I have no desire to argue with anyone. I asked my father about legwear as it was in his childhood. He was born in 1925 in New York City. Do the math. Acording to Dad, who does NOT suffer from dementia, it was universal custom for little boys up until about age 2, to wear gowns. This allowed for ease and modesty of diaper changes and early potty training. No boy ever admitted to remembering wearing a gown! From age 2 on up to about 7 or 8, long shorts and knee socks were worn in hot weather and knickers with argyle knee socks the rest of the time. By about 10, shorts were worn only for things like hiking or Boy Scout Camp. It was a hallmark of entering manhood to wear long pants full time. My Dad recalls the knickers vanishing between grades 7 and 8. No boy would be caught dead in knickers or shorts in high school unless it was to play team sports. And even then, they were baggy, not form-fitting like today's spandex.
I don't see any older boys or men wearing shorts in the sspx school picture. If anything, the boys have less leg showing than the girls. And remember, it is a school in Florida, not Minnesota! The shorts are not form fitting. Personally, I think many trads. are Puritanical. I'd be much more concerned over the doctrine my child will be taught at the school than over little boys in long, loose shorts!
Could a case not be made over the length of the girls' sleeves? Mary-like standards call for long sleeves, or at least no shorter than half way up the forearm to the elbow. Pope Pius XI conceded half way to the elbow on the upper arm "due to market conditions." How many SSPX chapels and schools enforce the more modest of the two?
And shouldn't every child have his or her top buttoned to the neck?
I teach in a private school K-8, that requires modest uniforms. Boys through grade 2 (age 7-8), are permitted to wear the same type of shorts if the temperature is 70° F or above. Unlike the sspx school, Polo shirts aren't allowed except for P.E. All boys wear a light blue long or short sleeve dress shirt and tie on top. Grades 6-8 must wear or have with them a suit jacket. Younger boys may wear a suit jacket or cardigan. Girls up through grade 2 wear a green, blue, gray plaid jumper with a blue long or short sleeve blouse, a Navy beret, and navy criss-cross neck tie. After grade 2 they exchange the jumper for a pleated skirt with button-up vest. Boys wear a Navy sweatsuit with Polo shirt and black, blue, or white sneakers for p.e. Girls wear navy clothes, white knee socks, Polo shirt, and zip-up navy fleece jacket, + same choice in sneakers. There are two styles of dress shoes for boys, three styles for girls. There is an optional school hooded wind-breaker for all. Teachers don't have a uniform, per se, but we do follow a set dress code. My personal opinion? We're an exceptionally well-dressed school.