What you say Nadir is correct even for the small school in India. Some of the ex-students do not practice the faith. And the school has a priority over the Mass Centers and along with the "orphanage" is the raison d'etre for the SSPX's existence in India.
When Fr Valan was with the SSPX he is believed not to have been too keen on these two Indian favorites, and is said to have told a faithful, that the use of volunteers in India was a "scandal"! Of course, I may have got this wrong and he may wish to clarify this.
Of course, even in the days when it was easy to get a good Catholic education, ie in my day, many ex-students did not practice the faith. This is something that cannot be helped. But usually the child takes faith seriously when the parents do. Or I should say they are more likely to. It is never assured. The most important factor is the attitude of the parents. That is why homeschooling is more likely to produce faithful Catholics.
When I said They can only deteriorate under the present management.
I mean that whileever SSPX is tending towards an agreement with the conciliar church, the schools cannot be trusted to continue to teach the Faith. At least one SSPX school that I know has already caved in to some Vat2 on the question of religious liberty.
I know of another school which employs non-Catholic teacher/s and other schools accept state aid by which they immediately compromised.
Lastly I don't believe you should be making such statements without assuring they are true, and naming names while you remain anonymous.
Also India is not open to evangelisation and does not give visas to missionaries. So the situation there cannot be compared with other places like the US or Australia. I cannot say any more on the subject of India in a public forum.
Yes, statements should not be made and names not be named while remaining anonymous unless of course those named are John XXIII, Paul VI, JPI, JPII, BXVI and Francis.All nice nicety covers the SSPX, both N and MC. I once said, in great irritation, to an SSPX Asia priest:
If I say X about you would that constitute calumny?
Yes, he answered.
And if you say the same thing about me would that do so?
No, he answered.
Concerning evangelization, the SSPX has obtained faithful mainly via caste fall outs. Singamparai, Asaripalam and Nagercoil. Likewise for RN Kandigai where the faithful ousted a so-called Dalit priest who was assigned to them.
I once asked a priest ( now married I have been told by another priest) if he could come and give Extreme Unction to a dying faithful by changing his schedule somewhat.
How can I, he wailed, when I have 1.1billion faithful to cater to. Repeat: 1.1 billion.
Evangelization in action!
Topic: SSPX Schools (Read 3858 times)