I tentatively backed off of my original belief that BOD is dogmatic (per Saint Alphonsus) due to the fact that several other theologians hold it to a lesser theological note.
Well, the majority in Father Cekada's survey did not consider it
de fide. Nevertheless, you're entitled to opine that it is. Given the history of what is obviously nothing more than speculation and not rooted in the Deposit of Revelation, nor can it be proven theologically as deriving from the Deposit, it can never become anything more than speculation.
I await a demonstration of how BoD is revealed truth, a theological demonstration, and a gratuitous assertion of any opinion. In order for BoD to be dogmatic, it must have been revealed. Where's the evidence that this was revealed. In fact, there's a mountain of evidence that it was not revealed.