Do you have your own experience in mind solitary Man, or is this a hypothetical question?
An extremely modern and unnatural perspective. What greater gift can you give a child than a younger brother or sister. Why would a child resent having to spent time helping their mother with a younger brother or sister.
Today children are raised to expect everything and to give nothing. Love in the family is a rarity for many in this affluent materialistic society where children are seen of little value. It is uncommon to be taught responsibility and care for others.
How many saints were raised by a sibling? You might be surprised. Was St Therese of the Child Jesús a burden and a cause of resentment to her big sisters? She is the first one who comes to mind.
Better for a child to be cared for by a sibling than sent to a day care as is done in the so-called civilised word.
I will respond to your objections
1 I am of Italian descent, yes, I have experience
I met both my own family, as well as other people and friends
2 modern perspective? I know people aged 70 who said it was very difficult to take care of their siblings, isn't it natural? Just ask and see what people say! About the present, I met people who loved their brothers very much, but admitted that it was very tiring to take care of them, they often took care of them all alone! what child would be resentful, I'm sorry to say that you are a person who doesn't know how to read well, donating your time and helping your parents, it's a virtue, but imagine, not being able to rest and barely being able to study because of this task because You are the main responsible ! That's why these are the cases I mentioned!
3 I partly agree with you, but family love also comes from the support of parents and I never said they shouldn't help and again you accuse me of being a heretic !because I don't read well or because you want to accuse me of being a heretic and a modernist for the pleasure of your own ego!
4 saints, in fact, however, remember that parents often had to work and in the case of Saint Therese, there were several older sisters taking care of one, the cases I mentioned were 1 or 2 taking care of several alone and remember- If the church says that the ideal is for parents to raise!
Now I ask you, do you have experience?
Do you live in a Catholic bubble?
Furthermore, you have a very unempathetic and romantic view of the world!
conclusion
I never said that brothers shouldn't help
Children must help their parents and parents must teach their children the virtue of work, both at work and at home.