Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana  (Read 14849 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Mark 79

  • Supporter
Re: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana
« Reply #70 on: March 17, 2022, 06:42:07 PM »
Nobody is ignoring your point, but rejecting your foolish generalization, projection of your own disorder, and denial of Catholic moral theology.

Re: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana
« Reply #71 on: March 17, 2022, 06:56:49 PM »
Nobody is ignoring your point, but rejecting your foolish generalization, projection of your own disorder, and denial of Catholic moral theology.
Catholic moral theology has nothing to do with the problem, the problem (THE POINT) is that recreational use of MJ is a leg spreader for girls, a certain indicator that they are promiscuous. You can stick your head in the ground but I lived it. All the girls that smoked MJ "partied". There is no projecting (whatever that means to you), it is a fact. If you choose to not believe it that is your problem. I do not write just for you, I write for all the parents that don't  know what I know. Ladislaus has complained that I am too detailed about my past and he is right, so I am refraining from saying more. My father knew nothing about these things that started in the in the 1960's with sex and drugs, I'm sure there are parents out there that are the same. THAT is why I write and shout from the roof tops.

If you really want to talk about THE POINT, stick to arguing about it, I posted it near the beginning in a polite manner, it could not be any clearer:


Quote
THE POINT
Marijuana, Cocaine, Hashish, Quaaludes and the like, they all were the high waving red flag that the female users were promiscuous ("they liked to party"). There was no moderation about it. All MJ smokers were promiscuous. I do not see why it would be any different today, especially since MJ is more potent.



Re: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana
« Reply #72 on: March 17, 2022, 07:11:40 PM »
Catholic moral theology has nothing to do with the problem, the problem is that recreational use of MJ is a leg spreader for girls a certain indicator that they are promiscuous. You can stick your head in the ground but I lived it. All the girls that smoked MJ "partied". There is no project (whatever that means), it is a fact. If you choose to not believe it that is your problem. I do not write just for you, I right for all the parents that don't  know what I know. Ladislaus has complained that I am too detailed about my past and he is right, so I am refraining from saying more. My father knew nothing about these things that started in the in the 1960's with sex and drugs, I'm sure there are parents out there that are the same. THAT is why I write and shout from the roof tops.
The term "leg spreader" is kind of scandalizing, just saying.

That aside, I essentially agree with you, with the caveat that we cannot also generalize recreational use as inherently directed towards hedonism and abuse. Mark has provided solid evidence to the contrary, and others have shown that morally-speaking you have just as much of a risk of MJ abuse amongst some dispositions as you would alcohol or tobacco.

We all have different backgrounds, especially those of us who came from the world to Catholicism. I've seen it, I'm sure just about everyone here has too in their personal lives. The problem here is why you feel the need to "shout it from the rooftops" so often on CI, where many are already well aware of the dangers of the modern world? Your audience, and scope, is limited to Catholics who are like-minded in that matter.

So, I see it as a futile exercise that serves to reveal your own morbid fixation on the subject of licentiousness and the possibility of a hidden (or explicit) pride on your part to condescend your virtue to others (as evidenced by both yours and Meg's replies in these threads).

Re: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana
« Reply #73 on: March 17, 2022, 07:38:46 PM »
The term "leg spreader" is kind of scandalizing, just saying. (You are 100% correct, I cringed every time I wrote it, but sometimes one has to be blunt. You will not see me use it again)

That aside, I essentially agree with you, with the caveat that we cannot also generalize recreational use as inherently directed towards hedonism and abuse (I always put recreational use among young people, and specifically young girls and I state my personal experience that it was and is a certain sign that they "Party". A girl that tries MJ just to see what its like and never does it again is not going to turn into a slave to Satan. I am not talking about older couples who smoke MJ by themselves at home. I have no experience there) . Mark has provided solid evidence to the contrary (no M79 has not, he has provided information about medical use, and his recreational use is not about young daughters, so his evidence has NOTHING to do with MY POINT), and others have shown that morally-speaking you have just as much of a risk of MJ abuse amongst some dispositions as you would alcohol or tobacco (Moral Theology has nothing to do with MY POINT, and they have not shown that young girls reaction to use of MJ is the same as alcohol or tobacco. In my experience, alcohol (and of course tobacco) did not result in the same reaction as MJ, not even close. Neither did Cocaine. Quaaludes did though.)


We all have different backgrounds, especially those of us who came from the world to Catholicism. I've seen it, I'm sure just about everyone here has too in their personal lives. The problem here is why you feel the need to "shout it from the rooftops" so often on CI, where many are already well aware of the dangers of the modern world? Your audience, and scope, is limited to Catholics who are like-minded in that matter. (If they were likeminded,  this thread would have not made it past my first posting.)

So, I see it as a futile exercise that serves to reveal your own morbid fixation on the subject of licentiousness and the possibility of a hidden (or explicit) pride on your part to condescend your virtue to others (as evidenced by both yours and Meg's replies in these threads).
(Speak for yourself. Obviously you are not like minded, you have a horse in the race, and a chip on your shoulder.)


Quote
I quoted St. Remigius saying it is THE sin that takes almost all adults. It's from the 5th century. I could post many more such quotes. Were all the saints that taught about THE sin that takes the most adults to hell also "revealing their own morbid fixation on the subject of licentiousness and the possibility of a hidden (or explicit) pride"? If it disturbs you just ignore it.

Thank you for bumping the thread and placing me in such distinguished company of the "morbid fixated prideful" saints.

Among adults there are few saved because of the sins of the flesh....With exception of those who die in childhood, most men will be damned. (St. Remigius of Rheims)


My comments in bold, and St. Remigius quote

Re: Oxymoron - Catholics for Recreational Use of Marijuana
« Reply #74 on: March 17, 2022, 07:51:05 PM »
(If they were likeminded,  this thread would have not made it past my first posting.)

(Speak for yourself. Obviously you are not like minded.)

My comments in bold
Clearly I was wrong in saying "we" are likeminded to include yourself, as it's apparent you have a particular idea of what can and cannot be condoned by Catholics within your own interpretation of Moral Theology. As I recall, you admitted that you utilize a reactionary assessment of moral situations, rather than one of moderation.

Yet, it is likeminded with other Catholics in the sense that we are all aware of the thorns posed by the world and the flesh. So emphasizing this point ad nauseum does nothing but annoy people as vain sanctimony.