Catholic Info

Traditional Catholic Faith => Anσnymσus Posts Allowed => Topic started by: Änσnymσus on May 27, 2019, 08:40:00 PM

Title: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 27, 2019, 08:40:00 PM
Or at least it seems to be the case with me, because I have read countless times that saints got answers to things they were asking/praying for even before they finished praying or by the time they finished.

I've also read stories here I believe, of people getting answers quickly etc.

But I have been praying for years to know something I believe to be very important, and have yet to receive an answer.

I have been wanting to know for about 7 years what to do with my life, as in, what job/career/business I should get into, because what I have been doing for the past year and a half is something temporary of its very nature and not enough to raise a family, much less save for the future/invest etc.

I'm 29 and male. I hate to have these thoughts, but why does God make it so hard? Why can't He give me an answer to what I have been asking for for years? Is this not important? If I knew the perfect answer to what my brother or father should do with their lives, I would not hesitate to let them know if they asked. Heck, I would let them know even if they didn't ask me at all, because I know they would probably be super grateful to know.

I absolutely hate not having a goal or not knowing what I should get into. Sure, I am learning some new things right now to get into a new industry and probably make more money, but I'm not sure I really like it and I don't know if it will pay off.

There's just too much information out there right now, and we can't be sure we will take the right decisions.

How does one even decide what to do? I would think God cares what I do for a living, so I don't really believe that it should be just about thinking what it is that you like the most and trying to pursue it and see if you make money with it. We can't see the future and we seldom have our best interests in mind, so why doesn't God let me know what I should do?

I'm not even asking for miracles or an instantaneous answer. But I would think anywhere from a week to a month would be reasonable, but seven years and no answer? I'm not getting any younger and the more time passes by, the worse things get. The less time you have to invest, buy a house, save money, raise a family, etc.

I've prayed almost the entire time for these 7 years, the Rosary in specific, and I have tried my best to live a clean, good life, but of course I have fallen and still fall often. Still, I have not given up and have been trying, but these kinds of things make me just want to throw in the towel and stop praying for good.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 27, 2019, 09:31:29 PM
That’s a tough spot to be in.  We’ve all been there, at times in our life.  Many times God uses such situations to test our Faith but also to help us learn perseverance and patience.  Further, as only God can do, He often is preparing us for future success, when He plans to answer us in a big, big way.  

As one of the Saints said, God originates the desires in our heart so that He can later fulfill such desires.  God never gives us desires He won’t fulfill, though they may not be on our timetable and in the exact way we picture it. 

The Saints often were answered in prayer but many times were not answered too.  But no matter the answer, they were satisfied because they usually didn’t pray for specific ends, but prayed for the goal of “God’s will”.  Thus, in any scenario, they were happy. 

Pray for fortitude, for courage, for hope.  Many times in life, we can look back and see how things made sense and worked out perfectly.  But in the moment, we can not see God’s wisdom at work, who knows all things - past, present and future.  He knew from all eternity that you would pray (and be challenged) by this situation.  Trust in His Divine Providence.  Trust in His plan.  And for the anxieties and sufferings you still have, offer them up for the souls in purgatory.  Suffering is a great grace. 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Nadir on May 27, 2019, 11:47:25 PM
Or at least it seems to be the case with me, because I have read countless times that saints got answers to things they were asking/praying for even before they finished praying or by the time they finished.

I've also read stories here I believe, of people getting answers quickly etc.

But I have been praying for years to know something I believe to be very important, and have yet to receive an answer.

I have been wanting to know for about 7 years what to do with my life, as in, what job/career/business I should get into, because what I have been doing for the past year and a half is something temporary of its very nature and not enough to raise a family, much less save for the future/invest etc.

I'm 29 and male. I hate to have these thoughts, but why does God make it so hard? Why can't He give me an answer to what I have been asking for for years? Is this not important? If I knew the perfect answer to what my brother or father should do with their lives, I would not hesitate to let them know if they asked. Heck, I would let them know even if they didn't ask me at all, because I know they would probably be super grateful to know.

