Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: What’s the biggest age difference you’ve personally seen in a marriage?  (Read 4060 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

The last three posts were by me Last Tradhican

Änσnymσus

  • Guest
Nonsense!

A 15 year old female is a woman not a child.

St Elizabeth of Hungary married at 14 to Louis, Landgrave of Thuringia, and it was a particularly happy marriage. Was this a case of rape?
That was in the 13th century. 15 year olds are children, and people marry for far different reasons than 800 years ago.

If I were a priest, and someone approached me about marrying a barely pubescent girl of 14 years, I would say no. Absolutely not. Even if there were a loaded gun to my head.


Broadly speaking, there is the expectation in today's society that voluntary marriage (i.e., marriage where the girl is not pregnant) will only take place after both partners have completed what is foreseen to be their terminal education or vocational training.  When a girl gets married at 18 or below, it is generally a concession by her that she will never do anything other than be a housewife and mother (which is the noblest of vocations for a laywoman), or some kind of menial job in retail or food service.  A boy who marries below the age of 21 or 22, unless he has some kind of potentially lucrative vocational training (plumber, welder, electrician, etc.), is conceding that he will never be able to support a larger family, and might well consider deferring marriage until he is better established in life, assuming that ever happens.  Our society basically treats anyone under 30 as a de facto minor whose life is devoted either to serious career development on the one hand, or pursuit of endless fun and "having one's space and freedom" while they "find themselves", on the other hand.  The military would be an exception to this.


One thing I think also needs to be brought up, is that both males and females (especially the latter) mature physically so much earlier than in times past, yet they are treated (in this regard) as children for many years, years during which they are physically mature, yet generally speaking, unsuited for marriage otherwise.  This is dangerous to purity --- they are surely physically equipped for marriage, and have all the accompanying desires, yet cannot act on them without committing the sin of fornication.  To remain chaste and virginal for over a decade, when desires are at their peak, requires heroic virtue and self-denial.

That was in the 13th century. 15 year olds are children, and people marry for far different reasons than 800 years ago.

Only because our society, and the Church, has been corrupted. Children today are generally raised in such a a way to permanently damage them and render them incapable of maturing. One only has to open one's eyes and look around you to see the reality of the situation. A normal mature young adult is generally regarded as an aberration and is certainly not the norm.
When I ask a "friend" if her young (adult) daughter was getting married, I got the answer, "Oh, she's too young for that!" Meanwhile she had been copulating for some time. This seems to be the norm.

So, 13th century or not, St Elizabeth's was a case of a happy marriage at 14. We have a sick and unnatural society today. Hers is not an exceptional case.

Änσnymσus

  • Guest
Nonsense!

A 15 year old female is a woman not a child.

St Elizabeth of Hungary married at 14 to Louis, Landgrave of Thuringia, and it was a particularly happy mrriage. Was this a case of rape?
What makes the present day 15 year old a woman?
1.  she is physically finished growing?            NO
2.  she has mental maturity?                         NO
3.  she has experience in anything?               NO
4.  she has knowledge of anything?                NO
5.  she has reached puberty?                         YES
So just because she can have children that makes her a woman?  What about the girls who are now reaching puberty at six and eight years old?   Not only that but getting pregnant at six and eight years old, does that make them a woman?