that people who are not just in families, but also active in religious or other larger meaning-giving organizations, are happier and healthier than solitaries or those who know only casual and informal relationships. One can e-mail, tweet, text, game, and surf the Web all one wants, even stream Theosophical lectures or participate in virtual sacred rituals at a keyboard together with fellow worshipers across the continent; this has been done. But the screen still does not take the place of face-to-face meetings. Words alone will never be quite the same as hugs and eye contact.
The jury is still out on how this will be achieved. Many voices will need to be heard as Theosophy adapts itself, as it always has over the ages, to new occasions which teach new duties and new words. It is exciting to have the privilege of living in such times of change and challenge.


Yes, they are aware of it. And they are indeed trying to stay relevant with their educational nonsense, but it's considered old school New Age, and quite frankly, Blavatsky's writings make little sense even to them. They have this idea that because they can't understand a lot of things that Blavatsky channeled, it must mean that it must be far above them and very profound. Theosophy is all in the mind, with no application for how to live in the real world. It's the opposite of Catholicism, since Catholicism is common sense as well as divine sense.

I've not heard of Robert Ellwood, but my husband probably has, since he's a Theosophist. We visited Krotona in Ojai many times when my in-laws were alive, since my husband's step-father was head of the krotona school and they lived there. That was 25 years ago, before I converted to Catholicism. I avoided anything having to do with their so-called spiritual views, and considered them harmful.

Theosophists may think that Theosophy is adaptable, but that's just wishful thinking, IMO. Only people who want to always be in search mode, and never land on anything definite will find it attractive. It used to be that most active Theosophists were freemasons, but few are now. Even my mother-in-law was a co-freemason, which was a group for women. She never talked about it, so I don't know anything about it.

The post above mentions virtual sacred rituals, but my husband's group doesn't have anything like that. The Liberal Catholic Church was started by a Theosophist named Leadbeater, which combines Theosophical principles with Catholic ritual. They believe that their mass connects with some sort of white majic. My husband was raised in that church, but had stopped attending by the time he met me. It's a truly bizarre "church," but it too is also declining in membership, thankfully.

I'm not saying that Theosophy doesn't pose a danger - it does - but it's a small group now. Though of course even a small number of people can cause problems with their false teachings. I feel sorry for those who have allowed themselves to be caught up in this pagan falsehood. 

Re: The Montessori Method
« Reply #8 on: December 21, 2022, 05:14:37 AM »
Meg, thank you for sharing your own personal experience and knowledge. Your post jogged my own memory.

I remembered that I had attended a theosophy meeting In Sydney, maybe 45 years back. I really could not work out what they were on about, and never went back. Also when I first met my husband he was an admirer of Krishnamurti, have attended some of his talks and read his writings. That didn’t jibe with me, either.

Then I recalled the psychotherapy training institute where I worked in London for 2 years. I had to allocate and book rooms and times for sessions. Each room was identified by a person’s name and one of those names was C W Leadbeater. I used to wonder who he was, so since your post I know. Now I realised that the Foundation I worked for was based on theosophical ideals.

A friend of mine (from the past, now deceased) belonged to the Liberal Catholic Church, and she was married, very unhappily, to a Bahai! 

I will pray for your husband’s conversion to the true faith. 

What a mess I escaped from, thanks be to a loving and merciful God.

Re: The Montessori Method
« Reply #9 on: December 21, 2022, 09:32:04 AM »
However confused Montessori's personal theology was her teaching methods, which have no doubt been
substantially modified, are far more sensible than what goes on in contemporary gladiator academies(public schools).
If you want your child to be a complete drone than public schools are ideal. In addition to practical education being reduced to the lowest common denominator, expect your child to be exposed to the most coarse and vulgar 
behavior and trends of popular culture, as their classmates will be walking ambassadors of this social dysfunction.

Montessori was correct in the sense that the role of education is help a child discover and encourage them in their true passions and talents.
I believe most people are unhappy not just because they shut God out of their lives but because they never
found their purpose or calling. 
Many of those in the West dread going to work at meaningless jobs that are utterly unfulfilling. 
We live in a horribly unnatural and artificial system compared to just about any other culture in human history.
Women are conditioned to focus on silly careers that preclude, delay or interfere with motherhood.
Men are no longer connected to the land or their community as bakers, farmers, blacksmiths, warriors, explorers,
craftsman. They are paper shufflers, bent over computer monitors and working on spreadsheets. 
How do they cope with the monotony, the conformity?
Drugs, video games, an obsessive devotion to professional sports, alcoholism, porn, promiscuity.

Any independent, creative or imaginative child will flourish far more in a Montessori school