The only thing you will teach an adult human being of either sex to do by striking them is to fear and hate you.

you have been drinking too much jew cool-aid

Nope.  This needed to be corrected ... along with all the other bogus information on this thread that can do harm.  Not every act of disrespect is a mortal sin.  This response of mine was made almost immediately after Jaynek posted it, so at the time nobody had "already agreed to that".  So you're full of it.

I already made clear, that disobedience is relative to it's object. And therefore is not always mortal.

This is ESPECIALLY true when one strikes a woman.  If a MAN, say a soldier, is disciplined by his drill sergeant, a man can even respect that on a certain level.  Women, on the other hand, take stuff like that very personally.

Modern women who do not want to learn and become better Catholics. Those women burn in hell. Praise be God for creating such a place.

Modern women who do not want to learn and become better Catholics. Those women burn in hell. Praise be God for creating such a place.

So, according to you, women who do not want to "become better Catholics" burn in hell?  Nonsense.  In many cases, it just may mean a long stay in Purgatory.  And now you're relishing the fact that they might burn in hell?  You're an incredibly warped individual.  No wonder you're afraid to reveal yourself.  You know that most people would recoil in horror.

So, explain again why you're too cowardly to reveal yourself but insist on posting anonymously?  If you believe in your opinion, you should man up and take ownership of it.

Total distraction from the issue.

Thats the tactic of evil women. Very very sad to see a man act like that.

I studied moral theology in seminary.  Have never seen it.  Cite references.  Otherwise, you're probably just a liar making this up to promote your own agenda.

You have seen the moral theology book that I cited in this thread.  It is very very likely that if the one I found said it was permissible, then other such books also said it.  There is no reason whatsoever to think a person who claims to have seen this in moral theology books is lying.
You really diminish your own credibility when you make comments like this.  

You have seen the moral theology book that I cited in this thread.  It is very very likely that if the one I found said it was permissible, then other such books also said it.  There is no reason whatsoever to think a person who claims to have seen this in moral theology books is lying.
You really diminish your own credibility when you make comments like this. 

Thank you Jaynek.


To everyone else out there, this is how a man should treat a women when she is good. Praise her, because she is doing something courageous especially against other women.

Scripture speaks about how much a good wife is worth.

But lets also remember that Jaynek and the other women coul d commit a mortal sin at any time. Just as I could fall into hell if I got any ideas about pretty girls in the office.

Accepting Church teaching does not make us saints.

Refusing it will not get you  anywhere near sanctity however.