God is a perfectly simple being. He does not vary, as do human beings, from being just one moment and then merciful the next. Every act of His is at the same time both perfectly just and perfectly merciful. Flabius ignores the part about mercy, because he has none. Flabius, you should be very afraid for your soul, since, as Our Lord taught, with whatever measure you judge others, so too will you be judged. Show mercy, and you will be shown mercy. Please meditate on the corollary to this.
In any case, as I said, every act of God is both at the same time perfectly just AND perfectly merciful. He may in fact withhold graces when He knows they will be rejected, and in this way the souls is spared the additional punishment for having rejected the grace.
Catholic predestination, however, works within the bounds of free will. At no point is the will fixed toward the end, and it is in fact more in line with foreknowledge than it is with any curtailment of free will ... so not the Jansenist view held by Flabius.