I absolutely hate not having a goal or not knowing what I should get into. Sure, I am learning some new things right now to get into a new industry and probably make more money, but I'm not sure I really like it and I don't know if it will pay off.

There's just too much information out there right now, and we can't be sure we will take the right decisions.

How does one even decide what to do? I would think God cares what I do for a living, so I don't really believe that it should be just about thinking what it is that you like the most and trying to pursue it and see if you make money with it. We can't see the future and we seldom have our best interests in mind, so why doesn't God let me know what I should do?

I'm not even asking for miracles or an instantaneous answer. But I would think anywhere from a week to a month would be reasonable, but seven years and no answer? I'm not getting any younger and the more time passes by, the worse things get. The less time you have to invest, buy a house, save money, raise a family, etc.

I've prayed almost the entire time for these 7 years, the Rosary in specific, and I have tried my best to live a clean, good life, but of course I have fallen and still fall often. Still, I have not given up and have been trying, but these kinds of things make me just want to throw in the towel and stop praying for good.
A few random thoughts in response to your post:

You don't say anything about what you have done or what you are doing, what training or skills you possess, or what responsibilities you have right now.

Have you put aside a nest egg for your future?

Do you have a religious vocation?

Has God already answered you and you weren't listening?

It sounds almost as if you are expecting God to act/decide for you.

I wonder if you don't have too much choice. Most people in the world work to live, but you seem to imply that work is to be something you "like" and that pleases you.


Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 12:41:57 AM
I tend to think of God's influence in our lives to be like a steering wheel. We know that when something isn't moving forward, the steering wheel can't help to move it in the right direction. But, when the vehicle is in motion, the wheel easily guides it down the right path.

I go about my life always trying to choose and do things for myself with the expectation that, through prayer, if my choices aren't the right ones, God will nudge me in the right direction by creating opportunities or obstacles depending on where He wants me to go.

So, set some goals and work toward them. If God doesn't approve, you'll know it when your plans fail and you have to make new ones.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on May 28, 2019, 05:33:06 AM
Or at least it seems to be the case with me, because I have read countless times that saints got answers to things they were asking/praying for even before they finished praying or by the time they finished.

I've also read stories here I believe, of people getting answers quickly etc.

But I have been praying for years to know something I believe to be very important, and have yet to receive an answer.
Needless to say, we are not saints, but yes, sometimes answers happen astonishingly quickly - although not usually in the form of a clear answer to a question or to a prayer, rather, the answer sometimes comes across more like a result.

After 7 years, although I certainly don't know, it seems obvious to me that it is very likely that God accepts whatever it is you have been doing as being acceptable to Him, even if it's not fine with you.


Quote
I absolutely hate not having a goal or not knowing what I should get into. Sure, I am learning some new things right now to get into a new industry and probably make more money, but I'm not sure I really like it and I don't know if it will pay off.

People learn many things, learn many trades and will sometimes, for a variety of reasons, even switch careers.

You're a young man and have no idea what your future holds - so let God know what your plans are and then do them - and ask Him often to guide you and bless whatever it is you decide you want to try - He can bless your efforts no matter what you do, just as He will offer you a way out if it turns out that endeavour puts your soul is in danger. Your soul, after all, is what God is mainly concerned with.

Keep the faith man, (Mat. 7:8 ) For every one that asketh, receiveth: and he that seeketh, findeth: and to him that knocketh, it shall be opened.

Whatever we ask necessary to salvation with humility, fervour, perseverance, and other due circuмstances, we may be assured God will grant when it is best for us. If we do not obtain what we pray for, we must suppose it is not conducive to our salvation, in comparison of which all else is of little moment. (Haydock)
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Pax Vobis on May 28, 2019, 09:25:05 AM
Here's some practical advice for the OP:

Quote
I have been wanting to know for about 7 years what to do with my life, as in, what job/career/business I should get into, because what I have been doing for the past year and a half is something temporary of its very nature and not enough to raise a family, much less save for the future/invest etc.
We need more info from you, to help out.  Did you go to college?  What is your major?  If not, what kind of skills do you have?  What are your hobbies?  What interests you?

