Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?  (Read 3487 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Nous

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 16
  • Reputation: +16/-0
  • Gender: Male
Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
« on: August 13, 2023, 01:49:06 AM »
  • Thanks!3
  • No Thanks!0


  • Greetings,

    Are there any resources/guides on the process of fulfilling a vocation to the monastic life, or perhaps a vocation to becoming a hermit? I did a few searches and found scattered information here and there on the forums, but nothing comprehensive. My location, if it matters, is Southern California.

    I am fairly confident I have a religious vocation, which possibility was first made known to me nearly 20 years ago around the age of 12 during an interaction with a priest (who has posted on this forum before), but I obstinately resisted and banished the thought. I believe it likely it was only through my daily rosary alone - my life certainly has little to no other merits - (which I would never have even prayed daily had it not been for living with my devout parents) that I was spared certain especial punishment at Judgment, forced to confront the truth of my sinful resistance, and given enough time (I pray) to amend my life.

    I single out the monastic life in particular as perhaps the vocation to which I was fitted, because I grew up in a family of some means, and recently I have lost much attachment to material possessions - I do not say “all attachment” lest I render insult to those holy souls who truly live with no attachment, in whose company I hope to one day be. Into this vacuum, I have found that I feel a need to pray almost constantly, which I do - not nearly as well I should, but my mind forms the words.

    Generally speaking, internally I feel the pervasiveness and depth of evil in the world are so great, the solution can only come from Divine intervention, which can only possibly be obtained, I believe, through sufficient souls living lives pleasing to God (which there is a dearth of), upon which God may freely and mercifully deign to use other human means as instruments for a remedy. But the instruments, I believe wholly now (I erroneously did not believe before), are ancillary, though they also be guided and strengthened by God if He so chooses to fit them for His purpose.

    For my entire life I have wasted my modest God-given intellect on frivolities and vanities rather than put it to even cursory effort toward learning the faith; I hope my thoughts here had some semblance of coherence. I welcome correction and clarification.

    Thank you and please pray for me.

    Offline Simeon

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 1349
    • Reputation: +887/-89
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #1 on: August 13, 2023, 08:25:57 AM »
  • Thanks!4
  • No Thanks!0

  • Greetings,

    Are there any resources/guides on the process of fulfilling a vocation to the monastic life, or perhaps a vocation to becoming a hermit? I did a few searches and found scattered information here and there on the forums, but nothing comprehensive. My location, if it matters, is Southern California.

    I am fairly confident I have a religious vocation, which possibility was first made known to me nearly 20 years ago around the age of 12 during an interaction with a priest (who has posted on this forum before), but I obstinately resisted and banished the thought. I believe it likely it was only through my daily rosary alone - my life certainly has little to no other merits - (which I would never have even prayed daily had it not been for living with my devout parents) that I was spared certain especial punishment at Judgment, forced to confront the truth of my sinful resistance, and given enough time (I pray) to amend my life.

    I single out the monastic life in particular as perhaps the vocation to which I was fitted, because I grew up in a family of some means, and recently I have lost much attachment to material possessions - I do not say “all attachment” lest I render insult to those holy souls who truly live with no attachment, in whose company I hope to one day be. Into this vacuum, I have found that I feel a need to pray almost constantly, which I do - not nearly as well I should, but my mind forms the words.

    Generally speaking, internally I feel the pervasiveness and depth of evil in the world are so great, the solution can only come from Divine intervention, which can only possibly be obtained, I believe, through sufficient souls living lives pleasing to God (which there is a dearth of), upon which God may freely and mercifully deign to use other human means as instruments for a remedy. But the instruments, I believe wholly now (I erroneously did not believe before), are ancillary, though they also be guided and strengthened by God if He so chooses to fit them for His purpose.

    For my entire life I have wasted my modest God-given intellect on frivolities and vanities rather than put it to even cursory effort toward learning the faith; I hope my thoughts here had some semblance of coherence. I welcome correction and clarification.

    Thank you and please pray for me.

    Greetings, Nous, in Christ,

    Let me sincerely thank you for this post. It's wonderful!

    First, you cite the Rosary as your salvation and your hope, and so it is. You discern the truth. It is your past, your present, and your future. Good.

    Secondly, you have a strong calling to prayer. Also very, very good. And I would draw your attention to the notion that if one is to devote their life to prayer, then they should pray the most efficacious and powerful prayer available to them - namely the Divine Office, namely the prayer which has an objective rather than a subjective essence, the prayer which is formal and substantial rather than material and founded upon human changeability, the prayer which is infallible, canonized, not belonging to the class of individual prayer, but to the public, corporate prayer of Jesus Christ and His Church.

