Author Topic: Celebrating the death of the Feeneyite heresy (Read 2776 times)

saintbosco13 · « **on:** February 16, 2017, 11:54:45 AM »

It's great to finally see the Feeneyite heresy come to an end after all these years. What a catastrophe! How do we know it is finally extinguished? Here are some obvious signs:

- For one, activity in this sub-forum has been drying up. The primary activity remaining is people bickering about individual quotes - as if that matters with the amount of magisterial support for the doctrine available. If you are still bothering to sling quotes back and forth, you are simply a novice and you are completely missing the boat.

- The website baptismofdesire.com has now been online for 4 years. If you look at their News page, they have openly challenged many of the most rabid opposers of baptism of desire to read their homepage and let them know where it is an error. They have ALL been silent for the last 4 years. That says it all. In addition, that site has received just as many conceding to the doctrine as those challenging it.

- Overall there have been no solid arguments over the years - just the same old beating of the dead horse from people trying to interpret what it all means on their own, instead of listening to the ordinary magisterium. Even 400 years after the Protestant revolt, they still fall into the same old trap of self interpretation. Pretty sad.

Great to see this finally extinguished after all these years! Time to focus on real Catholicism...

happenby · « **Reply #1 on:** February 16, 2017, 12:02:42 PM »

Quote from: saintbosco13

It's great to finally see the Feeneyite heresy come to an end after all these years. What a catastrophe! How do we know it is finally extinguished? Here are some obvious signs:

- For one, activity in this sub-forum has been drying up. The primary activity remaining is people bickering about individual quotes - as if that matters with the amount of magisterial support for the doctrine available. If you are still bothering to sling quotes back and forth, you are simply a novice and you are completely missing the boat.

- The website baptismofdesire.com has now been online for 4 years. If you look at their News page, they have openly challenged many of the most rabid opposers of baptism of desire to read their homepage and let them know where it is an error. They have ALL been silent for the last 4 years. That says it all. In addition, that site has received just as many conceding to the doctrine as those challenging it.

- Overall there have been no solid arguments over the years - just the same old beating of the dead horse from people trying to interpret what it all means on their own, instead of listening to the ordinary magisterium. Even 400 years after the Protestant revolt, they still fall into the same old trap of self interpretation. Pretty sad.

Great to see this finally extinguished after all these years! Time to focus on real Catholicism...

There is no such thing as baptism of desire. Proof is found in one sentence in the docuмents of Trent. It is impossible to read Trent in a way that supports baptism of desire. Both water of regeneration and desire are necessary for salvation. I have never been associated with Fr. Feeney or the Benedict Center, so whatever Feeneyism is, I am not of that group. I just know what the Church teaches and baptism of desire is an evolving extrapolation that denies Catholic teaching.

Ladislaus · « **Reply #2 on:** February 16, 2017, 12:05:01 PM »

Quote from: saintbosco13

Overall there have been no solid arguments over the years

:roll-laugh1:

Ladislaus · « **Reply #3 on:** February 16, 2017, 12:07:18 PM »

Quote from: Ladislaus

Quote from: saintbosco13
Overall there have been no solid arguments over the years

:roll-laugh1:

You came on here for a while and put your ignorance and theological ineptitude on display. You were destroyed, put to shame, and forced to turn tail.

Now you return to make the gratuitous assertion that you have refuted all arguments.

It's difficult to believe that you're serious.

LoT, you do have an incredible ego.

happenby · « **Reply #4 on:** February 16, 2017, 12:50:07 PM »

A true Catholic should celebrate the Sacraments while they despise the non-baptism bod designed by Satan to undermine and destroy the Sacrament of Baptism.