Can you start a side business to make extra money? 
Quote
I absolutely hate not having a goal or not knowing what I should get into. Sure, I am learning some new things right now to get into a new industry and probably make more money, but I'm not sure I really like it and I don't know if it will pay off.
"Pray as if it all depends on God; act as if it all depends on you."  God often answers prayers by circuмstances, or through people's advice, or through orders of superiors.  In other words, He does not normally speak directly to you.  Even in the lives of the Saints, their prayers were answered through NATURAL means, because we are natural creatures.

Secondly, a job is a job is a job.  Don't fall into the trap that a career will satisfy you, or that a career is what you should be looking for.  Few, few, FEW people in life have a career (I speak from experience here and the many, many friends I have who came to this realization).  The idea that we can all "find the perfect career" is a romantic ideal, much like the idea of "finding the one" in dating.  There isn't only one person you could marry and be happy with, and there isn't only 1 job path you can take to be successful.  The only types of people who have careers are those who are highly specialized - doctors, scientists, (and some types of) lawyers.  Every other skill is highly transferrable to many different types of companies and industries.

Thirdly, you should have multiple goals in life, many of them that have NOTHING to do with a job.  You should have health, religious, intellectual, social, hobby, and personal goals.  Don't let a setback/pause in one goal derail your progress in your other goals.  You are more than just a career. 

Quote
How does one even decide what to do? I would think God cares what I do for a living, so I don't really believe that it should be just about thinking what it is that you like the most and trying to pursue it and see if you make money with it. We can't see the future and we seldom have our best interests in mind, so why doesn't God let me know what I should do?
Follow your talents, not your passions.  (Some people's talents and passions are the same - this is unique, not the norm).  You can have a passion for snowboarding but if you aren't good enough to go professional, you'll be a homeless snowboarder.  If you have a talent for mechanic work, then go develop your talent and you'll be successful.  Happiness is not a goal, it's a by-product from being successful.  If you work hard to develop your talents, you'll do good work, you'll be successful and you'll be happy because of it.

Most people have many varied talents, but 1 or 2 which stand out.  As Aristotle said, "We are what we repeatedly do."  What do your hobbies tell you about your talents?  If you had 2-3 free days, how would you fill your time?  Go ask trusted people in your life to help you find this out.  Ask them what they think your talents are.  Seek wisdom from wise and trusted friends/family.  God will guide you through them.
Quote
There's just too much information out there right now, and we can't be sure we will take the right decisions.
Don't over think it.  It's just a job.  Don't fall for "analysis paralysis".  Update your resume, post it out there.  Take some interviews.  Go see what happens.  You're still very young.  Try a different industry.  Try a different job setting.  Go find a job that pays more and give it a whirl.  Sometimes you won't know if you like something until you try it.  Fail until you succeed.

In today's economy, there is less and less stability since companies are merging with other companies and globalism forces them to change strategies constantly, which affects jobs and industry needs.   Many of us won't have stable careers; we won't be with the same company for 20+ years, or even 5.  You should probably look to change jobs every 1-2 years.  Companies setup their positions and expect employees to get bored and move up or move on.  Employees are expected to develop themselves; you do that by changing jobs, learning new skills from that new job, and having a wide variety of experiences.  Eventually you'll find a type of work you're good at or some general skills.  But that doesn't mean you won't keep having to change jobs.  Change is the new constant in the economy.

If you provide more details in this thread (or send me a PM) I might be able to give more specific advice.  I've been where you are (and in some respects, still am).
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 10:00:56 AM
Praying about what is God’s will for our lives is good - but we also need to do the leg work and can’t always expect to just get an answer handed down from Heaven. That’s not an accusation, it’s a fact. In my own life, I have had to “change hats” (for lack of a better phrase) several times by necessity. Sometimes, you begin a job/career with great expectation and hard work ethic and it doesn’t pan out. I worked for a friend where I did crazy hours all the time, hard slugging, getting up insanely early and getting home insanely late sometimes with very little pay that I had to bother them for, all with the promise of “one day this will pay off” and of course I found another job and walked away (the friendship is less then existent) and start again. But I was promised a great career! That’s life. It didn’t work out, move on. 

