Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
As far as I know, there are no magisterial docuмents specifically addressing the question of the corporal punishment of wives, either for or against. However, there are countless references to the husband's authority over his wife. It is the nature of authority that it may be enforced and, for many centuries, Christians understood that this enforcement could involve corporal punishment (within reasonable limits).Earlier in this thread, we saw a passage cited from St. Thomas Aquinas about a specific instance in which corporal punishment of a wife by her husband is appropriate. While this falls short of being magisterial, St. Thomas almost always represents the mind of the Church.
More sophistry and bad use of Rhetoric. You're hitting about 900 with that "charity" bat though....
I am married. My wedding was in 1980. I have 7 children and 8 grandchildren. Also I am a woman.I suggest that people not assume that the only men accept that Church teaching involved the concept of a husband using corporal punishment on his wife.
Yeah you're full of crap. DISHONEST. Sophist.
Right. Because someone disagrees with your view, then obviously they are to be suspected of bad will or guile. Do you beat your wife?
Have you not taken your meds today?
"What if the woman was raped?!!!!!! What if it was your wife, mother, or daughter?!!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!!"DZP
I would propose that people discuss this topic logically, but that is probably too much to ask for. The quoted comment, for example, does not follow from what I said and is an obvious logical fallacy.
1. What, exactly, is my view?2. Regardless of what it is, if she were you, then likely yes.
That may explain why you have been married and divorced, what, twice, is that right?
Enough with the white-knighting already.
You're are not supposed to be arguing with men. It's up to us men to decide whether or not we're allowed to beat you. So keep silent, woman.
"What if the woman was raped?!!!!!! What if it was your wife, mother, or daughter?!!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!!"
This is an irrelevant appeal to emotion.