    This is not so much a prayer we make, but a prayer we enter into. It is a prayer to which we have access by means of our membership in the Mystical Body. When this prayer reaches God's ears, He hears it, infallibly and efficaciously, because it is the Voice of His Son. There is a subjective element - an accidental quality - an element of individual merit; for one must set his will to the yoke of making this prayer daily and regularly, no matter how much the body and the passions flag. But, no matter the feebleness of the one who takes it up, this prayer is great, and full of potency to bring good, and order, and Divine power into the world, by the very agency of its essential objectivity and its Divine institution.

    I wholeheartedly agree with you that the evil onslaught, so horrible and incomprehensible, so vast and metastasized, is incapable of responding to vigorous human intervention, let alone the effeminized impotence of the modern. Corporate action belonging to the temporal sphere is impossible now, due to the paralysis that has set in, the effect of incessant dissolution of natural and supernatural bonds.

    But there is no need to lose hope. For we have remaining to us the principle of the Banner on the battlefield. Down to the last solider, the Flag must be lifted up and carried for all to see. It is the rallying point for the corporate body, for the very kingdom. It must be lifted up, it must be seen and recognized, by the body, by the individual, by the foe.

    There are two orders of the Banner, if I may so nominate. The visible order and the invisible order. Both nature and supernature participate the visible order. For example, we see in history that our Lord himself demanded of the king of France that the image of the Sacred Heart be placed upon the king's banner. I would speculate, however, that only supernature participates the invisible order. This is a mysterious reality, because it involves the direct relation of God and the individual soul, but simultaneously, the individual soul carrying the Banner relates to God also as an agent of the Body, even as the Body itself, just as the lowly battlefield soldier who picks up the fallen flag, represents the kingdom, is the kingdom itself - and yet earns the individual merit of his valor and fidelity.

    I tell you, Nous, that the Banner of which I now speak is the Divine Office. I fervently believe that the Holy Rosary is necessary for salvation, and that if one must make a choice between praying the Office and praying the Rosary, one must choose the Rosary. For devotion to the Mother of God, and fidelity to Her Rosary, is sine qua non for getting in and staying in the state of grace.

    There is an objective quality of the Rosary, which, when prayed corporately, has great coercive power over the agencies of darkness. See Lepanto, et. seq.. Nevertheless, given the vagaries and difficulties of the day, given we have no hierarchy to gather the Rosary in, and make of it the potent weapon it is meant by God to be, it often falls out that the Rosary is relegated to the care of individuals and small bodies, such as families and church congregations. In other words, the Rosary is somewhat at the mercy of men, in its being wielded as a mighty weapon, and therefore fluctuates in its participating the objective and the subjective orders. It is always efficacious, whether it participates either order, for it can save an individual soul or a family from damnation, regardless of any divisions that prevent a more efficacious and organized deployment. But, I think, the Rosary is somewhat dependent on the good will of men, with regard to its quality of participating the objective order.

    Conversely, the Divine Office cannot be removed from the objective order. It is NEVER substantially the prayer of an individual. Even if only one man in a million is faithful to it, even if that man is divided from all other men - materially or psychologically - whenever he prays the Divine Office, he prays in the person of Christ, and in the Person of the Church. Though it does obtain merit for the individual, though it can be offered for souls and intentions, though it absolutely does sanctify the person devoted to it, because it steeps that person's mind in Scripture and Tradition, it is not a subjective prayer. It does not participate the subjective order, except accidentally.

    Make no mistake. Christendom was founded upon the Mass and the Divine Office rising up to God every single day, for hundreds and thousands of days. Christendom rose upon the prayer that belongs to the objective order.

    I can give you no advice about getting into a monastery, but I can suggest a guideline or two.

    1. You are a late bloomer. You've got to play catch-up. You've got to reform yourself, and train yourself. You've really got to go into the desert in your current circuмstances. God will test you in smaller things before He sets upon your shoulders any bigger thing. And I caution you, should a "bigger thing" seem to appear out of nowhere, beware.

    2. If you were in a monastery, your "job" would be to pray the Divine Office. I suggest to you that this is where you might begin in your current circuмstances. You say you feel the need to pray almost constantly, but feel you are not necessarily doing more than forming the words. The Divine Office would regulate your prayer life, train your body and mind to submit to Christ's yoke, and would bathe your soul in the most invigorating spiritual spring.

    3. Should you object that it's too hard to pray the Breviary when one is in the world, because of time constraints and demands, etc, etc., I would only give you myself as an example. I'm a worldling who has prayed it since 1995. I've had tremendous responsibilities in the professional world, which ate up my time like rats eat cheese, yet I made the time for the Breviary, and it was never a burden. In fact, now that I am retired, now that I have all my time to myself, now I find the Breviary a grind!!! Absolutely a temptation!!!