Yes it can be frustrating. But we can also offer our sufferings and struggles to God. We shouldn’t fall into the worldly career focused mentality that life is about a career and making money because many times we can loose our soul by going that path, but by seeing work and a career as God truly intended it, as a means and not the end. 

I will pray for you. 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 12:08:23 PM
this sounds like my son.  He is age 40.  He went through dating 23 women since age 25, and they just were no good.  And mom, me tried to help him through it.  Then I instructed him with keeping his sacraments, which is very important.  He went from stocking at a grocery store, to driving a semi for swift.  That turned out ok for awhile and Swift went very bad and mom told him look for another job.  We prayed and he found a family owned business, here in Glendale.  HE hauls very large loads of building material throughout the area of Phoenix.  He has Sundays off and the family owned business is doing well and treat their workers very well.  My son trains now and then.

Mom and Dad, we, pray for all our children.  They know it, see it lived.  I instructed our son that the single life has it's place in life with God.  And IF God wants you where he does, do it for him.  If God wants you somewhere else, He will guide you there!  And take your angel with you always as you do Our Lady who wants Her Immaculate Heart to reign.  Please them, and continue on, doing your best.

Prayers for you in these evil times.  It becomes harder to find good company and be aware of the bad, says Our Lady. Those men who thought well of Our Lady would wear or carry a blue scarf in battle.  Keep a rosary in your pocket and say many rosaries.  God Bless You!  A Mom
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 12:08:48 PM
Sorry, this post was from Songbird.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: songbird on May 28, 2019, 12:09:47 PM
Oh, my not 23 women, Ha!  3.  As my husband would say to me, "Goofy"!
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Ladislaus on May 28, 2019, 12:16:56 PM
God rarely answers a prayer by direct locution.  He uses the movements of your mind and heart to direct you.  So go in the direction that you are inclined by your own lights, and if it doesn't align with God's will, He'll close a door.  And sometimes in closing a door, something happens that opens up another one, one that you would not have found had you not tried to get in that first door.  Also, God speaks to us through our spiritual directors.  He's much more subtle in the way He responds than you seem to want or expect.

There's the St. Ignatius rule for the discernment of spirits you should apply.  If you are making a decision, for instance, and it disturbs your peace of soul, then it's likely not a movement from God.  I would look into these rules and then work with a good spiritual director to help you discern your various paths.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Ladislaus on May 28, 2019, 12:42:46 PM
So, for instance, we're currently in the process of buying a new house.  This can have very serious ramifications towards the rest of our lives, depending on who our neighbors end up being.  Where you live can have a profound impact on your life.  So my wife and I are completely trusting God.

So we look at houses based on the various material criteria we have.  There was one house that had been on the market for 192 days.  We looked at it, considered it, and were leaning toward making an offer.  Within an hour after WE visited it, they had an offer ... despite it having been on the market for 192 days.  Exact same thing has happened to us 3 other times now.  Just as we're about to make an offer, we find that it was gone.  So we're still looking.  We absolutely see God's Hand in this.  Now, our criteria for choosing a home are not, despite what I said, COMPLETELY material; that was an oversimplification.  We think about what life would be like, and how it would be conducive to the good of our souls.  So, for instance, if there's a pool in the yard next door or relatively nearby, that's an immediate disqualifier.  I don't want my kids subjected to displays of immodesty.  Proximity to church and school are important.  And we're looking for something that would be conducive to tranquility and calm.  Then we have some other criteria ... like if there are stairs, there must be a landing (my daughter fell down a long flight of stairs at a previous home we had and broke her arm), there has to be a finished basement (because we are 8 and don't want people getting annoyed and aggravated by lack of space).  There have to be at least 2.5 and preferably 3.5 bathrooms ... since our current 2 sometimes causes serious conflict.  So kindof material, kindof not.  We also look around the neighborhood and ask neighbors about it.  Are there people walking around who look like they might be bad news?  We also want for our kids to have some contact with nature, a decent-sized yard with trees, a place to have a garden, etc.  We consider this important for their spiritual welfare.

