This is a fantastic thread! I'm technically a Millennial, but being the youngest of my family, I was raised hanging around my older Gen X siblings, so I identify with the original post more than Sean's list. My score on Matthew's pole was a 1 only because I didn't have an aol email address, I had a yahoo email those days.
However, I can attest to the following from Sean's list:
1) Used a pay phone;
I not only used pay phones, but my mom's instructions were always to collect call when I was ready to be picked up from somewhere. She would decline to accept the charges, but knew that it meant that she could come get me from the pre-decided pick-up location.
6) Went to a drive-in movie;
I still remember my first double feature at the drive-in. It was Ghostbusters 2 and Batman. My mom made the popcorn ahead of time at home and we all loaded into the station wagon. I was 5, and that was as cool as it got.
7) Went to a video arcade;
There were no arcades where I lived, but there was a laundromat a few blocks away that had pinball and a few arcade games.
8) Watched movies from a movie projector (at school, theatre, etc.);
Yes, movie day in grade school was the best!
9) Your teachers used overhead projectors;
Yes, overhead projectors and chalk boards, no dry erase in my childhood.
10) Thre were only 1-2 queers in your huge public school;
I'm sure there may have been 1 or 2, but none that were open or celebrated about it.
16) Had an electric can opener;
Yes indeed
18) Had a Green Machine;
I never did, but my kids have one now, although it is not easy for them to ride on our gravel driveway due to the plastic, tread-less rear wheels.
20) Boiled your hot dogs.
Still do