Jayne, do you know of the abuses of women during those times? About women being thrown about in sheets during labor? About twilight births? Or when women would be tied down to tables to keep from moving? It was when men started attended those stopped. It also helped that women found their voices to speak up because their husbands were there. You talk about those times like they are ideal, but those are also times when women were hurt the most.
The twilight births and being tied down were practices of the time immediately before husbands began attending births. I have already identified the 50s as being a time of horrible birthing practices. I even said it twice. But these have nothing to do with the women-only births that I consider the ideal.
Yes, it was helpful for men to attend births in order to stop the awful hospital procedures going on. It is still sometimes necessary for men to be present to protect their wife from the hospitals. But this does not make men attending childbirth the ideal. It is something needed to deal with a disordered situation.
This is what I think is the ideal: The woman goes through labour and delivery in a home-like, comfortable, quiet room with one or two trained female attendants. There are medical services immediately available nearby in case of emergencies. The husband is also nearby and perhaps visits with her a bit in the earlier stages of labour depending on how she is handling it. As soon as the baby is born (assuming he does not require medical attention) the father joins mother and child while she breastfeeds the baby for the first time. The parents and baby are allowed to bond for a while. Mother and baby get cleaned up a bit and dressed. The father may need some attention too if it has been a long labour. At this point, any older children from the family can come to greet the new sibling, if practical (depending on what time of day it is, etc.) There should be an adult other than the parents in charge of the older children at this time. This could be a good time for a snack with the whole family if the mother has not eaten earlier. The mother spends the next two weeks resting, looking after her personal needs, and feeding the baby, while others look after her usual duties.