In any case, we are applying our own criteria, which we developed by the light of grace, but are essentially giving God "veto power".  So, for instance, we saw a house that we like a lot.  But on the day we were visiting, this neighbor guy happened to be sitting out on his deck without his shirt on.  We made some inquiries and found that he was out there a lot like that.  Had we visited the house at a time when he wasn't out there, we would not have noticed this.  Years ago, when we were looking at another home, the neighbors just so happened to pull up.  They came over and introduced themselves.  Turns out they were a Lesbian couple.  So God works in subtle ways .... using a subtle combination of our own lights and inclinations (which prayer helps to hone into conformity with His Will) and circuмstances that He will arrange for you.

So I would apply the same thinking with regard to a path in life.  Consider what would or would not please God.  Rule out jobs that would involve moral compromises.  Take into consideration your own personal inclinations and aptitudes.  If you're going to be miserable in a certain line of work, then it may lead to issues in your life, even your spiritual life.  So think it through, and try to make some decisions, leaving in in God's Hands.  If you trust Him, then He'll make sure you end up where He wants you.  Now, sometimes it doesn't end up as well as you expected, but know that He has a reason for everything and simply trust Him.  He'll use even our bad decisions for some good end ... even if it isn't obvious to us what that might be.  Lots of things have happened to me in my life where at the time I thought, "Why, God?" and then many, many years later I finally understood, "Oh, now I get it.  Had this not happened, then this other thing would not have happened."  But everything is really that way, except sometimes we don't find out until Eternity.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on May 28, 2019, 12:46:15 PM
And sometimes in closing a door, something happens that opens up another one, one that you would not have found had you not tried to get in that first door. 
This is me all over the place. A few of those doors that closed, to put it mildly, were very hard to take, and the doors (ones I wasn't looking for, not by any stretch of the imagination) that opened and I walked into, were at least as hard to take initially.

But it didn't take too long before I saw why I took those exact paths - it's because for me, that was the only way to get me where I needed to be, which is where I now know for certain I am supposed to be - and I wouldn't have it any other way, not for anyone or anything in this world.

With your salvation as your number one priority, do whatever it is you strive to do and go where you will make what you need to make - and keep praying your rosary, 20 decades every day if you can, that way you'll cover for those days you can only get in 5, 10 or 15 decades.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 12:47:41 PM
Oh, my not 23 women, Ha!  3.  As my husband would say to me, "Goofy"!
LOL, I wasn't going to say a thing ha ha, but thought, what the?
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Pax Vobis on May 28, 2019, 02:04:09 PM
Quote
Lots of things have happened to me in my life where at the time I thought, "Why, God?" and then many, many years later I finally understood, "Oh, now I get it.  Had this not happened, then this other thing would not have happened."  But everything is really that way, except sometimes we don't find out until Eternity.
Totally agree.
Quote
With your salvation as your number one priority, do whatever it is you strive to do and go where you will make what you need to make - and keep praying your rosary...
I think it was St Augustine who said "Love God and do what you want."  This corresponds to your point - if you put God first, He will guide you as you walk this earthly journey.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 28, 2019, 05:42:47 PM
 20 decades every day if you can, that way you'll cover for those days you can only get in 5, 10 or 15 decades.
20 decades? Do you pray the Luminous Mysteries?
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 29, 2019, 02:19:45 AM
We absolutely see God's Hand in this.  ….. 
The closer we get to God the more we see His hand in everything. I can't say how many times a day a see his hand in my work, when I figure something out, have an idea that solves everything or when I didn't take an eye out, or lose a finger in my daily home maintenance/yard/tree/car work/driving. My guardian angel has had a full time job keeping me whole.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on May 29, 2019, 06:34:53 AM
20 decades? Do you pray the Luminous Mysteries?
No, never. I will leave it at that.
Personally, I normally like to pray them in order, so I start with the Joyful mysteries, then Sorrowful, then Glorious. If I pray more decades after that, then it's whatever. For me, I have prayed only the Glorious mysteries since Easter and will do that until Ascension Thursday, then go back to praying them in order after that.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on May 29, 2019, 12:21:44 PM
No, never. I will leave it at that.
Personally, I normally like to pray them in order, so I start with the Joyful mysteries, then Sorrowful, then Glorious. If I pray more decades after that, then it's whatever. For me, I have prayed only the Glorious mysteries since Easter and will do that until Ascension Thursday, then go back to praying them in order after that.
Nice. How do you make time for it? 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on May 29, 2019, 12:43:07 PM
I usually try to say most before I get out of bed in the morning. Doesn't always work, but when it doesn't, then I often do it the Fr. Hesse way. Just listen for about 90 seconds starting at about the 6:30 mark. 

