Science finally caught up to TRUTH !

Unless all these miracles involve hosts from the Traditional Latin Mass, offered by a priest ordained in the pre-Vatican II rite by a bishop who was consecrated in the traditional rite, this seriously calls into doubt the idea that the Novus Ordo is not a valid Eucharistic sacrifice, and calls into doubt the idea that the new rites of ordination and/or consecration are per se invalid.

Just saying.

It’s not 0% valid or 100% valid.  This is not an either-or / all or none scenario.  Good golly, guys, your logic is horrible.  

The amount of variables associated with the new rites is HUGE.  NOBODY EVER SAID THAT ALL NEW RITES ARE INVALID.  We're saying we don’t know which ones are valid.   And you don’t know either.  

And if you’re trying to argue that it’s all or none, then you’re a simpleton and have no business discussing theology.  

Unless all these miracles involve hosts from the Traditional Latin Mass, offered by a priest ordained in the pre-Vatican II rite by a bishop who was consecrated in the traditional rite, this seriously calls into doubt the idea that the Novus Ordo is not a valid Eucharistic sacrifice, and calls into doubt the idea that the new rites of ordination and/or consecration are per se invalid.

Just saying.

Could not the Hosts be consecrated during a NO mess by a valid priest pronouncing the valid words of consecration?
What you describe is what we all hope for but is it possible?

For those who are more scholarly

https://philarchive.org/archive/BUCFPT-4

Incredible! All these Eucharistic Miracles do indeed support the case that the New Rite Masses are valid. And by extension, the New Rite priests of these Masses are valid. The miracle of the 'X' only chromosome proves they are one and the same miracle: the body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ.

This is false. Church teaching states that if any private revelation or miracle contradicts Catholic teaching in the slightest degree then it is a false miracle that comes from the devil.

Since the new rites have a POSITIVE doubt these miracles are fake and come from the devil. He has been allowed to do this to keep bad willed weak ignorant 'Catholics' with little to no faith in the false vatican 2 religion.

It is very easy for the devil to fool human instruments.

Borat, the Modernist troll, continuing the apologetic for the Novus Ordo sect.  Shocking.

As others have pointed out, the Catholic attitude is that we don't shape our doctrine and theology in response to "miracles", but judge purported "miracles" by theology.  It's one of the FIRST thing the Church does in making a judgemt about such phenomena, holding it up to the light of Catholic doctrine.  If it fails there, you don't pass Go.

Several of these incontrovertible "miracles" were later demonstrated to have been bacteria and/or fungus.  You'll notice the nearly identical story in the two different Polish ones, where a host had been dropped on the ground, and then reserved somewhere, and then some time later there was some red discoloration found on it.  OK, when there's fungus and bacteria in your environment, dropping a host on the floor would contaminate it.  Speaking of mowing lawns (which Borat made a big production about doing in a skirt), you can see at certain times of the year (at least in my part of the country), that you'll see this red dust, a red fungus coating your lawn mower, and even your shoes, and quite possibly Borat's skirt.

But EVEN THEN, even IF these could be established with scientific certainty (they have not), it would be childsplay for a demon to simulate a miracle ... where all he'd have to do is to grab a sample of blood or tissue and apply it to to the host, perhaps swap out a bit of the bread.  Piece of cake for a demon.

Now, let's say the NOM is invalid.  Well, if I'm the devil, then I want to convince as many people as I can that it's valid.  How do I go about that?  Well, this would be one very effective way to do that ... as even Bishop Willaimson ended up being fooled by this nonsense.