    I'm not in the habit of regurgitating my own posts, but I'm going to spit one up here, because it has long been my ardent desire to inspire other people to take up the Breviary. It can be taken up by many, many more than are willing. It's lying on the battlefield, fallen and un-picked up, is a grave, grave loss to the Church, and to the fight.

    If you simply devote your life to the Mass, the Office, and the Rosary, you will accomplish many things, but above all, I pray for you that you will accomplish God's holy will.

    Pax et Bonum!

    Here's my spit up:

    Quote
    There is a mortification - hard, terrible, perfect, and indubitably efficacious - simple - powerful against the devil........

    and no one is interested in doing it.

    Pray the Divine Office.

    Faithfully.

    Diligently.

    In absolute dryness and aridity and weariness of spirit.

    Alone, with no monastic companions to bolster up your sagging interest.

    Alone, forced to revive yourself and whip your motivation up the steep incline.

    God must be praised. God is not getting His praise. Only His praise, rising up from the earth, can defeat the enemy.

    What were monasteries but places of conscription? Galleys, where those pressed into Divine Service took the Eternal King's shilling. War ships. Armies in battle array, upon which, and upon no other, arose Christendom.

    Put away the hairshirts and chains and cold showers of the body, if you are not first girding and pricking and chaining your mind and your dainty fancies.

    Pray the Divine Office, perseveringly. Allow yourself to become a drafthorse of God.

    divinumofficium.com
       




    Offline AnthonyPadua

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 2145
    • Reputation: +1079/-215
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #2 on: August 13, 2023, 09:30:35 AM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • Greetings, Nous, in Christ,

    Let me sincerely thank you for this post. It's wonderful!

    First, you cite the Rosary as your salvation and your hope, and so it is. You discern the truth. It is your past, your present, and your future. Good.

    Secondly, you have a strong calling to prayer. Also very, very good. And I would draw your attention to the notion that if one is to devote their life to prayer, then they should pray the most efficacious and powerful prayer available to them - namely the Divine Office, namely the prayer which has an objective rather than a subjective essence, the prayer which is formal and substantial rather than material and founded upon human changeability, the prayer which is infallible, canonized, not belonging to the class of individual prayer, but to the public, corporate prayer of Jesus Christ and His Church.

    This is not so much a prayer we make, but a prayer we enter into. It is a prayer to which we have access by means of our membership in the Mystical Body. When this prayer reaches God's ears, He hears it, infallibly and efficaciously, because it is the Voice of His Son. There is a subjective element - an accidental quality - an element of individual merit; for one must set his will to the yoke of making this prayer daily and regularly, no matter how much the body and the passions flag. But, no matter the feebleness of the one who takes it up, this prayer is great, and full of potency to bring good, and order, and Divine power into the world, by the very agency of its essential objectivity and its Divine institution.

    I wholeheartedly agree with you that the evil onslaught, so horrible and incomprehensible, so vast and metastasized, is incapable of responding to vigorous human intervention, let alone the effeminized impotence of the modern. Corporate action belonging to the temporal sphere is impossible now, due to the paralysis that has set in, the effect of incessant dissolution of natural and supernatural bonds.

    But there is no need to lose hope. For we have remaining to us the principle of the Banner on the
    battlefield. Down to the last solider, the Flag must be lifted up and carried for all to see. It is the rallying point for the corporate body, for the very kingdom. It must be lifted up, it must be seen and recognized, by the body, by the individual, by the foe.

    There are two orders of the Banner, if I may so nominate. The visible order and the invisible order. Both nature and supernature participate the visible order. For example, we see in history that our Lord himself demanded of the king of France that the image of the Sacred Heart be placed upon the king's banner. I would speculate, however, that only supernature participates the invisible order. This is a mysterious reality, because it involves the direct relation of God and the individual soul, but simultaneously, the individual soul carrying the Banner relates to God also as an agent of the Body, even as the Body itself, just as the lowly battlefield soldier who picks up the fallen flag, represents the kingdom, is the kingdom itself - and yet earns the individual merit of his valor and fidelity.

    I tell you, Nous, that the Banner of which I now speak is the Divine Office. I fervently believe that the Holy Rosary is necessary for salvation, and that if one must make a choice between praying the Office and praying the Rosary, one must choose the Rosary. For devotion to the Mother of God, and fidelity to Her Rosary, is sine qua non for getting in and staying in the state of grace.