https://youtu.be/VF6jK8_Pr7I?t=4
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 03, 2019, 04:17:05 PM
I usually try to say most before I get out of bed in the morning. Doesn't always work, but when it doesn't, then I often do it the Fr. Hesse way. Just listen for about 90 seconds starting at about the 6:30 mark.  

https://youtu.be/VF6jK8_Pr7I?t=4
Before you get out of bed in the morning? You mean you pray lying down on the bed?
I've thought about praying it just like "Fr." Hesse says there, but it never felt right to me. You barely concentrate and I just think it's not that effective nor respectful.
I would not take anything Hesse said seriously, since he believed and said such outrageous things, errors and falsehoods.
You seriously can't set aside 25-60 minutes each day to pray with all your intent and devotion? Do you live by yourself?
If the Muslim infidels set aside time to pray with all their attention and devotion, someone who calls himself Catholic sure as hell should take care to do the same, at the very least.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Nadir on June 03, 2019, 05:57:52 PM
Before you get out of bed in the morning? You mean you pray lying down on the bed?
I've thought about praying it just like "Fr." Hesse says there, but it never felt right to me. You barely concentrate and I just think it's not that effective nor respectful.
I would not take anything Hesse said seriously, since he believed and said such outrageous things, errors and falsehoods.
You seriously can't set aside 25-60 minutes each day to pray with all your intent and devotion? Do you live by yourself?
If the Muslim infidels set aside time to pray with all their attention and devotion, someone who calls himself Catholic sure as hell should take care to do the same, at the very least.
Thess 5:17 Pray without ceasing! How do you know Muslim infidels pray with attention and devotion?
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on June 04, 2019, 06:13:39 AM
Before you get out of bed in the morning? You mean you pray lying down on the bed?
I've thought about praying it just like "Fr." Hesse says there, but it never felt right to me. You barely concentrate and I just think it's not that effective nor respectful.
I would not take anything Hesse said seriously, since he believed and said such outrageous things, errors and falsehoods.
You seriously can't set aside 25-60 minutes each day to pray with all your intent and devotion? Do you live by yourself?
If the Muslim infidels set aside time to pray with all their attention and devotion, someone who calls himself Catholic sure as hell should take care to do the same, at the very least.
Yours isn't, but my concentration is fine in the morning - and prayer is always good no matter the time or place. For me, I always start with my morning offering first, then rosary, it's the best possible way for me to start my day. Also, I usually set aside more than 25-60 minutes each day, but for me prayer and meditation starts when I wake up.  I don't think that most sedes like Fr. Hesse, nor do those lacking faith, but I have found him to be quite edifying, not quite as edifying as Fr. Wathen, but still a very, very good teacher who most certainly preaches the Catholic faith. It works for me.

For those who don't, praying 15 decades daily is life changing as long as you keep doing it. Hopefully the OP will take heed. I think that those who pray the 15 decades daily know what I am talking about, those who don't, can't know what I am talking about. Just do it, whether on your knees or while washing your car, pray, pray, "pray without ceasing" is what matters - there is nothing in this world easier to do than pray.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 04, 2019, 10:09:29 AM
Thess 5:17 Pray without ceasing! How do you know Muslim infidels pray with attention and devotion?
That  passage is not literal, obviously, and what I meant about Muslims is that they pray with attention and devotion according to their beliefs, not in actual fact of course. In their minds they're giving it their all and they are not ashamed of going to the side to prostrate to pray etc.; they don't do their prayers while they do something else but instead give it their full attention. 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Stubborn on June 04, 2019, 11:48:24 AM
That  passage is not literal, obviously, and what I meant about Muslims is that they pray with attention and devotion according to their beliefs, not in actual fact of course. In their minds they're giving it their all and they are not ashamed of going to the side to prostrate to pray etc.; they don't do their prayers while they do something else but instead give it their full attention.
Who says it's not literal? It most certainly is literal, obviously.

