https://mostholytrinityseminary.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Combined-Feeney-articles-red.pdf
Porro fide divina et catholica ea omnia credenda sunt, quae in verbo Dei scripto vel tradito continentur, et ab Ecclesia sive solemni iudicio sive ordinario et universali magisterio tamquam divinitus revelata credenda proponuntur.
vatican.vaWherefore, by divine and catholic faith all those things are to be believed which are contained in the word of God as found in scripture or tradition, and proposed by the church, whether by solemn judgment or the ordinary and universal magisterium as matters to be believed as divinely revealed.
In the pamphlet, linked by augistineeens, Cekada twists the infallible teaching of the Vatican Council. Cekada quotes the above teaching of the Vatican Council, and at the same time misrepresents it, adding disruptive emphasis and adding a punctuation mark, to twist the meaning (see Section I, I., A.). He then explicitly confirms his intention to eliminate an important condition by restating the teaching in his own words, omitting the condition (see Section I, I., C.).
The condition is "to be believed as divinely revealed". The Council is not speaking about everything which is proposed to be believed, but about those things which are proposed
to be believed as divinely revealed.
So much for the first misrepresentation of infallible truth solemnly proposed by the extraordinary magisterium of the Church of the Lord.
Cekada goes ahead, twisting the words of Pope Pius IX (see Section I, II.):
II. You must believe those teachings of the universal ordinary
magisterium held by theologians to belong to the faith
(Pius IX).
• “For even if it were a matter concerning that subjection which
is to be manifested by an act of divine faith, nevertheless, it would
not have to be limited to those matters which have been defined by
express decrees of the ecuмenical Councils, or of the Roman Pon-
tiffs and of this See, but would have to be extended also to those
matters which are handed down as divinely revealed by the ordi-
nary teaching power of the whole Church spread throughout the
world, and therefore, by universal and common consent are held
by Catholic theologians to belong to faith.” Tuas Libenter (1863),
DZ 1683.
Pope Pius IX says "matters which are handed down as divinely revealed, and therefore ... held ... by Catholic theologians as
de fide." Cekada, in the heading, swaps cause and effect, and claims that we must believe, not what in fact was handed down as divinely revealed, not what in fact was handed down
by the magisterium as
divinely revealed, but what
theologians hold to belong to the faith.
Then, Cekada goes ahead teaching all sorts of ideas selected from his linear meters of manuals, completely ignoring the magisterium. He starts his Section II with the heading:
Why the Church Requires You
to Believe or Adhere to Doctrines
Commonly Taught by her Theologians.
[...]
I. Introductory Concepts.
A. Definition of Theologian = “learned man who after the time of the Church Fathers scientifically taught sacred doctrine in the Church.”
Science replaces the magisterium, Cĭcāda cantat (the locust chirps).
Forget the magisterium, Cĭcāda presents scientific proof, why it's safe to do so:
IV. Thesis: The unanimous teaching of theologians in matters
of faith and morals establishes certitude for the proof of a dogma.
May the Lord have mercy on this scorpion.