    There is an objective quality of the Rosary, which, when prayed corporately, has great coercive power over the agencies of darkness. See Lepanto, et. seq.. Nevertheless, given the vagaries and difficulties of the day, given we have no hierarchy to gather the Rosary in, and make of it the potent weapon it is meant by God to be, it often falls out that the Rosary is relegated to the care of individuals and small bodies, such as families and church congregations. In other words, the Rosary is somewhat at the mercy of men, in its being wielded as a mighty weapon, and therefore fluctuates in its participating the objective and the subjective orders. It is always efficacious, whether it participates either order, for it can save an individual soul or a family from damnation, regardless of any divisions that prevent a more efficacious and organized deployment. But, I think, the Rosary is somewhat dependent on the good will of men, with regard to its quality of participating the objective order.

    Conversely, the Divine Office cannot be removed from the objective order. It is NEVER substantially the prayer of an individual. Even if only one man in a million is faithful to it, even if that man is divided from all other men - materially or psychologically - whenever he prays the Divine Office, he prays in the person of Christ, and in the Person of the Church. Though it does obtain merit for the individual, though it can be offered for souls and intentions, though it absolutely does sanctify the person devoted to it, because it steeps that person's mind in Scripture and Tradition, it is not a subjective prayer. It does not participate the subjective order, except accidentally.

    Make no mistake. Christendom was founded upon the Mass and the Divine Office rising up to God every single day, for hundreds and thousands of days. Christendom rose upon the prayer that belongs to the objective order.

    I can give you no advice about getting into a monastery, but I can suggest a guideline or two.

    1. You are a late bloomer. You've got to play catch-up. You've got to reform yourself, and train yourself. You've really got to go into the desert in your current circuмstances. God will test you in smaller things before He sets upon your shoulders any bigger thing. And I caution you, should a "bigger thing" seem to appear out of nowhere, beware.

    2. If you were in a monastery, your "job" would be to pray the Divine Office. I suggest to you that this is where you might begin in your current circuмstances. You say you feel the need to pray almost constantly, but feel you are not necessarily doing more than forming the words. The Divine Office would regulate your prayer life, train your body and mind to submit to Christ's yoke, and would bathe your soul in the most invigorating spiritual spring.

    3. Should you object that it's too hard to pray the Breviary when one is in the world, because of time constraints and demands, etc, etc., I would only give you myself as an example. I'm a worldling who has prayed it since 1995. I've had tremendous responsibilities in the professional world, which ate up my time like rats eat cheese, yet I made the time for the Breviary, and it was never a burden. In fact, now that I am retired, now that I have all my time to myself, now I find the Breviary a grind!!! Absolutely a temptation!!!

    I'm not in the habit of regurgitating my own posts, but I'm going to spit one up here, because it has long been my ardent desire to inspire other people to take up the Breviary. It can be taken up by many, many more than are willing. It's lying on the battlefield, fallen and un-picked up, is a grave, grave loss to the Church, and to the fight.

    If you simply devote your life to the Mass, the Office, and the Rosary, you will accomplish many things, but above all, I pray for you that you will accomplish God's holy will.

    Pax et Bonum!

    Here's my spit up:
     
    What's the difference between the divine office and the Breviary?

    Also is there a guide for this? I will look into it more during the week. I need to sleep now and work tomorrow.

    Offline Mr G

    • Sr. Member
    • ****
    • Posts: 2369
    • Reputation: +1533/-91
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #3 on: August 13, 2023, 11:27:41 AM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0

  • Greetings,

    Are there any resources/guides on the process of fulfilling a vocation to the monastic life, or perhaps a vocation to becoming a hermit? I ...
    Have you tried reaching out to the Dominicans? Welcome! - Dominicans of Avrille, France (dominicansavrille.us)

    Offline moneil

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 720
    • Reputation: +560/-62
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #4 on: August 13, 2023, 01:10:06 PM »
  • Thanks!1
  • No Thanks!0
  • First, to answer one question, the Breviary and the Divine Office are two titles of the same liturgy.  There are different versions: The Monastic Breviary, The Roman Breviary (Tridentine), and The Roman Breviary (Divino Afflatu of 1 November 1911).  The latter is the revision of the Breviary promulgated by Pope Saint Pius X.  He eliminated the repetitive recitation of some psalms and rearranged the assignment of when psalms were said during the week.  Some religious orders have their own pre VII versions of the breviary.

    There are also diurnals (Lauds through Compline, without the long Office of Matins and its psalms) and The Little Office of the Blessed Virgin Mary (there are some other “Little Offices”).  The “Little Office” structure is similar to the structure of the Divion Afflatu breviary but with fewer psalms.  I personally use A Short Breviary for Religious and the Laity with which I recite the entire psalter every four weeks, the majority of the psalms are recited every week.

