Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Working for Protestants  (Read 11366 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Working for Protestants
« Reply #55 on: December 17, 2012, 10:16:40 AM »
Looking back on this thread, many of my comments towards other members of this forum who offered sound advice seem rash, impatient, insincere, confrontational, uncharitable, and otherwise immature. I apologize. Please understand that at the time I was in a difficult situation that I did not want to be in but was forced into rather obligingly by various factors that were out of my control.

Now, before anyone has a chance to jump up and down saying "I told you so!", I still hold that this issue is more complicated and delicate than some here seem to believe, and I certainly do not think that it is an issue upon which a position can be clearly defined in one sentence.

As for myself, I did not continue work at either Protestant location very long after this thread was created, and I do not plan to take up any such work in the foreseeable future. However, I am in an entirely different living situation now and thankfully I don't think that working in a Protestant church is a realistic or viable option of possible employment.

As an aside, an aspiring traditional Catholic musician can do nothing but despair at the current job market. Frankly, it seems that many traditional Catholics in the pews are content to pay lip service to the need for beautiful art, music, etc (if even that), but when it comes down to money or even just a little effort, no one is willing to budge. I suppose if people don't even want to make an effort to sing themselves, it can't be expected that they care enough to pay someone else to sing or accompany their silence. Ironically, one common defense of the Latin Mass against the Novus Ordo is the aesthetic superiority of the former. Sadly, this is not true (musically speaking) in many, many cases.

I am just a disillusioned youth, wandering aimlessly through a world that is not as rosy as he once thought.

Thank you for bearing with me all these years.

Working for Protestants
« Reply #56 on: December 17, 2012, 05:17:18 PM »
Maybe there is a valuable lesson.  Before embarking on a career make sure there is demand for your skill and you and not basing your future employment on a world that only exists in your dreams.

Lots of people make this mistake writing software to solve a business problem that does not actually exist but which they would like to imagine did.  They then spend three years and a few million bucks finding out what a clear mind and a couple of well placed telephone calls could have told them.

You can lay out a logical argument and suggest there is less demand, you can show them the finances of the people who they hope will be their customers.  But their dream of being gainfully employed in their dream career blinds them to reality.

Or as despair.com a demotivation company in Austin, Texas would say.

"Dreams are like rainbows.  Only idiots chase them"