Good contribution, I am aware of that, I was dealing with the image posted and the claim that it is an orgy.
You're welcome. If anything, this history might back up what you're saying, unless if that specific image you are discussing caused similar controversy as
The Last Judgement did. Why does it seem that the controversy around
The Last Judgement is more well known than with that particular image? I should do some more research, but it seems to me that image did not cause controversy, or may have caused a little controversy, in comparison to
The Last Judgement.
Another word on Michelangelo: he was a complicated man. One of his heroes (and one of my own) was the great Dominican friar Girolamo Savonarola, who he painted as being among the just (alongside another notable Florentine, Dante Alighieri) in
The Last Judgement. It is said that Michelangelo often carried on him Savonarola's book
The Triumph of the Cross, and that while painting Sistine Chapel, he recalled Savonarola's powerful sermons (Michelangelo was in Florence while Savonarola was there, and heard some of his preaching in person). If Michelangelo had issues with sodomy, he certainly wasn't proud of it, as Savonarola was noted for his immense opposition to that sin, as Florence under the friar's oversight saw strong anti-sodomy laws be put in place. Secular commentators recall those measures with disdain for the man; we Catholics should remember it happily.
It does not make sense, in my view, for Michelangelo to have looked up to so thoroughly Catholic a priest as Savonarola while being a proud sodomite, as such hardened sinners would look down on a man like that.