In any case, I can't help but think that the Holy Spirit often works slowly, "degree by degree" as the saying goes. Surely being brought to (or brought back to) Christianity, albeit perhaps an imperfect kind, is better than being left as an atheist in the devil's grip?
I agree with this, and that's actually one of the things I like about JP. He's not saying he found "the light", per se. Rather, he's showing others some of the places he believes the light can be found in--and he keeps pointing more and more towards Christianity.
I 100% agree with the first sentence especially in the case of a private individual. Yet what I have been trying to point out in several posts is that
we are not speaking here of a private individual. In fact, "some of the places he believes the light can be found in" might be very dangerous places spiritually.
I fully recognize that everyone's path is different, and if someone takes a more tortuous or foolish route toward the Truth, that is part of Divine Providence. If Mrs. JP is on this path, wonderful. If JP gets there on his own schedule, wonderful. (Hence your very relevant quote re Elisha.) But until they do, that's their private business with their families, close friends, mentors, and most importantly, their confessors.
Yet again, what I've been trying to point out in several posts is that we should be wary of ignorant feel-good cheerleading and condoning what may turn out to be false shepherds, especially if any impressionable ones in our private lives look to us for guidance. Even if these public figures are indeed sincere in their own hearts and souls, there still remains for them the temptation of pride, where the roar of the crowd will stall them in what the faithless and faceless mob wants to hear.
So much of what we see in the media is a curated reality show not intended for our spiritual good. If TV and the internet had existed back in the days of Saint Augustine and he had chronicled his own conversion process in real time, how many in the crowd would have wowed at his edgy Manichean phase and disappointed when he left that falsity behind for good?