    The “official” breviary includes a reading from the Martyrology at Prime.  I don’t have a copy of the Martyrology but read about the day's saint or if it is a feria some other saint can be read about.  I’ve observed that those saints who became hermits usually were part of a religious community or monastery first.  That is to say, some period of formation before embracing the life of a hermit would be good.  Also, while primarily living a solitary life, hermits still have some connection with a religious community or spiritual father, with whom they periodically meet for Confession, Holy Communion, and spiritual direction.

    Interestingly I will see a hermit this afternoon.  He was part of the small Benedictine Community in the Diocese of Spokane which uses the traditional missal and breviary, but some serious food (and perhaps other) allergies made it difficult for him to live in community.  He was given permission to establish a hermitage in the Blue Mountains and is at the monthly High Mass at St. Patrick’s in Walla Walla, WA, last month he was the Master of Ceremonies.  There is also Our Lady of Clear Creek Abbey in Oklahoma which uses the traditional missal and breviary.  These communities are in communion with their local diocesan bishops, which may or may not suit your perspective.  However, if you would like some contact information you may private message me.  There is also a new Eastern Catholic (Ruthenian) monastery in eastern Oregon I hope to visit soon.  Perhaps others here can provide information from other traditional Catholic groups.

    As another mentioned, the life of a monk or hermit is centered around prayer, and especially the breviary / Divine Office.  In case you are not already familiar with it, the website Divinum Officium https://www.divinumofficium.com has a wealth of information, and one may see the text and rubrics of the various forms of the breviary in Latin and a variety of other languages (click the “Desktop” or “Mobile” tab).  There is also The Roman Breviary Online https://breviary.net/.  This resource was created by Father Bernard Hall to encourage the daily recitation of the breviary.  It is subscription based but offers many resources and much support.  Information about Father Hall is here: https://gspav.org/gspav/guild/contact/




    Offline moneil

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 720
    • Reputation: +560/-62
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #5 on: August 14, 2023, 10:58:17 AM »
  • Thanks!3
  • No Thanks!0
  • I wanted to give this a bump before it disappeared off the “front page” because of the importance of monasticism to the Church since the earliest centuries.  One recalls St. Anthony the Great (also known as   St. Anthony the Abbott and St. Anthony of Egypt), 252 – 356, who is referred to as the Father of Monasticism and Father of All Monks.  His feast day is January 17th.  And there is St. Benedict of Nursia, 480 – 547, who is considered the Father of Western Monasticism, his rule is the norm for monastic life in the west to this day.
     
    There is a body of thought in the Church that monasteries and hermitages are not niceties added on after the “important” structures are set up, but rather, since the earliest centuries, the foundation upon which all the other works are built.  One recalls the story of Martha and Mary (St. Luke 10:38-42) and how Our Lord said that Mary had chosen the best part.  I once read an article by a bishop who said that one of the most important things a bishop could do is to see to the establishment of a monastery of men or women in his diocese, as their prayer is a primary support needed for the other institutions to become established, such as parishes, schools, hospitals, orphanages, and the like.
     
    So, I was very excited to see Nous’ post about his discernment about the monastic life.  I shared the resources I was aware of and mentioned that they may not be suitable for him because of their connection to the “mainstream” Church organization, though they follow the traditional liturgical forms.  I am surprised (my remark is meant to be observatory, not critical) that no one has suggested resources from the traditionalist movement, other than a monastery in France.
     
    While not knowing Nous’ thoughts about the situation in the Church, I’ll make another suggestion.  I notice that there are several CMRI chapels in southern California where he is located.  While I don’t share their “theological opinion” as they call it, they have always seemed to be levelheaded and more focused on doing God’s work rather than arguing about what to do or talking about what other groups are doing wrong.  One of their priests might be a place to start, perhaps as a spiritual director.  One reason I thought of them is that if a call to be a hermit develops, Mount St. Michael’s in Spokane would seem to be an ideal location to have a detached hermitage, while still having access to Confession, Holy Communion, and spiritual direction.

    I came across a couple of articles about modern Catholic hermits which are interesting, granted that the sources and context are not "politically correct" on this forum:

    https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2013/10/28/modern-day-hermits-answering-the-call-to-solitude-prayer/

    https://www.sfcatholic.org/vocations/diocesan-hermits/
     
     



    Offline Simeon

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 1349
    • Reputation: +887/-89
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #6 on: August 14, 2023, 01:17:50 PM »
  • Thanks!1
  • No Thanks!0
  • I wanted to give this a bump before it disappeared off the “front page” because of the importance of monasticism to the Church since the earliest centuries.  One recalls St. Anthony the Great (also known as  St. Anthony the Abbott and St. Anthony of Egypt), 252 – 356, who is referred to as the Father of Monasticism and Father of All Monks.  His feast day is January 17th.  And there is St. Benedict of Nursia, 480 – 547, who is considered the Father of Western Monasticism, his rule is the norm for monastic life in the west to this day.
     
