Father Feeney and the cause of St. Benedict Center and the "Feeneyites" would have been totally unnecessary if the wise counsel of Pius IX was not neglected:
Indeed, Father Feeney's cause was simply about EENS, with Father Feeney holding fast to this admonition from Pope Pius IX. Only later did BoD even enter the picture, as it was being used disingenuously in order to undermine EENS dogma. There isn't a true "Feeneyite" around who would make a big deal about someone holding BoD who did not at the same time believe that salvation could be had in any religion. BoD was gradually extended to cover the case of those who did not profess the Catholic faith, whereas it was originally only understood to apply to catechumens. But the modern-day promoters of BoD could hardly care less about the relatively-rare case of a catechumen who died before Baptism; rather, their only intention in promoting it is to leverage BoD in order to overturn and undermine EENS dogma.
Pius IX, and Pope after Pope after Pope, explicitly condemned the notion that salvation could be had in any other religion than in the observance of the true Catholic religion. Yet we have Trad after Trad after Trad claiming that "Hindus in Tibet" and Jews and Muslims and Protestants and any men of good will, practically, can be saved in the observance of their religion. WHAT PART OF CONDEMNED do you folks not understand?
There was a poster here named Arvinger that most of us "Feeneyites" saw as an ALLY in this polemic rather than an adversary, even though he himself believed in BoD ... because he limited it to only those who had the Catholic faith, and did not extend it to heretics and infidels. This is the common dishonest tactic of BoDers, to hurl out pro-BoD quotes from St. Thomas, St. Robert Bellarmine, St. Alphonsus, etc. ... implying that these men thereby (i.e. by their support of BoD) also support the false lengths to which modern BoDers apply the notion, practically imputing to these Doctors the belief that non-Catholics can be saved, whereas in point of fact they explicitly rejected that.
Also, if Jews, Muslims, Hindus, and Protestants can be saved, then they must be in the Church ... since outside the Church there can be no salvation. So, now we have a Church that includes non-Catholics. So, sure, it subsists of Catholics, but it is not limited to them, but includes many non-Catholics as well. Starting to sound familiar yet?