And don't bring Muslims into the mix at all, the devil requires them to pray to him that way. You never see Catholics praying like that - never, not ever - even when we have Almighty God Himself right before us in the Blessed Sacrament we don't pray the way that the sons of the devil pray to their god, and we never have and there's a very good reason for that., Why you might ask? Just look what praying that way did to the Muslims.  Get it?
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 04, 2019, 01:20:49 PM
Who says it's not literal? It most certainly is literal, obviously.
The Bible commentaries, oh but you’re a Feeneyite, so you interpret the Bible in your own way. 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Ladislaus on June 04, 2019, 02:50:00 PM
Everyone is different.  My mind is most alert and clear in the morning.  I struggle late at night.  I also really don't like saying the Rosary while driving.  Just bothers me somehow.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Pax Vobis on June 04, 2019, 03:54:07 PM
When Scripture says “pray without ceasing” that is very literal.  We know this because the saints have explained how to do it.  Praying is not always verbal or mental; it can be, as St Therese explained, doing daily tasks and out daily duty.  This was her “little way”.  
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 05, 2019, 10:56:48 AM
When Scripture says “pray without ceasing” that is very literal.  We know this because the saints have explained how to do it.  Praying is not always verbal or mental; it can be, as St Therese explained, doing daily tasks and out daily duty.  This was her “little way”.  
I don't know why Nadir brought that passage up since it has nothing to do with the issue. The issue here is the notion that "there's no time" to set aside 20-60 minutes each day to pray the Rosary exclusively and give it your full attention, so you must resort to praying the Rosary WHILE you do anything else, and hence you'll never pray it giving it your full attention. It's ridiculous and anyone who says they "have no time" to do it simply isn't making time for it.
Hesse claiming he never had time to pray with full attention just gives you an idea of the kind of person he was. 
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Ladislaus on June 05, 2019, 11:19:44 AM
Hesse claiming he never had time to pray with full attention just gives you an idea of the kind of person he was.

Yes, NOT a good sign at all.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 05, 2019, 12:21:26 PM
I don't know why Nadir brought that passage up since it has nothing to do with the issue. The issue here is the notion that "there's no time" to set aside 20-60 minutes each day to pray the Rosary exclusively and give it your full attention, so you must resort to praying the Rosary WHILE you do anything else, and hence you'll never pray it giving it your full attention. It's ridiculous and anyone who says they "have no time" to do it simply isn't making time for it.
Hesse claiming he never had time to pray with full attention just gives you an idea of the kind of person he was.
So says the guy who admires Muslim prayer. :facepalm:
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 05, 2019, 12:40:17 PM
Yes, NOT a good sign at all.
That's not what Fr. Hesse said. The anonymous poster must have learned his religion in the NO.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Nadir on June 05, 2019, 06:43:44 PM
I don't know why Nadir brought that passage up since it has nothing to do with the issue. 
I brought it up because Anon had said:

Before you get out of bed in the morning? You mean you pray lying down on the bed?

which I found to be strange and judgemental. Nothing wrong with praying in bed. We are told to pray without ceasing. I think that a pretty clear direction.

Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: poche on June 06, 2019, 12:23:56 AM
Or at least it seems to be the case with me, because I have read countless times that saints got answers to things they were asking/praying for even before they finished praying or by the time they finished.

I've also read stories here I believe, of people getting answers quickly etc.

But I have been praying for years to know something I believe to be very important, and have yet to receive an answer.

I have been wanting to know for about 7 years what to do with my life, as in, what job/career/business I should get into, because what I have been doing for the past year and a half is something temporary of its very nature and not enough to raise a family, much less save for the future/invest etc.