    There is a body of thought in the Church that monasteries and hermitages are not niceties added on after the “important” structures are set up, but rather, since the earliest centuries, the foundation upon which all the other works are built.  One recalls the story of Martha and Mary (St. Luke 10:38-42) and how Our Lord said that Mary had chosen the best part.  I once read an article by a bishop who said that one of the most important things a bishop could do is to see to the establishment of a monastery of men or women in his diocese, as their prayer is a primary support needed for the other institutions to become established, such as parishes, schools, hospitals, orphanages, and the like.
     
    So, I was very excited to see Nous’ post about his discernment about the monastic life.  I shared the resources I was aware of and mentioned that they may not be suitable for him because of their connection to the “mainstream” Church organization, though they follow the traditional liturgical forms.  I am surprised (my remark is meant to be observatory, not critical) that no one has suggested resources from the traditionalist movement, other than a monastery in France.
     
    While not knowing Nous’ thoughts about the situation in the Church, I’ll make another suggestion.  I notice that there are several CMRI chapels in southern California where he is located.  While I don’t share their “theological opinion” as they call it, they have always seemed to be levelheaded and more focused on doing God’s work rather than arguing about what to do or talking about what other groups are doing wrong.  One of their priests might be a place to start, perhaps as a spiritual director.  One reason I thought of them is that if a call to be a hermit develops, Mount St. Michael’s in Spokane would seem to be an ideal location to have a detached hermitage, while still having access to Confession, Holy Communion, and spiritual direction.

    I came across a couple of articles about modern Catholic hermits which are interesting, granted that the sources and context are not "politically correct" on this forum:

    https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2013/10/28/modern-day-hermits-answering-the-call-to-solitude-prayer/

    https://www.sfcatholic.org/vocations/diocesan-hermits/
     
     

    First of all, Moneil, thank you and Anthony Padua for your interest. For some reason it is very difficult to get people interested in this subject. :) I too was delighted to see Nous's post, but even he seems to have taken a powder! LOL!!!

    To Anthony: Moneil's answer to your query is superlative. I would only add that if you are interested in praying the Divine Office (Breviary), you may go to divinumofficium.com, and there you may start praying the Breviary immediately. You don't need to read about rubrics, etc., because the rubrics are built into each office of each day. Simply pray according to what you see on the page, and, voila, you are a monk!

    The only difficulty is choosing which office to pray. The Divino Afflatu is the Pius X promulgation, as Moneil has explained. This is what I pray because it is entirely pre-Bugnini, and contains the Octaves and Feast days that were pulled even from the 62 ritual. There's a drop down box where you can choose which promulgation to pray, and then you simply click on the individual Hours for the prayers.

    It is an education in itself, to compare the various promulgations. You may see what the enemies did in spotlight.

    Moneil makes a great point, namely that "monasteries and hermitages are not niceties added on after the “important” structures are set up, but rather, since the earliest centuries, the foundation upon which all the other works are built." This I believe with all my heart. Christendom was a massive edifice, and as such, it needed a massive foundation. The monasteries were an engine - and the enemies know it. Would only that the Catholics knew it.

    Yet how does this reality translate to the post-conciliar age, when all the foundations have been broken up and thrown in a heap? I firmly believe that the eminent potency of the Office is unscathed, just as the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is unscathed. All that needs to happen is that many  individuals take up the Breviary as the deadly weapon it is. Interestingly we don't need Orders, don't need the Mass, don't need priests, and don't need permissions to pray it. All anyone needs is a dedicated and good will.

    We cannot fight the organized antichristian beast with human weapons. We must fight with prayer, because God alone has the power to break and throw off this monstrosity. We must besiege God - and that which besieges Him most powerfully is praise. The Psalms themselves give witness to this over and over and over.

    We all go around wringing our hands and following closely all the moves of the enemy, while a great weapon lies rusting on the ground, waiting for literally anyone to pick it up and wield it. I don't understand it. Unless Catholics simply do not believe in the power of the Psalms. That's another, and a very sad story.


    Offline Mr G

    • Sr. Member
    • ****
    • Posts: 2369
    • Reputation: +1533/-91
    • Gender: Male


    Offline Kazimierz

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 7682
    • Reputation: +3918/-88
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #8 on: August 14, 2023, 01:52:01 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • Places to fulfill and live amonastic vocation within Tradition are few and far between. You could look at Our Lady of Guadalupe in New Mexico. Neosspx affiliated. Beautiful rugged setting that a visit would grant you a good glimpse into the cenobitic life. As for the hermitical life, good question indeed.
    Da pacem Domine in diebus nostris
    Qui non est alius
    Qui pugnet pro nobis
    Nisi  tu Deus noster

    Offline AnthonyPadua

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 2145
    • Reputation: +1079/-215
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #9 on: August 14, 2023, 04:23:26 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • First of all, Moneil, thank you and Anthony Padua for your interest. For some reason it is very difficult to get people interested in this subject. :) I too was delighted to see Nous's post, but even he seems to have taken a powder! LOL!!!

