Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?  (Read 4061 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?
« Reply #15 on: February 19, 2021, 03:37:04 AM »
Correction:

unchangeable/speculative

Re: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?
« Reply #16 on: February 19, 2021, 04:56:42 AM »
Dear Donkath, I agree with your basic point. What is important, after we learn the Faith, is to live the Faith. To pray and sacrifice for sinners to be converted, for non-Catholics to become Catholic, and for souls to be saved. We can and must hold to the basics or essentials of the Faith, as taught in any Catechism, and then strive to grow in grace, in holiness, in charity every day of our lives. 

The issue of explicit-implicit faith may be important in theological discussions, like that between the SSPX and Rome. It is not very important for the average Catholic. The average Catholic only needs to know and believe that non-Catholics need to be brought to the Faith by prayer and evangelism and every available means.. We can and must exert all our efforts, and our prayers and sacrifices, to save souls. 

My issue with the Dimonds is they mislead people, and sometimes lead souls outside the Church. If they were baptizing non-Christians or evangelizing non-Catholics to the Church and the Faith, who would argue with them? They believe almost everyone except themselves are heretics, and anathematize just about everybody. That leads imo to a schismatic attitude and a "Church of 2" mentality.

God Bless.


Re: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?
« Reply #17 on: February 19, 2021, 06:37:20 AM »
Much appreciated.


Offline Ladislaus

  • Supporter
Re: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?
« Reply #18 on: February 19, 2021, 07:17:36 AM »
What are you looking for, precisely? Do you want me to condemn Archbishop Lefebvre or Bishop Fellay? I'm not going to do that.

No, we're asking you to have the integrity to simply disagree with them.  None of us has the authority to "condemn" anyone?
YES OR NO.  Do you disagree with +Lefebvre and +Fellay on this issue?

I know you tried some mental gymnastics about what +Fellay actually might have mean, but it's very clear what he meant.  So based on the obvious face-value meaning of what he said, do you disagree with +Fellay and +Lefebvre regarding the possibility of salvation for unconverted infidels?

Your honest answer here could perhaps begin to establish you as someone who is intellectually honest, so don't let this opportunity for personal growth pass you by.

If you continue to slither around this question, then there's no need for anyone to discuss these issues with you.

Re: XavierSem - Will He Answer the Simple Question?
« Reply #19 on: February 19, 2021, 07:32:30 AM »
I come to the end of a relatively short journey with XavierSem wherein I purposely refrained from debating the slightest details with him him, just probing to learn the big picture of his endless copy and pasting of haphazardly arranged misquotes, what others call spam. I did this because language, words, have no fixed meaning with people like him, for every word that comes out of their mouth means other than what the world understands it to mean. I speak both English and Spanish fluently, everyone has a native language, German, Italian, Hungarian, Polish..... The language of the Satan is lies. People like XavierSem are incapable of communicating in truth, because their language has no fixed meaning. Their language is like rat poison. Did you know that rat poison is 99% nutritious food? Nevertheless, the 1% will kill you just the same. One can't remove the 1% out of the nutritious food because it is interspersed in every molecule of the nutritious food. It is the same with people like XavierSem, their language is rat poison, their every word is poisoned by not having a fixed meaning, their every word does not mean what one thinks it does. So how do you talk or debate with such a person? You can't. There is no way. This is why it took so long for him to answer my simple question, which he still really has not answered, I had to answer it for him.

Modernism is the synthesis of all heresies, the cesspool of all heresies, it is of the Father of Lies, and double speak is in it's every molecule. The very air of all the heresies of the "spirit" of Vatican, is double speak, words that do not mean what they have always meant, nothing is fixed, everything is floating in the air. The camouflage of those possessed by double speak is false humility, an appeal to peoples sentiments. One will see XavierSem appeal to people's sentiments whenever he is cornered to reveal what he really means. It is the same cloak worn by John Paul II and Benedict X16, both examples of double speak, false humility,  and rat poison.