Quote from: umblehay anmay

Can someone please watch this video and show me where St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Alphonsis taught what is shown in the video.

http://www.youtube.com/user/mhfm1#p/u/197/J01vVszOObY

I watched it (most of it, anyway).  Naturally, no one will provide any citations, etc., .
Oddly, those of the Dimonds' and Hietanen's persuasion will make truly absurd (as in, irrational and completely implausible) excuses on the part of St. Alphonsus, but grant ZERO latitude to modern men who, for all they know, are of good will.  Tis just an observation.  Do with it what you will...

I just went back and re-read this.   Maybe I misread this the first time around, but you say "because the two Doctors you mentioned did not teach what is mentioned in the video".       Well, Bro. Dimond dosen't even bring up  anything but the dogmatic definitions.  But to reply to your question, what the two Doctors who even posed the possibility of BOD did say about it is nothing at all similar to the modernist interpretation of the dogma that developed into what is being taught even by the Trady Priests of today.   And the reason the Dimonds give less latitude to the "modern" men, IMO is that we today have access to ALL the info at our fingertips to review and discuss.  We have the ability to put everything in to proper order and perspective and look at the issues in total.  

Why did you have to turn the focus of this video from what it was truly about (the false teachings from the SSPX) into a straw man argument about the Doctors of the Church who aren't even mention in the video?

I'll read through the rest of the pages, but did you ever address the actual point of the video?  Or is diversion the only recourse to take so that the actual point of the video can be suppressed?


   

Bumping for Iuvenalis.