.
What an idiotic response. This was a competition. They were each trying to make more money than the other, get it? The S&P fund returned 125.8%; the hedge fund returned 36%. Losing a game 126 to 36 is called getting your ass kicked.
.
I'm sorry to lose my manners like this. Unfortunately I can't remove this because it's in the Anonymous section.
Anyway, the question is not "Which form of investment is better -- savings account or stock market?" The question is: "Which form of stock investing is better -- hedge funds/active investing or index funds?"
If this were a game, the index funds would have won with a score of 126 to 36. If you don't consider that a resounding victory for index funds, well, okay, but those were the results.