Are you next going to say that it's wrong to eat pork? This smells of OT-law-literalism to me, big time, pretending that some ritual law of the OT (Book of Leviticus) remains in force, where it's OK to wear earrings as long as the skin isn't pierced.
No, I actually lean the other direction and have no problem seeing tasteful nose piercings or tattoos. I don't personally have any of the above, but I don't find them repulsive.
My issue was with the lack of consistency in many people saying that earrings are fine but other piercings are not. How does that make any logical sense? If we're going to exalt or condemn something, I'm looking for something a little more solid than "it's customary" or "I don't like how that looks".