    To Anthony: Moneil's answer to your query is superlative. I would only add that if you are interested in praying the Divine Office (Breviary), you may go to divinumofficium.com, and there you may start praying the Breviary immediately. You don't need to read about rubrics, etc., because the rubrics are built into each office of each day. Simply pray according to what you see on the page, and, voila, you are a monk!

    The only difficulty is choosing which office to pray. The Divino Afflatu is the Pius X promulgation, as Moneil has explained. This is what I pray because it is entirely pre-Bugnini, and contains the Octaves and Feast days that were pulled even from the 62 ritual. There's a drop down box where you can choose which promulgation to pray, and then you simply click on the individual Hours for the prayers.

    It is an education in itself, to compare the various promulgations. You may see what the enemies did in spotlight.

    Moneil makes a great point, namely that "monasteries and hermitages are not niceties added on after the “important” structures are set up, but rather, since the earliest centuries, the foundation upon which all the other works are built." This I believe with all my heart. Christendom was a massive edifice, and as such, it needed a massive foundation. The monasteries were an engine - and the enemies know it. Would only that the Catholics knew it.

    Yet how does this reality translate to the post-conciliar age, when all the foundations have been broken up and thrown in a heap? I firmly believe that the eminent potency of the Office is unscathed, just as the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is unscathed. All that needs to happen is that many  individuals take up the Breviary as the deadly weapon it is. Interestingly we don't need Orders, don't need the Mass, don't need priests, and don't need permissions to pray it. All anyone needs is a dedicated and good will.

    We cannot fight the organized antichristian beast with human weapons. We must fight with prayer, because God alone has the power to break and throw off this monstrosity. We must besiege God - and that which besieges Him most powerfully is praise. The Psalms themselves give witness to this over and over and over.

    We all go around wringing our hands and following closely all the moves of the enemy, while a great weapon lies rusting on the ground, waiting for literally anyone to pick it up and wield it. I don't understand it. Unless Catholics simply do not believe in the power of the Psalms. That's another, and a very sad story.
    On the website, what is ordo?

    And what language should we pray in?

    I see there is 2 tridentine versions. 
    Is there much difference between them and the Pius X version? 
    Is his objectively superior?

    Do I just go through each

    Matutinum Laudes
    Prima Tertia Sexta Nona
    Vesperae Completorium
    Omnes Plures

    One by one throughout the day? 
    And what times are they? 
    And do they need to be prayed immediately at the start of the hour?
    And how does each one take to pray?
    Is it the same each day of the week?

    Thanks.

    Offline Yeti

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 4065
    • Reputation: +2405/-524
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #10 on: August 14, 2023, 04:34:23 PM »
  • Thanks!3
  • No Thanks!0
  • There are slim pickings for a monastery today, but I have known people that created their own monastic life. Or I guess it was more like the life of a hermit, since they didn't live in a community. What they did was get a job that allowed them to focus on God during the day, i.e. a low-level job that didn't require a lot of attention. Then they spent as much time at work praying to God as they could. This job had a low-paying salary, obviously, which they used to get a tiny place to live, and they lived a very simple, frugal life. They used their time at home after work and on weekends to continue their prayer and recollection. They had little contact with others, especially people who weren't traditional Catholics. They helped out a lot at their local chapel and donated a lot of their time to God.

    You could sure do a lot worse than that as a path to heaven, especially if you aren't able to join a monastery for whatever reason.


    Offline moneil

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 720
    • Reputation: +560/-62
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #11 on: August 14, 2023, 04:46:51 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • An Ordo is the instruction for saying /singing the Mass and reciting the office each day.  It is defined by the Roman Calendar and the rubrics in effect at the time.  For example, what saint is being commemorated or if it's a feria, the rank of the day, the color of vestments, if requiem or votive Masses are allowed that day.

    At the bottom of the Divinum Officium page (after selecting the "desktop" tab) the second from the left drop down box lets you select which version of the breviary you want use.  The web site will always show the breviary text in Latin, and one other language of your choosing, which is the third drop down box from the left ... I recommend a language you are literate in.  Usually only clergy who have a canon law obligation to receite the breviary are required to recite it in Latin, according to the pre vii rubrics.   Above those drop down boxes are hyperlinks where you choose which hour you want to recite.  There are eight:
    The midnight office with readings (Matins), the morning office at daybreak (Lauds), the four daytime hours (the first, third, sixed, and ninth hours), the evening office (Vespers) and the night office (Compline).