Could it be that God wants to purify you by not giving you the answer that you want?  



I'm 29 and male. I hate to have these thoughts, but why does God make it so hard? Why can't He give me an answer to what I have been asking for for years? Is this not important? If I knew the perfect answer to what my brother or father should do with their lives, I would not hesitate to let them know if they asked. Heck, I would let them know even if they didn't ask me at all, because I know they would probably be super grateful to know.

I absolutely hate not having a goal or not knowing what I should get into. Sure, I am learning some new things right now to get into a new industry and probably make more money, but I'm not sure I really like it and I don't know if it will pay off.

There's just too much information out there right now, and we can't be sure we will take the right decisions.

How does one even decide what to do? I would think God cares what I do for a living, so I don't really believe that it should be just about thinking what it is that you like the most and trying to pursue it and see if you make money with it. We can't see the future and we seldom have our best interests in mind, so why doesn't God let me know what I should do?

I'm not even asking for miracles or an instantaneous answer. But I would think anywhere from a week to a month would be reasonable, but seven years and no answer? I'm not getting any younger and the more time passes by, the worse things get. The less time you have to invest, buy a house, save money, raise a family, etc.

I've prayed almost the entire time for these 7 years, the Rosary in specific, and I have tried my best to live a clean, good life, but of course I have fallen and still fall often. Still, I have not given up and have been trying, but these kinds of things make me just want to throw in the towel and stop praying for good.


Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 06, 2019, 11:27:55 AM
So says the guy who admires Muslim prayer. :facepalm:
"Be thou ashamed, O Sidon, for the sea speaketh.”And if you ask why, listen to the cause: for a small gain they travel far; for eternal life many will scarcely lift a foot from the ground. They seek a petty reward, and sometimes fight shamefully in law courts for a single piece of money. They are not afraid to work day and night for a trifle or an empty promise. But, for an unchanging good, for a reward beyond estimate, for the greatest honor and for glory everlasting, it must be said to their shame that men begrudge even the least fatigue. Be ashamed, then, lazy and complaining servant, that they should be found more eager for perdition than you are for life, that they rejoice more in vanity than you in truth."

Is this passage here admiring sinners when it takes note of the fact that they work hard?
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 20, 2019, 09:27:08 AM
Who says it's not literal? It most certainly is literal, obviously.

And don't bring Muslims into the mix at all, the devil requires them to pray to him that way. You never see Catholics praying like that - never, not ever - even when we have Almighty God Himself right before us in the Blessed Sacrament we don't pray the way that the sons of the devil pray to their god, and we never have and there's a very good reason for that., Why you might ask? Just look what praying that way did to the Muslims.  Get it?
Catholics DO pray that way... In Lent, the Byzantines prostrate
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: Änσnymσus on June 20, 2019, 11:07:27 AM
Catholics DO pray that way... In Lent, the Byzantines prostrate

Not often.  It's not a regular prayer posture.
Title: Re: Why doesn't God answer right away when you need to know something important?
Post by: StCeciliasGirl on June 24, 2019, 10:13:03 PM
I've prayed almost the entire time for these 7 years, the Rosary in specific, and I have tried my best to live a clean, good life, but of course I have fallen and still fall often. Still, I have not given up and have been trying, but these kinds of things make me just want to throw in the towel and stop praying for good.
Well, that's why your prayer hasn't been answered. Somewhere it says you shall not put the LORD your God to the test? Also, there's being content in all things, and seeking God with all your heart &c. Isn't it more important to put the heavenly things (praying, attending Mass, helping others and so forth) first, and then trust that God will add the rest to you? Seven years: can't hurt to give it a try, right?

I'd most humbly suggest that you grab a job or career and be content in it as much as possible, and devote your life otherwise to the Church (which seriously needs devout men) and prayer, always thanking God for our blessings, and praying for others in all their calamities. God will provide the rest when you do that. You may have many blessings already but simply can't see them!

This is good start, too (and just do one or two a day for starters if you want; great habit!): http://divinumofficium.com/