What the OP describes is more like "female intuition" which can be correct -- but feelings are NOT a reliable indicator of anything. They might tell you, "look into this" but DO look into it -- let your head be in control, not your heart.
Be like Mike...ael the Archangel.
Your feelings aren't necessarily wrong, but they aren't necessarily right either.
I've seen too many people -- male and female, both online and offline -- who live by their feelings, with disastrous results.
There's the Traditional Catholic woman with 4 children who left her husband for an unemployed man. And MANY, many other such disasters. Advising women to always go with their feelings is about the worst advice a person could give!
Their feelings of love, excitement, pride, loyalty, piety, admiration, devotion, etc. for one priest (oh, he travels so much! He is so outnumbered, and is standing up for the truth! He is such a fighter, such a saint! etc.) lead them to YET OTHER feelings, much more negative, towards other priests and the laymen who support them: negative feelings of anger, revulsion, even hatred! And when/if they realize they made the wrong choice, there are temptations to yet OTHER FEELINGS: fear, discouragement, despair, ennui, etc.
Just remember:
We share having emotions with the ANIMALS.
We share having Intelligence/Free Will with the ANGELS.
Aim high. Use your reason, not your emotions.
Again:
Be like Mike...ael the Archangel.