    Offline moneil

    • Full Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 720
    • Reputation: +560/-62
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #12 on: August 14, 2023, 04:51:44 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • On the website, what is ordo?

    And what language should we pray in?

    I see there is 2 tridentine versions.
    Is there much difference between them and the Pius X version?
    Is his objectively superior?

    Do I just go through each

    Matutinum Laudes
    Prima Tertia Sexta Nona
    Vesperae Completorium
    Omnes Plures

    One by one throughout the day?
    And what times are they?
    And do they need to be prayed immediately at the start of the hour?
    And how does each one take to pray?
    Is it the same each day of the week?

    Thanks.
    I apologize, I replied before seeing all of your questions, I didn't scroll down.

    Good information is here: https://www.divinumofficium.com/www/horas/Help/rubrics.html
     

    Offline AnthonyPadua

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 2145
    • Reputation: +1079/-215
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #13 on: August 14, 2023, 05:19:57 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0

  • Quote
    Quote from: moneil 15/08/2023, 05:46:51

    An Ordo is the instruction for saying /singing the Mass and reciting the office each day. It is defined by the Roman Calendar and the rubrics in effect at the time. For example, what saint is being commemorated or if it's a feria, the rank of the day, the color of vestments, if requiem or votive Masses are allowed that day.

    At the bottom of the Divinum Officium page (after selecting the "desktop" tab) the second from the left drop down box lets you select which version of the breviary you want use. The web site will always show the breviary text in Latin, and one other language of your choosing, which is the third drop down box from the left ... I recommend a language you are literate in. Usually only clergy who have a canon law obligation to receite the breviary are required to recite it in Latin, according to the pre vii rubrics. Above those drop down boxes are hyperlinks where you choose which hour you want to recite. There are eight:
    The midnight office with readings (Matins), the morning office at daybreak (Lauds), the four daytime hours (the first, third, sixed, and ninth hours), the evening office (Vespers) and the night office (Compline).

    Other than midnight, I don't know what times those are.

    Code: [Select]
    Quote from: moneil 15/08/2023, 05:51:44

    I apologize, I replied before seeing all of your questions, I didn't scroll down.

    Good information is here: https://www.divinumofficium.com/www/horas/Help/rubrics.html



    Thanks, but that link has too much information and is more confusing. I don't want to read articles just pray.

    Offline Meg

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 6790
    • Reputation: +3467/-2999
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Discerning vocation to monastic life/hermit?
    « Reply #14 on: August 14, 2023, 06:11:29 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • Other than midnight, I don't know what times those are.

    Code: [Select]
    Quote from: moneil 15/08/2023, 05:51:44

    I apologize, I replied before seeing all of your questions, I didn't scroll down.

    Good information is here: https://www.divinumofficium.com/www/horas/Help/rubrics.html



    Thanks, but that link has too much information and is more confusing. I don't want to read articles just pray.

    If you can get hold of a St. Andrew Daily Missal (pre-1962 missal, published in the 1940's), it has at least a lengthy morning prayer for laity which is a portion of the canonical office of Prime (Prime being 6:00am prayers). It also has a nice evening prayer, and Vespers for Sunday. Unfortunately, it doesn't give all of the prayers you'd probably want to pray, but it may be a start.

    Here's the explanation provided from the missal for morning prayers, on page 3:

    "Morning Prayers

    "Taken from the Canonical Office of Prime 

    "The Church, ever solicitous for the glory of God and the sanctification of souls, sets apart certain hours of the day and night for prayer. "During the night I arose to sing thy praise," says the psalmist, thus it is that in monasteries Matins are recited in the middle of the night. "Seven times a day do I praise Thee," adds the psalmist, and the official prayer of the Church ascends up to heaven at Lauds (dawn), Prime (first hour 6am), Terce (third hour, 9am) Sext (sixth hour, noon), None (ninth hour, 3pm), Vespers (when the "Vesper" star appears, 5pm) and Compline (night prayers, with which all our duties and occupations come to an end).

    "In order to unite our voices with that of the Church, which sanctifies with its official prayer the first hour of the day, let us recite for our morning prayer a portion of the office of Prime."
    "It is licit to resist a Sovereign Pontiff who is trying to destroy the Church. I say it is licit to resist him in not following his orders and in preventing the execution of his will. It is not licit to Judge him, to punish him, or to depose him, for these are acts proper to a superior."

    ~St. Robert Bellarmine
    De Romano Pontifice, Lib.II, c.29